Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >
Jan 29, 2005 06:10 PM

good Indian E. 20s Lex

  • o

Can anyone recommend an inexpensive to moderately priced good Indian restaurant in the 20s Lexington Ave area?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Curry Leaf is great.

    4 Replies
      1. re: gaj

        Wow. Is this post from a long time ago. Well, in case people are still discussing this: my votes, in descending order of preference:

        Saravanaas - 81 Lexington Ave on NE corner of 26th St
        Pongal - 110 Lexington Ave btwn 26th & 27th
        Chennai Garden - 129 E. 27th btwn Park & Lex (tie)
        Madras Mahal - 104 Lexington Ave btwn 27th & 28th

        1. re: Jorel

          I will add enthusiastic seconds to Pongal, Channai Garden, and Madras Mahal - but my order of preference is just the reverse. Time to head over to Saravanaas to see if we agree on 4 for 4.

          1. re: Jorel

            I am in complete agreement with your choice of Saravanaas. It is the most authentic S. Indian food I have had in Manhattan.

      2. Depends on the definitions of what you are looking but Vatan on 29th & 3rd is absolutely fantastic. $24/person with a beautiful setting and wonderful indian vegetarian.

        2 Replies
        1. re: Tom

          What did you enjoy at Vatan, I didn't think my meal was fantastic, it was okay enough, but far from fantastic...

          1. re: Janie

            Doesn't this place have no windows? That's pretty much a non-starter for me when it comes to restaurants.

        2. Pongal (Lex btw 27/28) is my overall favorite.

          Chennai Garden (27th btw Lex/Park) is your best bet for buffet lunch or for dosas.

          Roomali (28th btw Lex/3rd) is fun for quick-service wraps. Nice and spicy.

          For the really cheap steam-table fare, my favorite is New Niamat Kada (Lex btw 28/29), followed closely by Haandi (Lex btw 27/28). Both have combo platters for around $6, including fresh naan baked on the premises. Haandi always has more options, but I find the food a bit more consistent at New Niamat Kada.

          I just revisited Curry Leaf this afternoon for lunch, and was underwhelmed by the lunch special. My saag paneer had a grand total of 2 tiny cubes of cheese in it. The best thing I tasted was the tandoori platter - they managed to keep the chicken nice and moist.

          Vatan is a bit more expensive than all the other places mentioned. It's fun, in that you get to sit on the floor with your shoes off, and they give you an assortment of small plates, with unlimited refills of the ones you like.


          1 Reply
          1. re: Viv

            I second Pongal. Yum.

          2. hi there
            was just in pongal recently.. especially with all the tables filled up and all that i have heard about it.
            i got the bhel puri (snack appetizer) and then the Indian thali.. which has a bit of everything..
            i was not happy with the bhel puri at all.. couldnt get any more bland than that... no spice.. no lemon juice.. no taste.. all the street food dishes of india have that lip smacking taste to it.. considering the price i would have expected better bhel puri
            the thali was alright.. i also got puri with it.. which were huge in size!
            overall i think i will continue at chennai garden instead..
            i give pongal a big plus on the decor.. but when it comes to the culinary taste.. it just doesnt hit it right for me! i would rather head somewhere with great food and ok atmosphere than the other way around (unless ofcourse u are taking a date to pongal)... dont order the bhel

            1. Saravanaas and Chennai Garden. Both are vegetarian but boy are they yummy!