HOME > Chowhound > General Topics >


Best Mail Order Fudge for Holidays????

  • c

I would like to find the BEST, REAL, fudge for gifts this year.

When I was a kid in Laguna Beach, there was a tiny shop run by a couple who made ONLY fudge and toffee. The tiny place barely had room to turn around, and was dominated by a massive gleaming copper kettle. The walls were covered with the names of towns they had shipped their lovingly made product to.

Please help me find a similar product, it must exist out there!

By real I mean the kind that is made with just cocoa,sugar and butter, ( walnuts ok but NOTHING else) cooked in a big copper pot and creamed on a slab of marble.

Please none of those mix in, peanut butter, marshmallow,what ever type specialty fudges...
just the real deal....

possibly made by Nuns or in a little shop in Wisconsin peninsula, or any other establishment that has been around forever and remembers how real fudge is made...

Thanks !!!!!!!!!!!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. The Brigittine monks from Amity, Oregon make absolutely delicious fudge. Here's the link:

    Link: http://www.brigittine.org/fudge.html

    1. This is the best stuff I've ever tasted (fudge-wise) and I come from a land where fudge is a huge commodity (Northern Michigan). The caramels are amazing too.

      Link: http://www.howsescandy.com/

      1. I love the fudge from Murdicks though I can only attest to eating direct from the shops on the Vineyard. The traditional chocolate fudge is wonderful very rich and true chocolate flavor. I think their penuche is some of the best I have ever had. The cap cod cranberry is good for what it is. My husband loves their peanut butter fudge but I find it sandy and a bit dry.

        The link takes you to Vineyard site but if you click on their homepage you can link to the one on Mackinac Island,MI

        Link: http://www.murdicks.com/index.htm

        1. You might try the Fudge Fatale from Chocosphere.com (linked below).

          Link: http://www.chocosphere.com/Html/Produ...

          1. Thank you for the great suggestions....will have to order some of each for a taste *test* before subjecting my giftees...yumm

            1. Allenfamilyfudge.com great fudge, made the old fashioned way

              5 Replies
                1. re: chefj

                  Not that I am aware of. But they do ship anywhere in the continental United States. Using the postal service - we don't have drones available for delivery.

                2. re: brothersj59

                  brothersj59, have you yourself tried the Allen Family fudge?
                  If so, which flavors did you try and what do you recommend?

                  1. re: liu

                    I have tried their fudge. I'm a chocolate lover so the chocolate walnut, and dark chocolate are my favs. But others in my family love the Maple Pecan and the Peanut Butter.

                    1. re: brothersj59

                      Thanks! I will order it for my mother's 95th! She likes fudge.

                3. This inquiry about mail-order fudge has been updated: