HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >

Discussion

Best preparation of sweetbreads

  • r

Where can I find the best sweetbread dish in Manhattan (or Brooklyn)?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. i
    I_<3_NYC_FOOD

    My vote goes to Craft

    2 Replies
    1. re: I_<3_NYC_FOOD

      people seem to love craft's...i like gramercy tavern's a lot...but thats about it as i think the restaurant as a whole is very 'meh'

      1. re: sam

        I still think GT's are the best in the city. The Craft sweetbreads, while good, can't hold a candle the the buttery, perfect rendition at GT.

        S

    2. I haven't been to Craft (although now I am REALLY wanting to try their sweetbreads), but the ones I had at Babbo were prepared quite nicely.

      1 Reply
      1. re: MM

        I agree that it's Babbo.

      2. I can't claim to have done much comparison shopping, but I enjoyed the sweetbreads at Blue Ribbon quite a lot.

        1. I have not had them in a while, and they are on the menu only occasionally, but Chantarelle makes a very good preparation in an orange sauce with, I believe, leeks.

          1. I may prefer Craftbar's to Craft's at the moment. La Luncheonette has a fine sweetbread salad.

            1. My partner and I tried the sweetbreads at Craftbar last night. Very good, but I can now officially say that the preparation at Applewood in Brooklyn (11th St., just above 7th Ave.) is better. So if Craftbar's are among the best in the city, I guess that would mean that Applewood's are, as well.

              If you get out there to try them, get the lamb w/ lentils off the menu as well - very, very good.

              1. Any updates for the new year (and new restaurants)?
                Thanks for the help.

                3 Replies
                1. re: JerseyJoe2

                  I really love the sweetbreads at Prune. A lot of acidity to cut through the richness.

                  1. re: Miss Needle

                    An enthusiastic second to the sweetbreads at Prune. Heaven!

                  2. re: JerseyJoe2

                    The sweetbreads at Convivio are excellent.

                  3. The sweetbread dish at Casa Mono is delectable.