After walking past a Graffeo store earlier in the day and not scoring some dark roast beans, I know - DUMB - I ended up at Costco for some overpriced gas and bought a bag of their in house roasted (not the Charbuks) French Roast. Made it in the Bodum French Press. It is the worst, most highly over roasted ie. CREAMATED coffee that I've ever tasted! I wasn't expecting Blue Bottle or Graffeo but this stuff is awful.
I was wondering what other Hounds have experienced? Did I get a bad batch or is it always this bad?
I bought the Kirkland (roasted by Starbucks) whole bean and agree it is quite oily and patience is needed when grinding. I also found that the depth of flavor was less than other dark roasts so I needed to increase the coffee per cup in my maker. Once the ratio was figured out I have enjoyed.
Their Seattle Mountain in-store roasted house blend in Austin, TX is second only to Peets to me. I have ordered coffee from all the top-rated places and it just can't hardly be beat. It was substantially better before the Tsunami, but it is still better than most.
I haven't been as happy with the other types. However, all have been head and shoulders above Starbucks or supermarket coffees.
It is also incredibly cheap. A two pound bag is like 6-7 dollars I think. It is so good that my Dad mails my two sisters and I bags frequently. Maybe Austin just has a really good roaster.
I have found that lately I don't like any french roast. Most brands seem to over roast, so I've been buying a Hawaiian or Jamaican blend that I buy at Sams. Can you take it back? I know most stores do stand behind their products. The worst that can happen is you use it to cradle around a candle--that is if you like the smell of coffee.
At my local Costco, the Kirkland brand coffee packaging says it is roasted by Starbucks. They also carry a locally roasted (and far less expensive) house blend; it's not very good. I stopped buying the Kirkland brand because it was too oily and kept clogging my grinder.
Is the gas at your Costco "overpriced" relative to other gas in your area? At mine, it's about 10 cents a gallon less than at other gas stations in the area. But it is all overpriced these days.