HOME > Chowhound > General Topics >

What's the difference? Crisp vs. crumble

k
Katerina Nov 5, 2001 11:02 AM

I have never been able to figure out what the difference is between a crisp and a crumble. (I want to make something with fruit at the bottom and (crumbly) pastry on top - but what is it called?) Please illuminate me. Thanks!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. t
    Tom Meg RE: Katerina Nov 5, 2001 11:42 AM

    My understanding is that a crumble's pastry is essentially butter, flour, and sugar, all crumbled up and sprinkled on top, whereas a crisp's topping is more granola-like, and can include stuff like rolled oats, coconut flakes, nuts, etc.

    A cobbler is basically fruit baked under a thick pie crust, differing from a pie only in its lack of bottom crust.

    2 Replies
    1. re: Tom Meg
      p
      Pat Goldberg RE: Tom Meg Nov 5, 2001 02:22 PM

      I don't think this is accurate. One of my favorite crisp recipes, from a New England cookbook, calls for a topping made from 1 cup flour, 1 cup sugar, 1 egg, and a bit of baking powder. This is mixed together, first with a fork and later with fingers until it is mealy. It is patted over unsweetened fruit, such as apples, to cover the fruit. Then some melted butter is spread over the top. A sprinkle of cinnamon is optional. A 375 degree oven for 40 minutes or so does the trick. It can even be made early in the day and reheated after the main course comes out of the oven.

      I suspect that lots of these names are regional names, and really have little to do with the details of how the dessert is constructed.

      1. re: Pat Goldberg
        t
        Tom Meg RE: Pat Goldberg Nov 5, 2001 04:47 PM

        I checked my crumble definition in the Oxford Companion to Food, which on the whole is very Anglo-centric, so I don't doubt that there must be tons of regional variation with these things. Your crisp sounds delicious.

    2. j
      Janet A. Zimmerman RE: Katerina Nov 5, 2001 12:25 PM

      According to Pam Anderson in "The Perfect Recipe," for a crisp the fruit is topped with a mixture of butter, sugar, flour and nuts; a crumble is the same but has oatmeal added to the topping. A betty is topped with buttered bread crumbs, and usually has layers of crumbs in between fruit layers. Also, in a cobbler the fruit is covered with a biscuit dough and baked until golden brown; same with a grunt, except the dish is covered so the topping steams rather than bakes. A buckle is topped with a cake-type batter and baked. Who knew there could be so many variations?

      1 Reply
      1. re: Janet A. Zimmerman
        k
        Katerina RE: Janet A. Zimmerman Nov 5, 2001 12:47 PM

        Wow!!! Thanks for the encyclopaedic response. I guess I'll make a crumble then, although the cobbler sounds tempting too.

      Show Hidden Posts