Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >
May 3, 2005 05:32 PM

German food?

  • v

Is there good German food in Manhattan? I'm coming to visit, and would love to find a great joint. Where I live there is nothing noteworthy. I'm staying in Midtown, location doesn't really matter, but close would be a plus.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Loreley is my favorite in Manhattan. But nothing to write home about, unfortunately, except the kaese-spaetzle,

    3 Replies
    1. re: Nina W.

      Loreley knows beer... and I'm not a usual beer drinker.

      1. re: Delilah

        As well as some terrific pretzels.

        1. re: Delilah

          so how does it compare to zum schneider's beer list? i bet they dont have aventinus on tap!

      2. Zum Schneider certainly seems authentic for beer garden food and the beer is great.
        For Austrian food (same language and zeitgeist?) take the subway to Queens to Thomas Beisel (sp?), search the outer boroughs board.

        1. Rolf's on 22nd and 3rd Avenue in Manhattan- Yummy and Festive

          3 Replies
          1. re: WombatNYC

            Rolf's is overpriced and the food is mediocre, but the atmosphere/decor is fun and unusual.

            1. re: Nina W.

              I live on the same block as Rolf's, and I love it for a drink with all their wacky lights and birds and everything. The food (well, this is actually a non-preference for German food in general) is very heavy, but not horrible. The best part is that the wafting Rolf smells coming from the kitchen, which I can sometimes smell from my window. It's kind of gross, but I also kind of like it. I wouldn't say it was a destination, but fun/fine if you're in the nabe.

            2. re: WombatNYC

              Cannot recommend Rolf's either. Bad quality and expensive.

            3. You could do a lot worse than Zum Schneider. Just be prepared to wait. Not that I mind, it's just more time to enjoy their hard-to-find German brews.

              3 Replies
              1. re: jamie

                Zum Schneider has the best authentic German food in Manhattan - it's on Ave B which is a hike from your hotel but worth it. Lorely is good but not as tastey as Zum Schneider.

                1. re: MD

                  Zum Schneider is at the corner of Ave. C and 10th St. Go there when the weather is nice and sit outside.

                  1. re: Roland

                    zum schneider is on the corner of 7th and ave. C. it is delicious

              2. If you are in midtown you might try the 'wurst' cart which is on 55th st and 5th Ave -- Tues through Fri from about 11:30 to 3. It's just a cart but it is quite good and authentic, with a wide variety of wurts.