Moving out, so I'll give up my spots.
Pio Maya- very good, cheapish mexican. a board favorite. go for the chorizo.
Mexicana Mama Central- expensive, new/quirky mexican. sweet potatoes in the burritos. also very good.
Il Corrallo (spelling may be off)- cheapish, a million different kinds of pretty good pasta.
Lombardi's/Arturo's: Take your pick. Good, traditional, famous pizza places that have been around forever. More expensive than Domino's, but worth it.
Grand Sichuan- Very good, very spicy chinese food. Don't bother with the American Chinese section.
Galanga- Pretty good, fairly cheap classed-up Thai.
Silver Spurs- good drunk food.
Walk to Grey Dog, don't get it delivered. Abbondanza has fallen off but it's still decent.
Anyone else? This is one of those lists that makes the rounds every couple of months.
All depends on what you're in the mood for. In the 2 years I lived down here and now 2 that I have been in school without living down here, I've often ordered from the following:
grey dog cafe
republic (only takes about 10 minutes, which is awesome)
Abbondanza's and Hummus Place are two of the more recent ones I've added to my list, but I usually go to them as opposed to getting delivery.