HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >
Brewing beer, curing meat, or making cheese?

Substitute for sherry vinegar?

ticksgirl Dec 7, 2004 03:59 PM

I have a lentil salad recipe with a vinaigrette that calls for sherry vinegar, which of course I can't seem to find anywhere.

Any suggested substitutes? I have sherry, and I have red wine, balsamic, rice, apple cider, raspberry, and white vinegar.


  1. e
    esvoboda Dec 14, 2004 03:19 AM

    You can choose from quite a few types at Draeger's in San Mateo, Los Altos, or Menlo Park.

    Sherry vinegar has a distinct flavor (not musty if it's any good) that can't easily be replaced. I think it'd be better to lose the flavor than introduce a flavor that might not work. So, a white vinegar or maybe even a champagne vinegar (my other go-to vinegar) could work. MAYBE using a neutral vinegar and a slight hit of sherry could do the trick.

    1. f
      farmersdaughter Dec 7, 2004 07:31 PM

      For a lentil salad red wine vinegar is probably the best bet but it won't taste at all like sherry vinegar. That's OK, it'll still be good. I'd stay away from balsamic and raspberry.

      You can buy sherry vinegar online at The Spanish Table or at Tienda, both of which are excellent sources for all things Iberian.

      1. b
        babette feasts Dec 7, 2004 07:30 PM

        I would do cider vinegar and a little sherry. (A little sherry never hurt anyone.)

        1. b
          brookmonton Dec 7, 2004 06:51 PM

          It would depend on the other ingredients in the salad but all things being equal, and especially if there is garlic in the salad, I would opt for the red wine vinegar.

          For the future, sherry vinegar is increasingly easy to find and I think it is a worthwhile ingredient to have in the cupboard. Keep looking for it.

          1. j
            jen kalb Dec 7, 2004 05:11 PM

            wine vinegar or balsamic would probably work the best. Sherry wine vinegar has a wood-aged and, to my taste somewhat musty taste. Its not as sweet as balsamic, so dont use as much. Cider or rice would probably be ok as subs too, just not raspberry - and white vinegar doesnt add any flavor at all so I would avoid that too.

            Show Hidden Posts