Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >
Nov 22, 2005 09:55 PM

Golden syrup???? need reponse quickly

  • f

I was all ready to make pecan pies but then saw recipes for golden syrup. I am clueless--always used corn syrup.

Is it sold in most supermarkets and is there a particular brand or name i should ask for?


  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
    1. re: Candy

      Is that the brand of golden syrup?

      Can i find it in a supermarket or does it have to be a specialty store?

      1. re: frogmore

        I'm in central Texas. Wal-Mart supercenters and some big grocery stores around here have Steen's cane syrup. Lyle's golden syrup is much harder to find.


      2. re: Candy

        Lyle's Golden Syrup is a British brand made from cane sugar. Karo on the other hand is from corn. Karo is pretty bland, while Lyle's has flavor (in the same sense that maple has flovor - though more buttery). Lyle's also more expensive. An import shop like Cost Plus should carry it, as well as a well stocked grocery.

        Most pecan pies use the corn syrup. Still it would be interesting to experiment with golden syrup, though for a start I'd only make a partial substitution.

        I hadn't heard of golden syrup until a recipe for ANZAC biscuits caught my eye (which only use a 1 Tsp of Lyle's along with a cup of sugar).

        1. re: paulj

          Try golden syrup only if you aren't satisfied with the flavor of corn syrup in the standard modern recipe. When the call goes out for *best pecan pie*, I assume we're looking for ultimate deliciousness (highly subjective, of course), and this recipe comes up. It's simply an adjustment to get back to the original characteristics of the pie's filling-before corn syrup swept the nation; a desire for a more nuanced sweetness.

          John Thorne has already done the homework on substituting golden syrup for corn syrup, check out his recipe (Athena's post) and book for more info.

      3. dark karo oil can be substituted or dark corn oil,

        1. I think you'd be just fine sticking with your corn syrup.
          But I used to use half honey and that was wonderful...

          1. p
            Professor Salt

            This is Lyle's Golden Syrup, from England. It's got a wonderfully caramelly flavor. It's very viscous, much more so than corn syrup, and slightly stiffer than honey.

            Golden syrup is an invert cane syrup that's been partly caramelized. In a pinch, you can substitute dark or light corn syrup (which is also an invert sugar), but you won't get the same flavor.

            Someone else suggested Steen's, which is a US brand. If you can find it, that'd be better than corn syrup. I've also tried a Southern brand called Cane Patch cane syrup, but turns out that was just a corn syrup flavored with molasses, and thus the same as dark Karo.



            3 Replies
            1. re: Professor Salt

              Interesting. I bought some Lyle's at an import grocer near me, and it came in a tin with the sort of lid that used to be seen on hershey's cocoa powder--not a glass jar with a lid. Maybe an artefact of importation (cheaper and less breakable?)?

              1. re: smokey

                My Brit import shop (Santa Monica, CA) carries both tin and jar.

                1. re: smokey

                  the tin is the classic here in england. i've never seen the glass jar, but there's also a squeezable plastic bottle.

              2. Don't know where you are, but Berkeley Bowl has it.

                I learned of it from Nigella. She raved about it, saying it was sooo much better than corn syrup or even sugar. I have used it in a couple of recipes which turned out well, but don't know if golden syrup was the reason.

                Btw, it certainly is NOT thicker than honey. It's a slow pouring liquid, a little thicker than maple syrup.

                3 Replies
                1. re: oakjoan

                  Oakjoan, I'm curious about the golden syrup you have that's not thicker than honey. The golden syrup I grew up with and the can that's in my cupboard are thick and viscous.

                  1. re: oakjoan

                    mine might be old, but it sure is thicker than honey! i can almost stand the spoon up in the tin!

                    1. re: hobokeg

                      It depends on your honey! Honey can be anywhere from fairly thin to solid -- good quality honey is usually as thick or thicker than Golden Syrup.