HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >

Discussion

P.J. Clarke's

  • s
  • sing me a bar Mar 10, 2006 11:54 AM
  • 16
  • Share

Is it still good for a burger? Has anyone ventured in there recently?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
Posting Guidelines | FAQs | Feedback
Cancel
  1. Definetely nothing special. You are better off going to Burger Joint at Le Parker Meridien hotel.

    Link: http://www.muckraked.com

    1. i love the burger at pj clarke's. great flavor, great piece of onion underneath. the fries are phenomenal and the atmosphere can't be beat. if you want a crowded frat-style burger place with a great burger, go to the burger joint, but for a great burger in an old-school ny place, definitely go to pj's.

      3 Replies
      1. re: mj

        I second this thought.

        Maybe not the best burger in the city, but its delicious and has a great atmosphere.

        They are opening a PJ's on the West Side....Im psyched for that.

        1. re: CDB

          aren't they small though?

          1. re: Hon
            d
            david sprague

            depends how you define "small." they're not oversized specimens (like McHale's, R.I.P.), but they're hardly sliders. Thicker than the usual burger, if a bit smaller in circumfrence.

            I've never ranked 'em among the best in town, but they are pretty tasty, and made with good meat -- which I like better as a steak tartare.

      2. The burger's really good. Be sure to order a side dish of onion strings.

        1. not a destination burger for me..but whenever i end up there it's worth it. after the rennovation, maybe it's lost a bit of the rat pack charm.

          as an upper west sider, i look forward to another burger option in the 'hood.

          1 Reply
          1. re: harrison

            Absolutely. It won't have the charm of the original PJ's, but it sure as sh*t beats Merlot that has been abandoned for about 4 years.

          2. the burgers are consistently good, if not great. to me, PJ's is a way more satisfying experience than some of the "better" burgers around. Hardly ever a line for tables, no rush, good beer, lots of other sides on the menu...nice atmosphere, too.

            The burgers aren't small. They're denser and rounder than some, but totally filling. And lots of options for toppings! Yum.

            1. By the way, the food in their upstairs dining room - aka The Sidecar - is good too.

              3 Replies
              1. re: Sir Gawain

                Any wisdom regarding when to go to avoid a crowd? I'm thinking of taking an older relative for a weekday dinner. Is there a happy hour crowd between 5 and 7, or will i be able to get a table?

                1. re: EFrancis

                  I haven't been in a while but there was always an an after work/happy hour crowd. I don't think anything will have changed.

                  1. re: KTinNYC

                    I agree with KT...I work right across the st and the place is always packed around that time. I think the best time to hope for a 'quiet' burger there is probably between 2 and 4 in the afternoon......just a guess, but that's been my experience.

              2. Great burger there. Certainly among the top in the city, but not the best. Nice atmosphere too, but can be crowded after work. The burger is a little overpriced for its size, but is delicious. A better burger can be found at Melon's or Burger Joint. PJ Clarke's is still a solid option though. See the Academy Award winning "The Lost Weekend" which takes place at Clarke's.

                1. Haven't been to the PJ Clark in midtown lately, but have been to the one at Financial Center downtown few times. Significiantly worse than my experience in midtown. The whole burgers were cold, tasted like pre-made and sat for a long time. Salad was with wilt greens. The crab cakes were quite delicious though.

                  I didn't find the burgers to be small, but they have a 3 mini burger (sliders) option which I think was quite good. Great for sharing.

                  Agree with steve h. on the onion strings!

                  1 Reply
                  1. re: kobetobiko

                    Yeah, you MUST try the crabcakes at the midtown location, not a smidgen of filler.....and big!