HOME > Chowhound > General Topics >

Pet peeve--corned beef

Alan H Apr 26, 2002 08:37 AM

Just curious, why do so many people call it "corn" beef, not "corned" beef??

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. c
    Chris VR RE: Alan H Apr 26, 2002 08:49 AM

    For the same reason that many people call it "ice tea" and not "iced tea."

    1. s
      saucyknave RE: Alan H Apr 26, 2002 11:50 AM

      I don't care what they call it. Now that they've taken most of the fat out of it, I don't order it anymore.

      1. m
        Molly Symmonds RE: Alan H Apr 26, 2002 12:18 PM

        Seems to me that people don't realize that "corned" refers to the method of preparation. Few people know that, according to my New Oxford American Dictionary (forgive the plug!), "corned" means "preserved in salt." Consider pickled cucumbers: no one says "Pass the pickleds." Verbal shorthand, and it makes sense for speakers to think of one common foodstuff - corn - when talking about another - beef.


        9 Replies
        1. re: Molly Symmonds
          Dan RE: Molly Symmonds Apr 26, 2002 02:11 PM

          ...and the grains of salt used for corning beef are about the size of... kernels of corn!

          (my plug for food lover's companion)

          1. re: Dan
            Molly Symmonds RE: Dan Apr 26, 2002 02:35 PM

            I really need to keep an OC to Food at my desk, because I didn't know that nifty 'niblet' about salt.
            Thanks, Dan.

            1. re: Molly Symmonds
              Sweet Willie RE: Molly Symmonds Apr 26, 2002 03:52 PM

              Dans explanation is the one I've heard.

              "...and the grains of salt used for corning beef are about the size of... kernels of corn!"

              1. re: Sweet Willie
                Alan H RE: Sweet Willie Apr 26, 2002 04:40 PM

                Still, it is CORNED. We don't call it smoke salmon, it is smoked salmon; we don't call it boil eggs, it is boiled eggs. Corning is the method and is referred to in the past tense. Oh well, probably the same people who say "I could care less".

                1. re: Alan H
                  saucyknave RE: Alan H Apr 26, 2002 07:19 PM

                  This process of altering words over time by dropping bits has a philological designation: clipping. So think of it as a venerable quality of language, a kind of evaporation of sound, like water boiling away in the pot. Now, doesn't that make you feel better?

                  1. re: Alan H
                    Lindsay B. RE: Alan H Apr 26, 2002 08:18 PM

                    It goes both ways in standard English. We refer to popcorn, instead of popped corn. Or roast beef, instead of roasted beef. Hash browns, not hashed browns. A french fry instead of a french fried, though we sometimes say "french fried potato"

                    As far as "could care less" vs. "couldn't care less" dispute, I'm don't understand why grammarians are always griping about it. The former is sarcastic, not illogical.

                    Intellectually I'm for descriptive rather than prescriptive linguistics. But it's not as if I don't have my share of pet linguistic peeves, like "data" being plural.

                    1. re: Lindsay B.
                      saucyknave RE: Lindsay B. Apr 26, 2002 09:17 PM

                      I could care less when a sentence ends with a preposition. But, alas, I still care when, between you and I, there's confusion.

                      1. re: saucyknave
                        ironmom RE: saucyknave Apr 26, 2002 09:57 PM

                        Yeah, there's so many confusing things going on nowadays, for somebody to understand their situation properly, is a whole nother thing.

              2. re: Dan
                ironmom RE: Dan Apr 26, 2002 06:42 PM

                corn v. 1. To granulate or form into small grains. 2.a. To preserve and season with granulated salt. 2.b. To preserve in brine. (American Heritage Dictionary)

                When the British say "corn", they are referring to any grain, such as wheat, rye, etc. When they mean corn, they say "maize". Was the book written by an American or a Britisher?

            2. s
              sooth RE: Alan H Apr 28, 2002 06:55 AM

              it seems that "corned beef" and "corn beef" almost sound alike that maybe people are slurring the pronounciation of the former leaving the "-ed" silent; also, it seems saying "corn beef" is faster than saying "corned beef". i dunno.

              Show Hidden Posts