HOME > Chowhound > Outer Boroughs >
What's your latest food quest? Tell us about it
TELL US

2nd best coffee in Brooklyn is now in Brooklyn Heights?

r
Rick Elkins Oct 22, 2004 01:08 PM

Surprisingly, a just-opened cafe in Brooklyn Heights just might be serving the best coffee in Brooklyn (OK, after Gimme Coffee).

My wife and I saw it and stopped in on Wednesday night. The Cafe Chez Henry had just opened, but I was dubious... from what I know about the owners other places, I didn't really have high hopes.

But there behind the counter was a shiny new e61 Faema Legend...pretty impressive. So we ordered an espresso from the manager, whose name is Saeif, if I remember correctly.

He wasn't satisfied with the first shot, and threw it out...a sigh of high standards not commonly seen in this city. Then he threw out a second shot, offering an apology! This guy really cares about coffee!

Moments later he handed over a doppio ristretto in a warm ceramic cup. Extremely good...maybe the best in Brooklyn, and certainly better than anything in Brooklyn Heights, or anywhere else nearby for that matter.

He's grinding Dallis Coffee's "New York Espresso" blend fresh for every shot, and seems to care very much about keeping up the quality, so this place may be a real jewel.

Again, I have no idea about the restaurant, which has yet to open...this is the Cafe.

They also have what look to be good fruit tarts, croissants, sandwiches, etc. We had stopped in after dinner, so we didn't eat anything.

It is located near the corner of Henry and Cranberry Streets, on Henry.

  1. b
    bkeater Mar 9, 2008 07:22 AM

    Hands down-

    CAFE REGULAR - 11st between 4th and 5th

    1. Xiao Yang Feb 25, 2008 06:51 PM

      Do your rankings apply to brewed coffee as well? Have you tried the brewed-to-order coffee at Cafe Grumpy in Greenpoint? That $11,000 Clover brewing machine reminded me of the old San Francisco saw about never drinking coffee from a machine that weighs less than you do. All I can say is the cup I had at the Chelsea location reminded me of a good ol' North Beach Italian roast; perhaps they could call it a "heirloom" brew.

      4 Replies
      1. re: Xiao Yang
        p
        PAL Feb 26, 2008 06:37 AM

        I don't think the Greenpoint Grumpy has a Clover, just the 20th Street one. But in Brooklyn, I believe El Beit is brewing coffee this way (and their espresso is amazing, too) on Bedford and N. 9th.

        Cafe Grumpy in Greenpoint has really excellent drip coffee, though.

        1. re: PAL
          lambretta76 Feb 26, 2008 07:43 AM

          The "drip" from the Clovers in Manhattan are amazing. Only place where you can reliably get a choice of different decaf brews (don't hate me, but I had to give up caffeine in high amounts like in coffee and tea).

          I'm really going to miss the decaf Americanos I used to get at Brooklyn Bean & Tea - they were hands down the best coffee shop in the South Brooklyn area. (I do like the cafe on 11th St. or thereabouts in Park Slope that serves La Colombe.)

          1. re: lambretta76
            a
            apossibleworld Feb 28, 2008 06:51 AM

            I just went to El Beit. I'm not sure quite what I think of the Clover. Well, I think I liked it! What was interesting is that as I got to the end of my cup, and the coffee started getting colder, it still tasted good, if not better. I like the space there too, very clean and open for a tiny spot.

            1. re: apossibleworld
              m
              mrnyc Mar 6, 2008 04:33 PM

              what THE VICTORY is not good enough for you brooklynites anymore? ;)

      2. j
        JennS Feb 25, 2008 10:57 AM

        Is it open in the morning now? For a while they weren't opening until 11am.

        1 Reply
        1. re: JennS
          h
          heightsfamily Feb 25, 2008 02:07 PM

          Are you talking about Siggy's?

        2. j
          Jacob Oct 22, 2004 10:08 PM

          Thanks for the tip. I belive that Gorilla also uses an e61 Faema Legend: how would you compare the quality of the two places?

          I recently tried an espresso at the vaunted Gimme and was somewhat underwhelmed. What other places in Brooklyn do you think pull good shots?

          10 Replies
          1. re: Jacob
            f
            fortune elkins Oct 23, 2004 12:02 PM

            imvho, i find the coffee at gorilla extremely over-roasted. they mean well there, but the technical roasting style isn't to my taste.

            they buy a lot of their beans from royal coffee, which is good, specialty coffee, but to my mind the roasting style overwhelms the nuances that could be coaxed from this quality bean. finally, i'm just not impressed with the quality of beverage preparation there.

            gimme has several espresso blends, and if you didn't like, say, the leftist, then you might perhaps like the platinum blonde. ask the barista to try a different blend; they are usually happy to do this if the shop isn't crowded and they have time to dial in the robur grinder.

            the roastmaster for gimme does seem to prefer certain leathery notes in his coffee that's not going to be to everyone's taste. and he roasts more in a west-coast style.

            however their espresso machine, the hand-built, temperature- controlled mirage, is one of the best in the entire u.s.a., and their baristas continue to sweep coffee competitions for their skill in pulling shots and pouring latte art. chris deferio and mike white are fantastic baristi -- chris particularly is moving the art of the barista forward with his triple-laurel wreath latte art, which he pours with a lovely hand.

            saeif at cafe chez henry has the foundation of a great coffee program. but he does need to hire a pro barista to carry his coffee cuisine forward. steve schulman's (of dallis coffee) new york espresso blend is an interesting one in that it tries to straddle the east-coast, west-coast divide. it may have a strong central american/nicaraguan component, whereas many espresso blends are rooted in a brazil cerrado. . .i'm still sussing this out with every taste, myself.

            alas, we have mostly bad coffee in new york and bklyn. the victory at state & hoyt serves the wonderful batdorf dancing goat blend, but the owner, patrick, doesn't to my mind take proper care with machine cleanliness, coffee freshness, or consistent preparation.

            here in bklyn we do have some of the best coffee in the u.s.a. with gillies coffee leading the way for non-espresso. however, we lack coffeeshop owners who take their product seriously. it's near impossible to find a shop that makes the beverage properly, that maintains the machines, then holds the coffee at the right temperature for the right time, etc.

            it's really a shame. . . thus besides gimme, rarely the victory, and maybe saeif once he's been open for a while, good pulls are very tough to find, which is why most of the serious coffee lovers in bklyn i know have retreated to their homes, bought their own pro-sumer machines, and gone to workshops to learn to be their own barista. . .many are even home-roasting now. . .

            1. re: fortune elkins
              c
              chow chow Oct 23, 2004 01:11 PM

              where is "gimme"?

              1. re: chow chow
                h
                heightsfamily Feb 25, 2008 09:50 AM

                Good coffee in the Heights/DUMBO:

                1. Tazza
                2. Siggy's
                3. Coffee Box

                Bad Coffee:

                1. Plymouth
                2. Starbucks
                3. Cranberry's

                1. re: heightsfamily
                  NYJewboy Feb 25, 2008 06:23 PM

                  Bad coffee:
                  1. Tazza (stale and weak)
                  2. Siggy's (bad coffee bad machine)
                  3. Coffee Box (starbucks level)

                  Good coffee:
                  1. Gimmie Coffee
                  2. maybe this place that this guy is writing about. I have not yet tried it.

                  1. re: NYJewboy
                    h
                    heightsfamily Feb 25, 2008 07:29 PM

                    I must add Gimmie Coffee to the list as well. Respectfully disagree on Tazza and Siggy's.

                    1. re: NYJewboy
                      p
                      parkslopemama Mar 3, 2008 09:20 AM

                      The original post was from 2004. Is Cafe Chez Henry still there??

                      1. re: parkslopemama
                        h
                        heightsfamily Mar 3, 2008 02:54 PM

                        Long since closed.

                        1. re: heightsfamily
                          p
                          parkslopemama Mar 6, 2008 08:48 AM

                          Yeah, that's what I thought. So, NYJewboy, do not bother to try Chez Henry!

                  2. re: chow chow
                    Xiao Yang Feb 25, 2008 03:57 PM

                    Bingo!

                    -----
                    Gimme! Coffee
                    495 Lorimer St, Brooklyn, NY 11211

                  3. re: fortune elkins
                    g
                    gfood Feb 26, 2008 08:00 AM

                    I live on 5th ave in Brooklyn, and I have to agree with you on Gorilla. I find their coffee over roasted, more along the style of Starbucks, which I also do not like.

                    I know I'm in the minority here, but I think that Ozzie's does a great job with their roasts on fifth ave. I tend to stay away from the French Roasts, but their Vienna Roasts and American Roasts are excellent, in my opinion.

                    "Ozzie's blend", which they serve in their cafe, however, I do not particularly like; only their "take-out" beans.

                Show Hidden Posts