Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > General Tristate Archive >
Feb 28, 2005 11:12 AM

Review: Blue Hill @ Stone Barns - long

  • d

Never before have dining expectations been exceeded as they have for me at Blue Hill @ Stone Barns.

My wife and I took the train from Grand Central to Tarrytown last night...and was picked up by my parents and sister to celebrate my birthday. Getting a table at Blue Hill isn't the simplest feat, and thus my birthday dinner was a month after the actual date. Its true then...what they say about "all good things..."

The train ride out was quick - 45 minutes or so. The ride from the Tarrytown trainstation to BHSB was a nice, quiet, 7 minute drive through some windy turns in a residential area of fine homes.

Driving down Rt. 448, you can see the restaurant/farm some distance off of the road. The entrance is clear and easy to detect but not obtrusive. Understated but noticeable. The drive to the restaurant bisects extensive grazing land for the resident animals. The valet attendants were bundled up in matching down jackets - both of whom were pleasant and welcoming.

The walk, past some gardens and into the courtyard of several buildings (mostly attached) is a great tease. You know, just from this walk, how far removed you are from any dining experience in the city, and also how good you are about to have it.

The entrance to the restaurant is on the right, with a few flickering lanterns on the ground and a sign that says Blue Hill. We walk in and check our coats. In doing so, I look to my left (in the direction of the lounge and beyond that the main dining room) and come face to face with Sen. Hillary Clinton, who is casually pacing the lounge - feeling remarkably comfortable about herself but also anxiously awaiting someone. I'm a bit star struck (it was Oscar night afterall) - she notices, and smiles back, then goes about her business.

We move to the lounge, ordered some drinks. I had a glass of the Schneider Cabernet Franc 'Le Breton', North Fork, New York 2002 and have to say that it wasn't that great. This needs to hold for at least another year. Very grassy. Very immature.

And then we see Ms. Clinton excited at the arrival of Chelsea and three of her girlfriends. They are about to sit in the lounge but are told their table is ready. Ours is soon ready as well, so we make our way into the dining room...a renovated barn with modern but clean and simple appointments including new exposed beams, unobtrusive service counters in the corners, a large central table for waitstaff to place water carafes and utensils and the like as well as a large floral display with colors echoing the farm this time of year. The back wall has a large farm/Westchester scene (regrettably, I only took a quick look at the back of the room - so this is not completely accurate) mural that seemed to go the width of the room.

The ceilings are very tall, which allowed the noise level to be large, but again, unobtrusive. It was loud, but we had no trouble hearing each other. The voices of others seemed to rise to the rafters making it a very acoustically pleasant experience as well.

On to the food. We chose to have 4 courses each, and in doing so, I was able to at least try almost everything they had to offer. I will list all of the food we had as a group and then will describe the items we had. For those that don't know how the menu works, I'll quickly describe it. There are 4 sections of the menu. Tonights were: "Greenhouse", "Seasonal (Mushrooms)", "Handmade Pasta" and "The Pasture". You can order anything at any time. So for example, if you want to order something from the Pasta menu first, then the pasture then the greenhouse and then the seasonal...that's fine. However...the first dish you order will be small. The second bigger. The third bigger still, etc. So here goes.

The Wine
A very nice wine. We got two bottles which worked just fine for our dishes.

Bread and Butter
The bread was in the shape of individual "books" with several "pages". Unique presentation that allowed you to take a page out of the book to eat at a time. The butter was good, but nothing to really wright about. Perhaps I expected more from it?

The Amuse
Chickpea puree with syrian pepper flakes
Served in a shotglass, perfect temperature and a terrific blend of chickpeas and very flavorful pepper. Not your average chile pepper flake.

{The Greenhouse}
Maine Crab (with ferona beets, panther soybeans and lime sorbet)
Baby Romaine Lettuce (w/pine nuts, soft/fried egg and warm pancetta vinaigrette)
Parsnip Soup (apples and American caviar)

The maine crab dish was small, but later on I'm glad it was. The panther soybeans, which were to the side of the main dish, had a slight crunch to them, adding a different texture to the very fresh crab, delicate beets underneath and the lime sorbet that crowned the dish. A simple but complex dish that I did question at first...but wished there was more of afterwards.
The Parsnip soup, by two accounts, was fabulous. I unfortunately didn't get a taste.
The salad's big winner was the egg. The egg, most likely laid just hours earlier, was encrusted with panko and lightly fried. It tasted like no other egg, but how god intended eggs to taste like. So fresh, so big and so full of "fresh egg" flavor. I can only imagine what breakfast would be like at BHSB.

Striped bass (w/ organic maitake mushrooms, caramelized cauliflower, almond and caper vinaigrette)
Poached Cod (w/local musrooms, braised leeks, toasted pumpkin seeds and squash sauce)
Dad had the poached cod and wouldn't share. He isn't the sharing type but did share his enjoyment for the dish. I had the striped bass, and make no mistake, the other dishes are all fantastic, but this might have been my favorite of the night. The hen of the woods (maitake) mushrooms were great and blended well with all of the other textures in this dish. A remarkably savory dish. So powerful but not forceful. Great depth in this dish and truly recommended for everyone. An incredible dish.

{Handmade Pasta}
Chicken Soup (w/rosemary dumplings, garden vegetables, fregola)
Cavatelli (w/guanciale, broccoli puree and italian parsley)
Braised chicken leg (with chestnut pasta and mushroom consomme)

Both the chicken soup and cavatelli were a bit salty, and this coming from my wife who loves salt. I have to agree. The chicken soup, which our waitress informed us has been written up about quite often (yet I haven't seen a word on it yet) was very salty. It almost seemed to keep reminding you of the salt content even afterwards. It almost tasted like it had a gelatin in it, because I felt like I had a salty "soup moustache" on my upper lip. Of course I didn't, but it really lingered on your mouth. Not necessarily in a bad way, just an odd way. My wife, who was not feeling well during the train ride out, was, mysteriously, feeling much better after she had this. No joke. The chicken meat in the dish was also quite tender, but perhaps awkward. It needed cutting (just a bit too big) and using a knife in soup seemed too we managed with our spoons.
The braised chicken leg looked wonderful. I wish I got to try this. The chestnut pasta apparently stole the show from this course.

{The Pasture}
Grass Fed Beef (with farro with roasted carnival and kabocha squash)
Cured Bacon and Roasted Berkshire Pig (with red ace beets, braised red cabbage and cotechino)
Baby Lamb (braised and roasted, amaranth crust and brussel sprout leaves, horseradish broth)
Crescent Duck (w/beet greens and sticks, stew of napoli carrots with toasted spices, fromage blanc spaetzle

I had to get the beef after our waitress' description. Apparently, BHSB rarely offers beef. Apparently a farm upstate grass fed some beef specifically for the use of Blue Hill and her guests. Yes. It was delicious. Cooked medium rare (closer to rare), it was incredibly tender, with a wonderful red similar to tuna sashimi and perfectly cooked. The farro added a great taste and texture as did the squash. An attractive dish in both visual display taste.
Pork, as it has been mentioned before, is not my favorite dish, unless it is in the form of Bacon. So I got chance to try both as well as some cured sausage. This was very good. Much better pork than what was offered at Lupa (see recent review on Manhattan board). But perhaps not enough for me to embrace pork the way others have. The bacon, which was served thick lardon style was nice and crunchy but also chewy.
The lamb came two ways and was also very tender and delicious. The amararynth crust was a nice compliment to the horseradish broth. I would have liked to have tried more of this.
The duck, I think, might have been the best dish of these four. I was in no mood for duck tonight for some reason. Which, when I think about it, is a silly approach for this restaurant. But in the end, I tried my wife's and can only say that it was the best duck I've had to date. It was breast meat cooked to perfection with such a rich, velvety flavor and texture. The spaetzle, served in a mini cast iron skillet on the side, was also a winner and made perfect sense as an accompaniment. Every dish of the night offered great balances of textures, this was no exception. The stew underneath added flavor but brought out the best in the duck as well. Yum.

{Dug Today}
Roasted Jerusalem Artichokes
I'd never ordered these before and felt that the time to do so was now. Excellent starch, served warm (not hot) in a mini, oval cast iron skillet and roasted with butter(?) and I believe parsley. Very flavorful - allowing the vegetable to speak on its own behalf.

see below

Dessert wine
Unsure, but on the house. Very nice finishing touch

Petit Four
Chocolate covered sesame seeds. Crunchy, milk chocalatey and delish.

Service was very good but not great. Our waitress was very good. She knew her dishes, was accomodating, explained the menu well and was overall a pleasant host.
The table service however, was quite sloppy. Spoons were given to the wrong people, plates never reached the table at the same time (although they tried to...just never got it right), we were sat a good half hour late and thus needed to skip dessert in order to get the train back to the city - but we were stuffed, so that's okay this time :)
The coat check girls were less than pleased to be doing their job and even put my sister's jacket downstairs (no room left upstairs)...which by the frigid temperature of her jacket on leaving, seemed to be the equivalent of being put outdoors. That is unforgiveable and I regret tipping her.

But alas, having dinner at Blue Hill at Stone Barns is not just having dinner. It is a full on experience that will, in my case, never be forgotten - sort of like the first time you fly first class. I cannot wait to return in the spring, for a new experience...or maybe I'll just have to head up on a Saturday for one of their give me a fix until then. I can't imagine anyone having an experience other than the one I've described. It really is a great place and reaches, if not exceeds anything I've been to in the city (or anywhere for that matter). I will accept 90% in service if it means getting 110% in food. That's the case here. Thanks, MM


  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. great review..right on target..ive eaten there many many time try to reserve thru

    8 Replies
    1. re: doc

      Believe me I tried. I had to call to get one, as their OpenTable reservation service were, for awhile, only capable of going 1 month out. Now its fixed/updated and allows for 2 months ahead of time. Thanks though.


      1. re: dkstar1

        Last time I went, Super Bowl Sunday, opentable listed no openings, but a phone call snagged us an easy reservation. And it was wonderful--expensive but worth it.

        1. re: spa

          try and do a sunday brunch..walk the a

          1. re: doc

            We've had dinner there a few times and have been walking the grounds there for years--but I don't know about the brunch. I looked at the website and couldn't find a sample menu. Can you pls describe?

            1. re: spa

              call them for info..

              1. re: doc

                How about a little info. One of the great values of this board is not just where to eat but what to eat. If you have been there often,was anything memorable?

                1. re: stuartlafonda

                  Went to Blue Hill a few weeks after it opened-- with 2 other couples-- some impressions: Nice room, beautiful even; amateurish servers; funky, off-base sommelier; bacon fat spooned onto tough spinach salad; weird menu structure; cold,bland entrees; burlap undies desserts. No thanks.

                  1. re: stuartlafonda

                    I've just been there once, and agree wholeheartedly with the long review at the beginning of this thread.

                    Generally speaking, I'd say go with the Farmer's Feast and a Flight of Wine, which will cost you a fortune (95 for the feast 55 for the wine, and it all just adds up), but is the most interesting approach. 5 small entrees, 4 "amuses", 2 desserts, plus a little something or two with your coffee.

                    Specific dishes within our Feast were a Grouper sushi thing with avocado puree and a lime sorbet, and their salad, which seems to be a staple: Lovely fresh greens, a perfect dressing, and a wonderful egg on top. You have to try it to see how good it can be!

      2. Thanks for the in depth review. I unfortunately could never patronize an establishment that sends me home in a cold coat. I can accept cold feet, maybe a cold shoulder now and again but never a cold coat. Regardless of the quality of the meal, no no no!

        2 Replies
        1. re: rkroc

          I like your sense of humor!

          1. re: rkroc

            fortunately our bellies were warm enough to account for it. is well worth it...nay, a bargain.

          2. j
            Josh Mittleman

            We finally got to Blue Hill (with the help of, who found us a reservation 45 minutes from the time I looked). Lovely place, excellent (though not flawless) service. The food is remarkable, every dish a work of art. Very innovative, very clever. I enjoyed it all.

            But I doubt I'll go back: It's too fiddly and fanciful. I would enjoy many far less expensive restaurants just as much.

            On the other hand, I definitely will be back to have nibbles at their bar, which is also lovely and the bar menu is priced very well indeed.

            And note that the farm market is open for the year. I hear they have fresh baby greens. Fridays, 2:00-5:00.

            1 Reply
            1. re: Josh Mittleman

              kinda agree with you..a little too fanciful...but ive been back many times..the meal& & expewrience always good, i hit the fresh market often, besides asst produce..try their eggs

            2. Dinner at BHSB two nights ago. Party of six, so I tasted plenty. The hype is deserved. Only misstep came when the servers, trained to place with assiduous, quiet, signal-corps synchronicity (the cue apparently is when one among them touches his/her chest), fumbled around and lapsed into apologetic chatter and abandoned their coordinated air when informed they had confused two of the plates and had to switch them. It was like Buddhist monks suddenly hiking up their sleeves and lighting up cigarettes. This, in any event, was intriguing, not annoying. Anyway, the five best things I put in my mouth:

              (5) GNOCCHI . . .
              local cheeses, stinging nettles, shiitake musrooms, pinenuts, and asparagus

              Not just the flavor. It was the momentary brain awkwardness as my tongue persisted in reporting implausibly that something so insubstantial--very small, very light--could pack such intense flavor.

              (4) BREAD AND BUTTER

              Butter was predictably excellent. Understated--flavor was small but very round. The dark rough crust made me worry I'd taste nothing but char and get my palate torn up. But the crust turned out to be a kind of light-crispy-darkish that complemented the flavor of the white rather than the kind of dense-tough-charred that displaces it. I suspect now it's what other heavy-crust bakers are shooting for but don't usually achieve.

              (3) PORK BELLY from STONE BARNS BERKSHIRE PIG . . .
              fromage blanc spaetzle, pancetta, ramp leaves, greenhouse minutina

              I actually didn't care much for the loin--two slices are the main event--or the sausage. But the spaetzle was good. And the pork belly was just awesome. I typically despise pork belly. The flavor is often garish, the texture repulsive. This was a cube of tender melt, both texture- and flavor-wise. My teeth moved slowly through that little bar of belly, because the thing was utterly homogeneous--soft and dense. It tasted like bakery without the sweet.

              (2) MINT JULEP

              BHSB is famous for these, so I'm surprised there isn't more comment along these lines. It was a cold forest well. Maybe more mint leaf than booze: if it were less fresh, the pointedness of the mint might have interfered, but the flavor was full and green enough that the mint didn't pierce through and beat up on the rest of the drink. One of the best five drinks I've ever had. Easy.

              (1) GREENHOUSE GREENS AND HERBS . . .
              mushrooms, asparagus, crosnes, pistachios and this morning’s soft/fried farm egg

              I'll not go on, because others already have. It's a plate of yes.

              A last note:
              MAINE CRAB MEAT . . .
              marinated celeriac, soy beans, apple mustard vinaigrette

              While the crab was fine, it was not fantastic. The celeriac was overpowering, and the crab was tender but with little else to commend it. All other things being equal (meaning assuming you are not so crab-happy that you can't possibly stay away), I'd opt for the so many other things that are stand-outs.

              1 Reply
              1. re: chowbound

                I don't feel the hype is deserved. We've given so many chances & we are always underwhelmed. It is a great "Concept" but the delivery is so poor & this whole place is based on media hype & does not live up to the billing. We've never had a "Stand out" dish & wish we had. Assembly line would sum it up!

              2. Thanks so much for the descriptive review! I'm going Friday for my anniversary....can't wait!