HOME > Chowhound > Outer Boroughs >

Brooklyn Pie

Paul May 7, 1999 03:40 PM

I have heard rumors of a pie phenomenon in Brooklyn on
weekend mornings. Apparently people get on line very
early on weekend mornings to get pies in some
neighborhood in Brooklyn. If anyone knows anything
about this trend, please post a reply

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. s
    suze RE: Paul May 8, 1999 12:41 PM

    it might be "Steve's Key Lime Pies" in Redhook. The #
    is 718-858-5333 or www.keylime.com.

    2 Replies
    1. re: suze
      jg RE: suze May 8, 1999 05:56 PM

      it might be but I hope not. He makes only those lime pies, and he delivers to rests. in a really cool old fashioned truck. I tried to get him to do other pies or just even a lemon meringue but he won`t.

      1. re: jg
        wayne RE: jg Oct 24, 1999 09:37 PM

        The fruit pies at Peter's Ice Cream on Atlanti Ave. are really nice. I doubt it's the place you are refering to, but they are really well done. My fave is the peach-blueberry. I think it is the crust that makes these pies so good.

    Show Hidden Posts