Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >
Jul 9, 2005 09:17 PM

Chocolate Chip Cookie Recipe

  • k

This may seem like the most simple thing to make ever, but I've NEVER made good chocolate chip cookies! A lot of people I know use the Tollhouse recipe and have good results, but that's always been the one I've used and have never liked the results! I like chewy, thick cookies, but mine always turn out thin and crispy. My friend, who uses the Tollhouse recipe actually halves the butter or margarine, and I've tried that, but don't get the same results as her. I've even tried using her same brand of butter, but no change! I cook and bake a lot, and this is one of the only things I struggle with continuously! Does anyone have any ideas on what I can do to have different results or have a recipe they like? Also, would like a good recipe for chewy oatmeal chocolate chip cookies! Thanks!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. t

    Instead of all butter, some people use half shortening/half butter. My mother-in-law uses half oleo margarine and half butter, that also makes a thicker, chewier cookie.

    Another tip---chill the dough before baking.

    1. Well, I haven't actually tried these, as I like my cookies crisp myself, but I know a lot of chewy chocolate chip cookies fans that really like Alton Brown's version. See link at Food Network below.


      4 Replies
      1. re: Jujubee

        Specifically its the chewy version. There is a whole thread on e-gullet about them. Check it out. You also have to make the recipe exactly as written. If you don't they won't turn out just right. Enjoy!

        1. re: Jujubee

          Specifically the chewy version. There is a thread on them at egullet. This is one recipe you need to make exactly as written. Otherwise they won't turn out just right. Enjoy!

          1. re: Jujubee

            Bread flour? Fascinating! I will have to try this sometime - while I don't watch him often, I do think he knows his stuff.

            1. re: Jujubee

              Just made these this evening and they are delicious. Husband has already eaten at least 5. Chewy, but not overly so. I'd recommend you try the recipe.

            2. I bake cookies all the time using the tollhouse recipe. I agree that if you follow the recipe exactly, the cookies are generally thin and cripsy. HOWEVER, I have learned that if you use just a LITTLE bit less butter and add approx. 1/8-1/4 cup more flour and an EXTRA 1/4 tspn of baking soda, the cookies come out more cake-like. Also (and this is just my personnal preference) I like to cut down the sugar significantly.

              Experiment a little bit. The worst that could happen is you have cookies you don't want...use them to score major points with the neigbors : ) Good luck!

              15 Replies
              1. re: MM
                Katie Nell (formerly posting under the name Katie)

                Believe me... doing the Cookie of the Month Club this year, and have had several batches of cookies that I just wasn't quite thrilled with... my boyfriend's co-workers have gotten several experiments and have not complained one bit!

                1. re: Katie Nell (formerly posting under the name Katie)
                  La Dolce Vita

                  I, too, spend time looking for the "perfect" chocolate chip recipe. The one I found, and am quite happy with, is published in Cook's Illustrated "Best Recipes" book, on p. 419. It's called "Thick and Chewy Chocolate Chip Recipes."

                  They also have a recipe for Tollhouse cookies on the preceding page, but I never cared for those thin little cookies.

                  However, the Thick & Chewy recipe is the ONLY one I'll use. Everytime I make them, I get rave reviews. I've even had guests ask if they could take some home, they found them so delicious. The one thing I do differently from the recipe is I first freeze the dough balls before I bake them. Not only does this allow me to bake only as many as I need (and have a handy stash of dough in the freezer for those last-minute cookie cravings), but the shape of the cookies come out better if baked from frozen.

                  Incidentially, this book also contains the best oatmeal cookie recipe, and oatmeal cookies are my absolute favorite cookie.

                  1. re: La Dolce Vita

                    I have recently become a fan of the Cook's Illustrated "thick & chewy" recipe. No other recipe I've used has come close. The flavor and texture is perfect. This is the only version my husband likes.

                    For a cakier, puffy chocolate chip cookie, I use the "Ultimate Chocolate Chip Cookie" recipe from the crisco website. It uses the Crisco butter shortening sticks. These really keep well.

                    1. re: MixyG

                      PLEASE post the recipe. I'm drooling.

                    2. re: La Dolce Vita

                      I always use this recipe as well - I found it when my office was doing a chocolate chip cookie bakeoff! I never thought that melting the butter would make such a difference in keeping the soft consistency in the cookie.

                      I have also tried using half butter, half lard. (yes, real lard, not crisco) They were very delicious. Funny, I had a teenage friend stop by, and when he sampled both, he said the one with lard tasted "more nutritious" LOL. I think he was trying to put his finger on the richness and depth to the flavor.

                      1. re: La Dolce Vita

                        Another vote for this recipe. I've been using it since the it was in the magazine, to rave reviews every time. I also do a variant that is my personal favorite cookie - replace chocolate chunks with toasted walnut halves, replace light brown sugar with dark brown sugar, add 1 tsp Frontier natual walnut flavoring or, if you can't find that, 1 tsp natural maple flavor, or just double the vanilla. This makes a chewy, richly flavored walnut cookie, which I had been trying to do for years before finding this recipe.


                        1. re: La Dolce Vita

                          Another happy CI CCC recipe user. In the interests of full disclosure, however, I've never made the Alton Brown chewy CCC recipe, and I have heard good things about it.


                          1. re: La Dolce Vita

                            I was just about to recommend this recipe also - a friend made me cookies using this recipe and shipped them to me, and they were great. A couple of seconds in the microwave made them softer, if you like them that way.

                            1. re: La Dolce Vita

                              One more vote for this recipe. This recipe makes big, chewy cookies that are to die for! I had one girl tell me they were the best chocolate chip cookies she'd ever had - anywhere.

                              1. re: La Dolce Vita

                                Post the recipe for those of us who don't have the book! I'm dyin' over here!

                                EDIT: Found it w/ a quick search on google ->

                                1. re: La Dolce Vita

                                  In the directions, it says to bake the cookies for half the time on the top rack and half the time on the lower middle rack. But when it says to bake, it doesn't say which one to start with. Does it matter? Should I start w/ the bottom? The top? Help! =)

                                  1. re: mstinawu

                                    If you're baking two sheets at once, you start w/ one on top, the other on bottom (one on the left side, one on the right) and switch them. If you only have one sheet, put the rack near the middle and leave it there but cut the baking time (start looking 2 about minutes earlier). I've also read you can eliminate the switch with two sheets if you keep a pizza stone in the oven so I've done that and it's fine. It could also be that my oven is pretty uniform in temperature anyway.

                                    1. re: chowser

                                      So basically it doesn't matter where you start off baking your cookies--as long as they get switched and are on opposite sides. Thanks. =)

                              2. re: MM

                                Hey MM: if you happen to check on this again... how much of the sugar do you cut out and do you replace that volume with anything? i'm always trying to cut down on the sugar. I've been doing what you do re:butter and flour for a long time now and like those results. I'm very curious about the sugar reduction! hey, soon enough it'll just be chocolate ;)


                                1. re: fresser

                         know, honestly, it changes all the time! Let's see...I would try knocking it down 1/4 of the amount listed - or even half (I can't remember what it is right now...something like 14T of brown sugar and 12T of white?).

                                  Once you do this, taste the dough before you bake (I know it's a tough job, but someone's gotta do it!) If it doesn't seem sweet enough, add more sugar. Or, if it's too sweet, add more flour. Good luck!

                              3. f

                                I consistently struggle to get the same puffy cakey consistence that my grandmother's chocolate chip cookies had. I'm searching in vain in my house for her recipe, which she wrote down for me years ago. Since I'm moving in the next two weeks, I may find it, and if I do I'll post it. Until then, try some of these tips which have worked for me:

                                Use half butter and half butter flavored shortening.

                                Use cake flour.

                                Use a higher percentage of brown sugar vs. white sugar than the toll house recipe calls for.

                                Chill the dough and use larger scoops of it when portioning.

                                1. Katie, I hope you'll try these! Feel free to substitute chocolate chips for the Raisinettes. (I also emailed you another recipe - not sure if I am supposed to post that one here since I got it off another site)

                                  Kim's Oatmeal Cookies

                                  These are my babies. The very best oatmeal cookies that I can devise. I worked long and hard on these and I am happy with the results. Of course, if you can improve, please let me know. I love a soft, chewy, spicy cooky!!

                                  1 c. butter
                                  1 c. brown sugar
                                  1/2 c. sugar
                                  2 eggs
                                  1 t. vanilla
                                  1 1/2 c. flour
                                  1 t. baking soda
                                  1 t. cinnamon + a dash or two of nutmeg, clove, allspice and ginger
                                  1/2 t. salt
                                  3 c. Oats - quick or old fashioed
                                  1 c. raisins, or RAISINETTES (the best)

                                  Preheat oven to 350 degrees.

                                  Beat butter and sugars. Add rest of wet ingredients.

                                  Mix and sift together the dry ingredients except for the oats and raisins.

                                  Add the dry to the wet and mix well. Add the oats and the raisins. Scoop up by fairly large spoonsful - I use one of those cooky dough scoops that works like an ice cream scoop (these are the bomb).

                                  Bake 10 -12 minutes. Cool one minute on sheet then transfer to racks.

                                  2 Replies
                                  1. re: kim shook

                                    kim, i tried this recipe yesterday (subbing chocolate chips for raisinettes) and they were GREAT!! i used vanilla paste instead of extract, and used a combination of quick and old fashioned oats. i like how adding the extra spices gives the cookie more flavor. thanks so much!

                                    1. re: kim shook

                                      I tried your recipe over christmas and My family loved it :)
                                      However, it is TOO sweet.
                                      Perhaps it would be better to reduce the amount of sugar significantly.
                                      Wonder if it will affect the texture of the cookie?
                                      Anyway here's a photo of the cookies.