HOME > Chowhound > Outer Boroughs >

Noodle Pudding report

D-NY Apr 28, 2006 06:00 PM

Went to Noodle Pudding last night with my SO, and since there arent a lot of detailed report on this place I'll add my 2 cents. It has a nice vibe, friendly but not at all stuffy and the prices are better than I had expected (apps from ~ 6-10; pastas from 9-12; dinner entrees around 20; desserts 5). Shared the buffalo mutz appetizer and a special of fried anchovies. The mozzarella was served with halved cherry tomotoes, greens and roasted red pepper. It was really delicious--large portion, very fresh, the roasted pepper had more of a smoky roasted flavor than the peppers we make at home. I've had better mozzerella but only in italy. My SO didn't like it as much but still thought it was quite good. The anchovies were a total disspointment--we had expected whole anchovies, they were filets, and looked like the white anchovies (boquerones, i think) that i get from the appetizer case, batter fried. The problem was they had no taste--nada, zilch. In retrospect we should have sent them back. But I digress--we ordered a pasta, which was served with eggplant and ricotta (maybe peppers too). This was a little bitter and slightly overcooked, but once the ricotta was mixed in it was creamy and quite tasty.

And then the absolute highlight of the meal, and one of the best entrees I have ever had (I'm an app person): lamb with cannelli beans. The lamb was seared with rosemary, perfectly med rare and served sliced. Hard to explain how wonderful this meat tasted, but each bite was a flavor explosion. beans were pretty good too, but less out-of-the-ordinary.

After that I was more inclined to try dessert and for $5 how could I resist--we had the lemon goat cheesecake and it was lovely. Not too goat-y (goat cheesecake never is) but very smooth with some high notes of goatness. A nice end to a pretty great meal.

Mentioned my dissapointment with the anchovies when the waiter came by to ask how I meal was--he didn't seem to care much, ce la vie.

For when I go back--any other pasta recommendations?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. p
    Pat Hammond RE: D-NY Apr 28, 2006 06:06 PM

    I miss Noodle Pudding. My son used to live just around the corner. I loved their skate dish. Try that if you see it on the menu sometime. And thanks for the vicarious meal! pat

    1 Reply
    1. re: Pat Hammond
      becky RE: Pat Hammond May 9, 2006 08:03 PM

      Tagliatelle with wild boar ragu!

    2. d
      Donnie RE: D-NY Apr 28, 2006 06:07 PM

      I have no further pasta recs but the pork chop with the stewed vinegar peppers is another outstanding entree.

      1. f
        Fleur RE: D-NY Apr 29, 2006 02:12 AM

        We have been disappointed by the not so terrific food at NOODLE PUDDING the last two dinners we had there.

        We much prefer going next door to HENRY'S END where the food is consistently excellent.

        1. b
          binkis RE: D-NY Apr 29, 2006 03:32 PM

          My wife and I LOVE Noodle Pudding! Next time you go, get the bolognese. It's out of this world.

          1. m
            mdog RE: D-NY Apr 30, 2006 10:09 PM

            Love this place- always great. Try the gnocchi in butter sauce- it's amazing- especially with a glass of red wine.

            1. j
              Jenn RE: D-NY May 1, 2006 10:28 AM

              The lasagna bolognese is amazing. For something lighter, the cappelini pomodoro with basil is my favorite. Love this place.

              1 Reply
              1. re: Jenn
                manco RE: Jenn Jan 24, 2008 02:04 PM

                I second that on the lasagna! mmmmmm

              2. r
                rowdynee RE: D-NY Jun 5, 2006 01:48 PM

                i have probably been to np twelve or more times in the past four years and find it to be very consistently excellent in terms of service and food. the strozzapretti is a favorite pasta dish among my friends. the roasted chicken is delicious.

                np was featured in 'tables for two' in the new yorker a couple months ago and i heard it's been pretty swamped since then, which may make service slower, etc. but i'd say it's still worth it for reliable, affordable, and tasty italian food at a comfortable, family owned restaurant.

                Show Hidden Posts