HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >
What's your latest food quest?
TELL US

Slow cooker vs. oven

s
Sheilapal May 30, 2005 05:43 PM

Instead of using a slow cooker, couldn't I just brown a roast -- say a chuck roast, add some onion and garlic and then some liquid, cover it, and cook it in a very slow oven for several hours? How would a slow cooker do a better job? Why even invest in one?

  1. e
    ErnieD Apr 12, 2010 01:23 PM

    It's just the convenience factor, and you're probably the only one who can decide whether that's worth it to you. If I'm going to be in the general vicinity of the kitchen, I'll always opt for a braise or simmer either on the burner or in a low oven. Especially for meat-I like to brown first and the slow cooker causes me to have to wash two vessels rather than one. But I do feel safer with the slow cooker, and it doesn't heat up the kitchen as much. I use mine maybe once or twice a month, if even that, but it was probably $30 (cheaper than my enameled Dutch oven, actually, although less versatile) and I have plenty of cabinet space, so for me it was worthwhile.

    1. l
      lexpatti Apr 12, 2010 12:49 PM

      tonight we are having spaghetti squash that has been in the crockpot since I left this morning - I have never tried this in the oven, nor would I want to leave it all day in the oven.

      same with a great 13 or 15 bean soup, I wouldn't leave that on the stove top or in oven all day but the crock pot = fantastic.

      1. m
        Mestralle Apr 12, 2010 09:41 AM

        We have a small apartment kitchen and a really cheap, old stove/oven. I find the crockpot very useful not only because I can't get anything to cook evenly in our oven, but starting around this time of year, I will go to almost any length not to use the oven and die from the heat it gives off, particularly for something that takes a while to cook. (In fact, I just bought a new toaster convection oven because I was dreading summer cooking.)

        1 Reply
        1. re: Mestralle
          chowser Apr 12, 2010 09:58 AM

          You might have some luck if you put a pizza stone in the oven. When it comes up to temperature, it'll help keep the heat constant if the oven is doing odd things. It doesn't help with the how hot the house gets, though.

        2. t
          tonka11_99 Apr 11, 2010 10:11 PM

          Actually the oven will do a better job, particularly if you use a dutch oven. A crock pot always seems to be good but not quite as good as the oven in my humble opinion anyway.

          However, I wouldn't leave the oven on all day while I went to work. I would with a crock pot. I would make very sure nothing was around it to catch on fire.

          Quite frankly, I am not sure why I am less concerned about the dangers of leaving a crock pot on as opposed to an oven but I am. I have probably been brain washed by the commercials and recipes and the fact that the crock pot was specifically designed for just that.

          1 Reply
          1. re: tonka11_99
            i
            icecone Apr 12, 2010 03:08 AM

            "I am not sure why I am less concerned about the dangers of leaving a crock pot on as opposed to an oven"

            crocks draw less current than an oven. they're less likely to cause a fire, less likely to run up the electric bill.

          2. Uncle Bob Apr 11, 2010 07:36 AM

            "Why even invest in one?"

            We have three....they are (I think) in a cabinet in the top of my kitchen...Takes an 8' ladder to get to it......There they are probably collecting dust...Can't say for sure as I've not seen them in years.... HTH

            Fun!

            1. i
              Ilaine May 31, 2005 07:12 PM

              You wrote: "couldn't I just brown a roast -- say a chuck roast, add some onion and garlic and then some liquid, cover it, and cook it in a very slow oven for several hours?"

              Answer: Yes, yes, yes. I brown the meat in the oven on a rack, then put into a Le Creuset with beef broth, tomato paste and red wine, and braise at 250 farenheit.

              "How would a slow cooker do a better job?"

              Answer: it won't. A slow cooker takes MUCH longer to cook things and doesn't surround the pot with heat like the oven does.

              "Why even invest in one?"

              Because you shouldn't go off and leave your oven unattended but a slow cooker is safe to leave while you go to work or do other things outside the house.

              1. w
                waste not May 30, 2005 10:55 PM

                slow cookers use less energy than ovens. no need to keep a large mass of air at temperature. but will the cost of a slow cooker ever get recovered by lower energy bills?

                the other thing is that a quality slow cooker can hold a more even temperature.

                remember that these types of dishes originated from pots left by home cooks at the local baker to cook in the slowly cooling wood burning oven after the morning breads have finished baking. modern ovens don't insulate as well as a thick masonry oven.

                1. a
                  applehome May 30, 2005 10:26 PM

                  You're absolutely right. I braise in the oven all winter long - it's a gas oven with an electric timer. I have no problem sealing up a brisket, thick 7-bone chuck roast or short ribs in a deep pan with foil to cover in the am - having it start around 2pm and cook at 280 or so until I'm home at 6. Boil some potatoes to mash and steam some beans or whatever... a "cooked all day" dinner at 6:30 on a winter workday...

                  For the brisket, I use carrots and garlic for flavoring, and use the water to make gravy. The short ribs get some canned tomatoes and onions, also some tomato paste. The 7-bone chuck is a little different, because we like it traditionally with the vegetables cooked in the braising liquid. If you put in carrots, onions and potatoes up front, they will be too mushy. Luckily, our son is old enough to be home from school, so at around 4:30, we have a bowl of veg's prepped, and he (carefully) picks up the foil, spreads the vegs all over the meat and pan, then closes it back up again. The veg's need the hour and a half because it's at 280.

                  By the way - I don't bother browning. The "sealing in the juices" thing is an urban myth, and when braising that long, there's no advantage in trying to create a crust.

                  I also have a slow cooker, but I primarily use it for serving at pot-lucks.

                  One of these days, I guess I'll actually buy me a dutch oven... but so far, I just use these cheap $10 10x14 pans that are about 3" deep - you get them in the grocery store - they're non-stick and last for about 20 or so cookings before the non-stick stuff starts to come off. Then I chuck it and buy another. I use heavy duty foil to cover.

                  This is a fall/winter thing for us because the kitchen does get hot during the summer if we do almost any cooking. We have our gas and charcoal grills, as well as a gas burner on the deck right outside the kitchen, and almost all our cooking is done outside once it gets hot. I suppose that we could use the slow cooker to braise during the summer, but nobody really feels like pot roast when it's 100 outside...

                  2 Replies
                  1. re: applehome
                    f
                    Food Tyrant May 30, 2005 11:48 PM

                    The browning thing....it really adds character to a braise. the Maillard reactions that are set off by browing the meat is something that does not occur in nature. High heat changes and creates a host of secondary protien chains and flavors that simply do not exist without the intial browning.

                    I believe that you get a very tasty pot roast without the browning. But to elevate the flavor try browning the meat first. At least on weekends when you have the time.

                    1. re: applehome
                      thew Apr 12, 2010 09:56 AM

                      brown for flavor, not for seal or crust

                    2. c
                      Candy May 30, 2005 09:05 PM

                      I have never seen the point of a slow cooker. I can brown in one of my Le Creuset Dutch Ovens and add the other ingredients and pop it all into my oven at 200 or 250 and come back hours later to perfectly done, braised whatever.

                      4 Replies
                      1. re: Candy
                        c
                        ChowFun (derek) May 30, 2005 09:25 PM

                        Maybe it has something to do with leaving an oven (gas) on all day???
                        It certainly would seem an oven would create a more even heat...However, the slow cooker does come with a warm cycle which stops the cooking after a preset number of hours ( I guess some ovens do, but I never used that option) and browning in the same pan is always a help.

                        1. re: Candy
                          m
                          MikeG May 30, 2005 10:22 PM

                          That's the equivalent of using the slow cooker on "high." I doubt very much one could an oven to the ~ 150F temp for "low" slow cooking, where you let it go all day or overnight. And even on the high setting, the temp is lower and steadier than many ovens can maintain (under 200F.) If you have a good oven that can maintain a steady, low heat and you don't want to do the all day version, I agree it makes more sense to stick with the oven, or indeed, stove top.

                          The other thing is that I wouldn't be comfortable leaving a gas oven on all day when I'm at work. It's one thing to do it overnight, but I wouldn't want to do it knowing I'd be gone for 10 hours. Unless I had a really wonky, old electric oven, I wouldn't worry a whole lot about that.

                          1. re: MikeG
                            c
                            Candy May 30, 2005 11:00 PM

                            I have a gas cook top, but an electric oven.

                          2. re: Candy
                            o
                            oneslikeme Apr 11, 2010 06:27 AM

                            i enjoy using my slow cooker because i can put everything in before i go to work and know that it will be done when i get home. so there isn't really a wait. slow cookers also make the most tender meat i've ever eaten.

                          Show Hidden Posts