HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >

Shepherd's pie

s
Susan Nov 11, 1999 10:17 AM

I'm looking for recommendations. Of my limited NYC samplings, my favorite is at Jimmy Walker's, a bar on 55th and 2nd. Followed by Tea & Sympathy (a few dollars more than the one at Jimmy's, not as good but a quieter place to eat). The shepherd's pie at Swift's looked like a Lean Cuisine (still in the plastic thingy) and tasted like it, too. I've also tried it at McGee's (55th and B'way/7th), but I don't remember it, so it was probably okay.

Any ideas where I try next?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. f
    fd RE: Susan Nov 11, 1999 10:34 AM

    A year and a half ago we had the worst shepherd's pie at the Landmark Tavern and haven't tried ordering it again there since.

    1 Reply
    1. re: fd
      a
      AHR RE: fd Nov 11, 1999 09:20 PM

      But their Scotch eggs are fine, the roast beef pretty good, and the malt collection...

    2. j
      Jim Leff RE: Susan Nov 11, 1999 10:39 AM

      molly's on 3rd and 22nd.

      also fantastic cheeseburgers (sauteed onions a must)

      1. w
        wendy RE: Susan Nov 15, 2000 11:30 PM

        You absolutely have to try Maggie's -- on like 48th and Madison -- love it and miss it, since I just moved back home to SF. Made a point to visit it last time I got back!

        Show Hidden Posts