Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >
Jan 4, 2005 11:14 AM

ultimate brownie - what kind of chocolate

  • f

I am volunteering to make desserts for an event on Thrusday and would love to find the ultimate brownie recipe. One that would be chewey and buttery would be perfect (not cake-like). So many recipes I have seen call for only unsweetened chocolate and all I can find is "Baker's Brand" at the supermarkets where I live; but all kinds of good bittersweet brands like Lindt and other imported kinds. Any advice would be appreciated.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Aren't you going to share your receipe?

    If you are looking for good chocolate like Lindt, you should go to a specialty food store or nice candy store (like one in an upscale mall).

    1. My hands down favorite chocolate for baking (especially brownies) is Scharffenberger. It has a very high cocoa content and makes a noticeable difference in the end result. It's made in northern California, and is widely available at high end markets (e.g., Bristol Farms in So Cal) or specialty stores. Peet's Coffee carries snack sized bars, but not the baking size.

      1 Reply
      1. re: LBQT
        culinary nerd

        I second the use of Scharffen Berger chocolate in brownies. It makes all the difference in the world.

      2. I often substitute bittersweet/semisweet and unsweetened.

        1 ounce bittersweet=1 ounce unsweetened plus 1 scant tablespoon of white sugar.

        So if your recipe contains any added sugar, you may use bittersweet chocolate and cut the sugar accordingly.

        Try to use 75% cocoa chocolate - the unsweetened chocolate typically has higher cocoa content than bittersweet/semisweet.

        Alternatively, if a chocolate is to be melted, you can substitute 3 tablespoons of cocoa powder and one tablespoon of oil for an ounce of unsweetened chocolate - should you have access to a good cocoa powder.

        1. The number of eggs you use determines where on the cake-like scale brownies fall. Use more, use less and you change the consistency. I can't remember which way it goes, but it is in the King Arthur cookbook.

          As for chocolate, in brownies, I'd use a high-quality unsweetened if I could find one. A high-quality brand uses better beans, that had a careful ferment and roasting and were never alkalized. Unsweetened chocolate is raw chocolate without sugar. Bittersweet has sugar, some vanilla and soya lecithin added. The % cocoa content is the combination of cocoa butter and cocoa solids. Chocolate makers increase the ratio of cocoa butter (tasteless but creamy) to solids. So a 75% bar is 75% cocoa butter and cocoa solids. The rest is sugar (mainly), lecithin (a couple percent) and vanilla. Because you're putting it in brownies, as opposed to candy, the extra oomph from the higher ratio of cocoa solids to cocoa butter in unsweetened(you'll be adding sweet butter anyway, which is better then cocoa butter for taste) will give you a more powerful taste. If you cannot find a quality unsweetened, then go with a quality bittersweet and adjust the sugar accordingly.

          1. I always make the ones linked below. Note they use mostly semi-sweet. I rarely use anything but regular grocery store choc. (Bakers) They are spectacular. I often leave out the choc chips.

            Recently I have been making them very thin, sans choc chips, and then making a choc/cream ganache to spread in a super thin layer on top. Then I refridgerate (seems to make the texture even denser) and cut into tiny (about a sq inch) squares to serve as a post-dessert nibble.

            I would think that Scharfengerger or Valhrona would put them into orbit.