HOME > Chowhound > Outer Boroughs >

Discussion

Mike and Tony's in South Slope

  • j
  • 4

As a South Sloper, I can't help but be curious about
the new-ish Italian restaurant that opened recently on
6th Avenue and, I think, 11th St. (could be off by 1 or
2 streets).

Any word on it? Is it just another red sauce joint,
and if it is, does it at least do THAT well? I have
only managed to stop by when the kitchen has been
closed, but it looks like the place has quickly
attracted a tight little group of regulars.

Please post a followup if you have actually eaten there
(rather than gotten tipsy on red wine like I have).

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. Went there in late April 99, worth the trip. Good food
    and had decent service. Not as fancy nor full of air as
    tuta-pasta appears. I believe that the people who
    macks bar(?) on 8th avenue seem to run cousin tony.
    make the trip and enjoy a relaxed and good meal.

    1 Reply
    1. re: Ralph F

      I have no Idea what your saying.

    2. Not Mike and Tony's which is the steak place owed by
      the Cucina partners, but COUSIN TONY'S, at 12th St.And
      6th Ave. I live at 10th and 6th, so I have eaten there
      and got carry-out several times. At first it was great,
      a real find, then it got very crowded and they seem to
      have not been able to keep up. It is nice and
      reasonably priced and the protions are huge, but the
      last few times there have been a bit of a
      disappointment for me.
      It is certainly better than say Tutta Pasta or Aunt
      Suzie's, and you may get a good night, which is really
      good when you do.

      1 Reply
      1. re: Lisa R.

        It's me, er, JEssica Nepomuceno, who made the original post. Anyway, you're right, I messed up the name. But I did stop by for dinner one slow night...I had a hankering for lasagna. NASTY NASTY NASTY! Extremely gloppy bechemal sauce, tepid and soggy pasta. Lame all around. The service was very good, however, considering there were several large parties there.