Log In / Sign Up
HOME > Chowhound > Greater Boston Area >
a
amatto Jun 21, 2006 12:41 PM

Beacon St. Tavern

Walking by this morning, I saw a sign on the Beacon
St. Tavern (Brookline, on Beacon St around the St.
Mary's area) that it'd be open at 5pm today. Just fyi.

(this is opened by the same guy/people who run the
Washington Square Tavern)

  1. n
    nomadfromcincy Jul 5, 2006 02:06 PM

    Had dinner at BST last night.

    Comments in order of importance:
    1) The wine list is superb. Along the lines of the Franklin Cafe, Silvertone, and Washington Square Tavern... but even better. If you are into wine, you must check this place out.
    2) There are still service kinks to work out. I think it would help if Gerry hired a very professional front-of-house person to manage the crowds that are sure to come. He is a great host and very wine knowledgeable -- he should focus. I am sure he is just trying to get the ship in order, so I withhold any judgments.
    3) The food was 90% there. Highlights were the eggplant napoleon, lobster chowder, quail appetizer, and goat cheese appetizer. The carpaccio and sirloin were serviceable. The steak tips I would not order again... but I was eating with someone who had already tried the steak tips twice before and declared mine were not up to par... next time, I will either order the eggplant or try the burger.
    4) Did I mention the wine?

    Good luck to them.

    1. l
      localchemist Jul 4, 2006 03:59 AM

      Beacon St. Tavern may have an excellent chef and owner, but my wife and I wouldn’t know.

      As Brookline residents, we have eaten at WST. As a Beacon St. commuter, I have been interested in BST, literally, since Via Via “left the building.”

      On July 3rd, my wife and I decided to go check out the fare. We arrived at 7:30, and it was crowed. The front man said, “20 minutes.” No problem. We could wait...and we did.

      As we sat near the bar, several groups left, including several couples, and a four top or two. As I type, it was mostly two tops leaving. The couple who signed in before us asked about their “status”. One of the four tops that left actually returned, had some words with the front man, and waited at the bar. A seven top was seated, requiring 3 tables for 2 tops to be combined.

      Around 8:45, there were a couple of make or break moments, do or die, be seated or leave, you know, a couple has to make a choice.

      That four top, the one that left, and later returned, actually was seated outside on a four top (which could easily be ‘adapted’ to seat two) around 8:45. The couple that arrived immediately before us was seated...we were next...right? No. Not the case. A couple that came in 30 minutes after us was seated in, oh, a 4 top booth. Nice.

      Wow, that was it.

      First, find a better way to keep track of names and numbers in each party (chronological order would be a plus). Second, if you want BST to be a “couples” destination, DON’T leave your tables configured as 4 tops when 80% of the queue is 2 tops, and the last 4 top was just seated.

      Needless to say, my wife and I left at 9, and we bid adieu to the front man. Get straight, seriously...Hosanyi had a nice stay at the St. Mary’s T-stop, too!

      1. j
        jonathan Jun 21, 2006 08:47 PM

        Yes. It is owned by Gerry Finnegan.

        4 Replies
        1. re: jonathan
          p
          POINT KID Jun 22, 2006 09:24 AM

          HAD DINNER LAST NIGHT HAD A STEAK THAT WAS AS TENDER AS ANYTHING I HAVE HAD AT ANY OF THE BIG NAME STEAK HOUSES IN BOSTON, I HOPE THEY WILL HAVE THE SAME BURGER AS WASHINGTON SQUARE. THEY TOLD ME PATIO WOULD OPEN FOR FOOD THIS WEEKEND. BROOKLINE HAS A NEW JEWEL.

          1. re: POINT KID
            l
            lissa Jun 23, 2006 02:28 AM

            Went last night for dinner (first night open) and tonight for a drink. Amazingly tasty and tender food... great atmosphere - it is a great place for something more neighborhood-bar-like in the area; hoping for the best!

            1. re: POINT KID
              l
              lissa Jun 23, 2006 02:29 AM

              Went last night for dinner (first night open) and tonight for a drink. Amazingly tasty and tender food... great atmosphere - it is a great place for something more neighborhood-bar-like in the area; hoping for the best!

              1. re: POINT KID
                l
                lissa Jun 23, 2006 02:29 AM

                Went last night for dinner (first night open) and tonight for a drink. Amazingly tasty and tender food... great atmosphere - it is a great place for something more neighborhood-bar-like in the area; hoping for the best!

            Share with your friendsX