Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >
Jul 5, 2006 02:35 PM

Save me from ever going to Blue Smoke again...

Kansas City ribs were dessicated and tasted reheated. St. Louis were merely serviceable. Is Daisy May the current mecca for BBQ?
Any help would be appreciated....

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Personally, I don't like Daisy Mae's very much. Have you tried Dinosaur or R.U.B.? There have been tons of posts on both places, so if you do a search you can find lots of opinions and suggestions re: what to order.

    4 Replies
    1. re: parkslopemama

      I second that. Daisy Mae's was an enormous let down. Ribs were tough and dry. Do they not have sauce? I know its about the meat, but when I asked for BBQ sauce, I was given some red-hot concoction that really didnt work at all with the ribs (Memphis Rub). The only solid thing was the rib-tip baked beans. Everything else that I have had there has been less than satisfactory. As to Blue Smoke, like all Danny Meyer clap-traps, if anything is even a bit out of place, send it back! Demand satisfaction, like a short, white-suited, side-armed, proper Southern gentleman! It will be made right.

      1. re: noodles

        In all fairness to Daisy May's, Authentic Memphis Dry Rub ribs are supposed to be dry... if you like the wet ribs, you should order a different kind. (Not saying you have to like it, but that's the way it's supposed to be...)

        1. re: zGustibus

          Dry-rub is a far cry from dried out MEAT. Sorry, inexcusable, regardless of whether or not I like some sauce on the ribs or not. Dry BBQ is no good.

          1. re: noodles

            You are definetely right about that... point taken. I was just saying I'm not surprised the wet sauce they gave you didn't mesh well with the dry rub. I had the same ribs at Daisy May's a few months ago and they were delicious- almost as good as ribs I have had in Memphis... sorry you had a bad experience!

    2. Depends on what you like... I could see people not liking the location and/or atmosphere. And the pulled pork sandwich is a little too sweet for my taste. But if you like Dry Rub Memphis style pork ribs- I can vouch for the ones at Daisy May's. They are the real deal. Almost as good as the ones I had in Memphis...

      1. the best place is Waterfront Ale House (corner of 30th n 2nd)... although it may look like crud from the outside, the food is outstanding and reasonable priced.

        6 Replies
          1. re: Blumie

            The brisket sandwich is always good, and sometimes fantastic. They serve a good pulled pork sandwich. Never tried the ribs, but they make their own BBQ sauce and it is tasty.

            1. re: Scott V

              I have seen Waterfront before. You mention barbecue sauce--is that the only kind of pulled pork they do? I am desperate to find a proper Carolina barbecue.

              1. re: dbird

                I've never been to the Waterfront Ale House in Manhattan but am a regular at the original on Atlantic Ave in Bklyn (same owners and some of the same staff). I eat the pulled pork regularly and it is not bbq sauced, at least not heavily. Try it and let us know what you think. I love the stuff but have no frame of reference for comparison to Carolina. Thanks.

            2. re: Blumie

              W.A.E. doesn't serve authentic barbecue (and doesn't pretend to). The chef loves barbecue, though, and has wide latitude over the specials he serves -- the food is much more interesting than you'd ever expect from a neighborhood bar. Nice little grace notes like the chipotle ranch dressing, game burgers (I particularly like the ostrich). I don't think of the "barbecue" as being one of the highlights of the menu, but it's certainly edible.

              1. re: Dave Feldman

                The cue at both Alehouses is prepared in Brooklyn over Hickory on a Southern Pride pit smoker

          2. I personally love the Dinosaur!

            1. The original comment has been removed