HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >


Thanksgiving-themed ice cream ideas

  • a

I'm on, I think, my 6th batch of ice cream here over the past 3 weeks.

Anyhow, wondering what a good idea would be for an ice cream for thanksgiving. I suppose I could look for a pumpkin one, but I'll be having apple and pumpkin pie... so I'd rather have something that complements. Maybe a maple ice cream?

Ideas? recipes?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. b
    Bride of the Juggler

    This site should give you some ideas. It is for a groumet gelato store in Philadelphia, that has many seasonal flavors like pecan sweet potato, and clove. Thank you.

    Link: http://www.capogirogelato.com/

    1. pecan praline? Butter pecan praline??
      Trader Joes has pretty good pralines that you could use in it.

      1. In a pinch, you can get good vanilla ice cream and add ground cinnamon and a dash of nutmeg, blend it and refreeze or to the vanilla add ground ginger, fresh ginger and crystallized and refreeze. Both are great over the pies you mentioned.

        1. cinnamon & ginger ice cream are both excellent for Thanksgiving. You just steep cinnamon sticks or ginger slices in the milk before you make the ice cream mixture. If you have any left over, the ginger makes great floats with orange soda!

          1. I like to make buttermilk ice cream for the holidays. It goes very well with all sorts of spiced desserts. If you're planning to serve the ice cream by itself, then I would suggest adding various spices to give you that holiday feeling.

            1 Reply
            1. re: theSauce

              I'll second that recommendation. Buttermilk ice cream is one of my favorites.

              Link: http://seasonalcook.blogspot.com

            2. I personally would go w/ my all-time fave...vanilla! Yes, perhaps "boring" and not particularly seasonal but still the most swoon-worthy IMHO. Like the little black dress, goes w/ everything. I like to use a combo of bean and extract.

              If you want to do something more interesting...maple syrup or caramel swirl or ginger sound good.

              1. I made a spiced, sweetened cranberry sorbet last year. The flavor was great, but I used the cuisinart rather than push the pulp through a sieve. Next time, I'll use a sieve. The skins turned into little rolled-up pins, so the texture wasn't what I wanted at all.

                This year it will be pumpkin ice cream. I'm going to have two 5 year-olds "helping" with a number of dishes, so the simplicity of opening a can of pumpkin puree wins over something a bit more complex.

                1. Dulce de Leche (Caramel) would go well w/ the apple pie.

                  1. Look for Cinnamon Ice Cream...Publix grocery stores (I live in Florida) sells a lovely "Fried Ice Cream" variety that is basically cinnamon ice cream...very lovely, especially for a store brand! We've been enjoying it!

                    1. I don't have a recipe, but I've always wanted to taste chai ice cream...