HOME > Chowhound > Outer Boroughs >


Birthday cake

  • s
  • 9

I'm looking for a great tasting birthday cake in Brooklyn. I know Sweet Melissa's on Court St. and Margaret Palca Bakes on Columbia St. make good cakes. Wondering if anyone knows of any other places.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. If you have a car, check out Baked in Red Hook. Their website is www.bakednyc.com. They have fabulous cakes and most of it is made to order. I ordered one for a birthday a few months ago and everyone loved it, especially their amazing buttercream frosting.

    1. We got ours from Monteleone's, also on Court Street. We had a devil's food cake with vanilla custard filling and another chocolate buttercream filling with a buttercream frosting which was colored orange for a Halloween theme. Monteleone's was recommended by several neighborhood vendors and residents and I know friends have used it since.

      We have also gotten an amazing cake for a friend from Downtown Atlantic, which was basically a big version of their cupcakes. However, it was expensive for the lack of decorating they did.

      1. Recent wedding cake thread. I'm sure many of these vendors do birthday cake too.

        Link: http://www.chowhound.com/topics/show/...

        1. I didn't get to read the other replys, but BAKED in red hook makes an amazing cake!! and they are not refrigerated, so the buttercream is silky smooth and ready to eat! they are on van b runt and have a website, google it. their pistachio cake is amazing, and the malted chocolate cake is great too!

          1. Sweet Melissa for buttercream cakes is very nice.
            Cafe Scaramouche, also on Court St., makes cakes with a really nice smooth icing finish, I forget what it's called, and the decorations are more creative than the average buttercream flower, etc, and the prices seem pretty good for the delicious quality!
            If you want a more affordable option, Court St Pastry Shop makes some pretty good, altough very basic, cakes as well.

            1. Does anyone know roughly how much cakes are at Baked>? I traded messages with them today but the prices are not on their site

              1. Three Red Hens on Eighth Avenue has never let me down for impeccable old school--ie very straightforward Magnolia Bakery style--cakes. Their Brooklyn Blackout is quite nice, as is their yellow cake with white icing and coconut. Also, Cake Man Raven's red velvet is deservedly famous, IMO.

                1. Almondine in DUMBO. Amazing cakes made to order...Also best baguette in Brooklyn and beyond...


                  1. Back in October we used Pathmark for a decorated sheetcake (a 2 year old's party), since Monteleone's was still not opened. We ended up being very pleasantly surprised with the cake, icing, decoration, etc. and received a lot of compliments.

                    But, last weekend we were at a party with a cake from Baked in Red Hook. It very well may have been the best slice of cake I've ever had. A deliecious butter cream frosting coverd a devil's food cake that had the perfect taste and consistency, filled with a peanut butter filling. This cake was perfection.