Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Italy >
Apr 23, 2006 12:02 AM

Italy Report (long)

  • j

Hello All,
My girlfriend and I recently returned from a trip to Italy. We ate very well and wanted to share.

We started in Rome at the Trimani Wine Bar. This is a sort of upscale bar with some very good small plates. The cured meats were great as were the lamb meatballs. The bar focuses on higher end wines and has a very nice wine shop attached.

That night we ate one of our best meals. The restaurant was called MATRICIANELLA and was recently featured in a NY Times article called "The Bounty of Rome." The carbonara was the best I've ever had with the crispiest pork cheeks and very sharp cheese. This was followed by a truffled pasta with a very rich sauce and a truffle taste so strong that it probably could not be found in the US affordably (the dish cost 15 Euros here).

We spent the next night at Fattoria Dei Barbi, one of the top producers of Brunello Di Montalcino. The rooms was very nice and our stay was made infinitely more pleasurable by Angela, one of the few English speaking staff members. Barbi also cures its own meats and exports them throughout Italy. For dinner, we started with the meats and then went to a tagliatele (sp?) with wild boar. We shared a hen braised in vin santo that was slightly sweet but much more savory than you might think. The service was superb and my girlfriend (who fortunately speaks fluent Italian) had a great conversation with out waiter about the pros and cons of Italian vs. French cuisine. This night was really about the wine though. We had a bottle of their 1995, which they say is one of their best years. I'm not a great wine writer and cannot do it justice here. It was wonderful. Order it if you see it anywhere.

Our next stop was Siena. This was the least impressive of our nicer meals and I mention it only because we found the rec on Chowhounds. The restaurant is called Cane e Gato (dog and cat). It is unbelievably romantic and the service superb. The food was to close, I felt, to French or refined American. A creamy potato leek soup was followed by a piece of beef with red wine and mushrooms. Don't get me wrong, these are delicious dishes but not what we hoped to eat in Italy, and certainly not for these prices (the meal came to about 175 Euro, expensive for us!). Not a wasted night at all but very heavy and not what we were in the mood for.

The next couple nights we stayed in Chianti. We had pulled a rec from the Babbo website for a place called Sfizio in Gaiole in Chianti. This was an amazing meal. The restaurant is family run and the dishes rustic and satisfying. This antipasti platter was the best of the entire trip. Amazing chicken livers and lots of other things. We had ravioli with truffle and finally tried Bisteca Fiorentina. The meat was much more rare than most American steak houses serve it and it was wonderful. That's the only time I have had the dish so this might always be the case but I loved the simplicity of the pepper and olive oil. This dish is about the great meat and not much else. It just doesn't need much else.

Next was the coast. We hiked thorugh the Cinque Terre. The food here is mostly seafood and reminded me quite a bit of the simple fresh fish of Maine. Nearly every restaurant had a platter of mixed grilled fish which was wonderful. A lighter style of food. The local wine was not very good but Vernaccia (the white wine from San Gemingano) is readily available.

Next we ate our last high end meal of the trip. L'antica Tratorria in Colle D'elsa. This was very good. The restaurant serves tartare and a wonderful risotto with tons and tons of fresh pureed herbs. This food was a little closer to the style of Cane e Gato but much better executed. Now that I think about it, it's possible we just needed a change of pace and this was it.

We returned to Rome and had our last dinner at Da Armando al Pantheon. I had eaten here a few years ago and loved it. It has a very nice energy and a mixed crowd of hungry people. Service was very good and the pastas wonderful. This is closest in style to the meal we had our first night in Rome. The truffle pasta is also very good here.

What a wonderful trip! Can't wait to go back.


  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Thanks for taking the time to post such a helpful review. We're looking forward to New Year in florence and Rome so I'll be keeping the info handy.

    1. jeremy,

      glad that you didn't go to agata e romeo. Many people on CH recommended agata e romeo as one of the best places in Rome. As you did with your meal at cane e gato, I felt this place was incredibly overpriced and not what one should be eating in Italy. It was more of a fancified take on california cuisine. Seems that chowhounds aren't really upto snuff when it comes to Italian eats. Next time you are in Rome check out Pizzeria Da Baffetto. Best pizza in the world.

      4 Replies
      1. re: yoyoma

        You must have had a really bad experience at Agata e Romeo since you seem to be going out of your way to trash it. Granted it's been two years since I've eaten there and it certainly was expensive (about 135 euros nowadays for its tasting menu), but I still have fond memories of a cook who was taking traditional Roman cuisine to fairly sophisticated heights. Of course, restaurants do deteriorate, sometimes very rapidly but I've noticed that the restaurant has held on to its Michelin star and to its high ratings in Fodor's and Frommer's, others who apparently aren't "up to snuff when it comes to Italian eats."

        1. re: jbw

          it was boarding on horrible. i've had better meals in los angeles.

          1. re: yoyoma

            its useful feedback (I dont much go for fine dining or creative cooking in Italy either) but you gotta do better than a pizza recommendation to help Rome travelers.

          2. re: jbw

            good friend of mine was there 2 months ago..said is was horrible...

        2. re cane e gatto, just out of interest was it the (slightly) elderly chef / patron who is still running the show there? It's never been cheap but it has been more "Tuscan" than you suggest, when I have been there..


          3 Replies
          1. re: DarD

            The gentleman who ran the place was wonderful. The food had a slight Tuscan edge to it (cured meats to start for example). But the rest of the meal was very French we thought. Service was great and as I mentioned before, the space was very romantic.

            1. re: JeremyeG

              just wondering the the whole menu was continentalized or it might just have been the dishes you chose -

              I know I am prone to ordering different sounding dishes which may not be the strongest or best a regional kitchen offers.

              Finally,there are a lot of veg puree soups in the italian repetoire, as well as meat stews made with red wine, so your meal wasnt necessarily french or continental. There's just a lot of overlap in the cuisines

              1. re: jen kalb

                I was just at Cane e Gato in July (and my friend went in May and recommended it to me) and we both found it very Tuscan. The old man was SO cute! He brought flowers out for all the girls, and our server was very sweet too. I remember starting out with antipasto (including a parmesan cheese with a drizzle of honey that was excellent!) and we had Tuscan bread/tomato soup. The soup was 100 times better than anywhere else we came across it... I'd say the food was very Tuscan, but the presentation was fairly French.