HOME > Chowhound > New York State (exc. NYC) >


My PI - Anyone Remember this Long Island Pizza Restaurant?

  • r

Hey there-

I seem to remember a Long Island deep dish pizza restaurant called "My PI" (but spelled with the greek symbol for 3.14) There was one by the Sunrise Mall and one in Hicksville. Does anyone remember this chain? Do they still exist?


  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. I remember the one in Massapequa...but that goes way back. I don't recall seeing any others around since that one vanished.

    2 Replies
    1. re: Tony Bad
      Steve Triplet

      There was one in Tulsa Ok back in the mid 70's. Have been looking for one recently but have had no luck. Best pizza I ever had. Hope to find one if they are still around.

      1. re: Steve Triplet

        That's so funny, my husband and I were talking about the one on Sunny Isles Blvd right before Collins ave in North Miami Beach, Fl, the other day...when we first started dating in 1979, he used to take me there all the time--the BEST pizza..couldn't figure out why they closed....

    2. I remember the one in Hicksville quite fondly. Used to frequent with my friends during high school (yikes! that was a long time ago!)

      Haven't seen one since that folded.

      1. Yes. I know there is one in Chicago at Clark and Fullerton. It is still the best pizza. Yum! They even still have the silly game placemats.

        1. Definitely my best Pizza memories. I used to go very often to the one on South US1, near Dadeland Mall, but also went a few times to the one in North Miami Beach. I've been looking for them for years, but didn't check the net about it until today. Please let me know if they are somewhere else. I'd surely go back there. M.

          1. My family remembers My Pi fondly. We used to go there often. We miss the place and wish to find a way to get in touch with the owners. Best pizza we ever had! If the owners see this please reply to this and tell us where you have moved. We would love to come wherever you are. The greatest thing would be if you come back to Long Island! Anyone with any information about this place please reply. Thanks!

            1. I LOVED the My Pi @ Sunrise, esp the pepperoni pie, but also the cheese bread & the chilli. I think they went out decades ago :'(

              1. Many fond memories of the one in the Mid-lsland Plaza mall in Hicksville. The dark interior, the roaring, round fireplace, the proudly displayed hifi with reel-to-reel tape deck, and of course the pizza [nobody else around did deep-dish], and l loved the corn on the cob!

                  1. re: lrub99

                    OMG it looks just like i remember!

                  2. My pi with the Greek symbol, I have the matchbook when they were on sunrise hwy in massapequa ny