HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >
Brewing beer, curing meat, or making cheese? Share your food adventure
TELL US

Opinions on Chelsea Market's The Lobster Place?

l
Lisa O. Jul 16, 1999 01:32 PM

I just moved to Chelsea and I was psyched about the
shops in the Chelsea Market at 16th and 9th (esp. the
AWESOME Thai place) but several times now I have gone
into The Lobster Place and found it a little
unsanitary. I've had their lobsters, but I've been
squeamish about buying other seafood there. Has
anyone had good or bad experiences with buying fish
there?

  1. a
    Allan Evans Jul 16, 1999 02:15 PM

    Another place to be wary of is the Italian market, as
    many of the items stating "da consumarsi entro..." [to
    be eaten by...] are often 2 years old. Yuck. But they
    still carry good Umbrian olive oil.

    3 Replies
    1. re: Allan Evans
      t
      Trip Jul 19, 1999 09:12 AM

      When I lived in Chelsea, I had no problems with The
      Lobster Place. Between me and my s.o. (there are a lot
      of fishs I don't eat but she does) we've had many of
      the fishs and the shrimp, but no shellfish and no
      lobster.

      1. re: Trip
        r
        Rachel Perlow Aug 26, 1999 10:46 AM

        I'm sorry to quibble, but shrimp is shellfish

      2. re: Allan Evans
        c
        chimera Jul 19, 1999 11:51 AM

        The Lobster Place has been my primary fish source
        for the last couple of years, and while I entirely
        understand your wariness, I can report no bad
        experiences. The fish I've had--while not always
        superlatively fresh--has been consistently decent,
        and sometimes excellent.

        On the other hand, I second Allan re: Buon Italia--
        I've stopped buying their buffalo mozzerella, which
        has been distinctly past its prime on more than
        one occasion. Yuck, indeed.

      3. b
        Benjamin Schmerler Jul 20, 1999 01:08 PM

        While others may have mentioned this, try the lobster roll, it's fantastic and a great deal. In addition, while you're in the Chelsea Market, go to Amy's for her twists, prosciutto bread and cheddar sandwich with cilantro and chipotles. Make sure they melt it.

        Show Hidden Posts