Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >
Jun 11, 2005 07:10 PM

Cherry pit or not?

  • c

I have been gifted with some lovely fresh cherries, sweet and semi sweet...and want to make a nice Clafouti.

I know a good recipe was posted here recently, anyone care to post it again??? The recipe below uses only milk, but I was thinking of using something a bit richer, yet don't want to make the cake heavy... big pit or not? I know I have heard not to pit, by keeping the cherries whole, their juice does not disturb the liquid ratio of the batter.

Any thoughts...???

Pour 4 personnes: 400 g de cerises de Montmorency, 2 oeufs, 80 de sucre semoule, 80 g de farine, 20 cl de lait, sel. Laver, équeuter et dénoyauter les cerises. Les saupoudrer avec la moitié du sucre et en garnir une tourtière beurrée. Dans un saladier, mélanger la farine, une pincée de sel et le sucre restant. Ajouter les oeufs, fouetter, puis verser le lait peu à peu. Napper les cerises de cette crème et faire cuire 35 mn dans le four à 200 °C.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Below is a link to Julia Child's cherry clafoutis recipe. I haven't had a chance to try it yet, but a few hounds have vouched for it. If you scroll down, "veebee" made an alteration by adding melted butter. Julia's recipe calls for milk and pitted cherries. I agree that heavy cream would be nice, so I'll probably use 1/4 c. heavy cream and 1 c. milk.

    While I didn't care for the Saveur recipe that I used, it did recommend to NOT pit the cherries for better flavor. Since I was making it for a dinner party, I went ahead and pitted them but recognized how much yummy juice was sacrificed. The added liquid of cut fruit may have added to the rubbery texture too. Ultimately, I think it's best to follow your particular recipe's suggestions, as leaving them intact may not work as well for Julia's recipe...not sure though. Let us know how it goes.


    1 Reply
    1. re: Carb Lover

      I've made Julia Child's cherry clafoutis recipe a million times over the last 35 years, always using pitted cherries. I love it, guests love it, everyone loves it. Pit your cherries and go for it.

    2. Traditionnellement, on ne dénoyaute pas les cerises après les avoir équeutées -- on dirait que ça leur donne un certain goût, mais je n'aime pas quoi que ce soit qui me retient de manger vite mon dessert, et je n'aime pas devoir regardes mes invités cracher leurs noyaux en mangeant, alors je les dénoyaute toujours !

      Traditionally, cherries aren't pitted after being destemmed -- supposedly this gives them a better flavour, but I don't like anything that keeps me from eating my dessert as quickly as I want, and I don't like to watch my guests spit out the pits as they're eating, so I always pit them!

      1. FWIW, when this dish was served to me in Paris, cherries were not pitted. I think not pitting them might help them keep their shape as they bake in the clafoutis batter.

        1. No personal experience, but in this article the reason for not pitting the cherries is that the pits impart an almond-like flavour... maybe some almond extract would have similar effect?