HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >
What's your latest food quest?
TELL US

Upper East Side Eats?

l
LED Aug 29, 2001 05:07 PM

I just moved to the Upper East Side (and just found this website due to The New Yorker!) I'm looking for suggestions for great food in my new neighborhood. Any ideas?

  1. e
    eva l. Aug 29, 2001 05:10 PM

    Red Cat on 75th bet. 1st and 2nd is great. the pre-fixe is a great bargain.

    BBQ on 72nd and 3rd is fine for take-out.

    JG Melon's on 75th and 3rd serves a great burger.

    EJ's is ok, but the wait for weekend breakfast is ridiculous.

    Coconut Grill, Googies should be stayed from.

    hope this helps. welcome to the neighborhood and let us all know what you try.

    18 Replies
    1. re: eva l.
      m
      Matt Aug 30, 2001 01:49 PM

      here are a bunch of places I like on the upper east side:

      bagels:
      * Tal Bagels, 86th bet. 1st and 2nd [branch on 60 something and 1st, too]

      pizza:
      * John’s Pizzeria, 64th between 1st and York (pies only--no slices) [other branches in village, etc.]
      * Georgio's Pizza on 2nd (I think) around 70th or so--not a traditional NY slice (a little gourmet for my taste), but pretty good nonetheless [other storefront on union square]

      italian:
      * Trattoria Rustica, 85th bet. 1st and 2nd

      american:
      * Sharz, around 90th and 3rd
      * Barking Dog—about 78th and York--great comfort food if you can ignore the annoying people who eat there--for brunch try the poached eggs with caviar and creme fraiche (forgot the actual name of the dish)

      vietnamese:
      * Saigon Grill—around 87th and 1st

      marzipan:
      * ELK Candy Company, on 2nd between 85th and 84th

      bacon, lettuce, and tomato sandwich:
      * Viand, 86th and 2nd

      chinese:
      * Wu Liang Ye, 86th bet. 2nd and 3rd (currently undergoing renovations)

      french (+ great hamburgers, moules frites):
      * Brasserie Julian--3rd and about 83rd or so

      mexican:
      * taco taco--wondeful little place--try the puerco enchilada torta

      my request--if anyone knows of a good NY slice on the upper east side, I'd be eternally grateful for the suggestion (seeing as I eat pizza at least once a day, and have yet to find a great slice in this area)

      best,

      Matt

      Link: http://www.guidetocinema.com

      1. re: Matt
        b
        Beth P. Aug 30, 2001 03:33 PM

        Matt, it might be a little far north for you, but have you tried Patsy's for slices (or pies)? It's on 2nd between 117 and 118, if memory serves. No exotic toppings (not even eggplant), just delicious, thin, crispy, bubbly crust, great sauce and the perfect amount of cheese, all cooked in an ancient coal oven.

        1. re: Beth P.
          e
          Eva L. Aug 30, 2001 05:00 PM

          There's also a Patsy's on 70 Street and 2nd Avenue (on the NE corner, I think?)

          1. re: Eva L.
            b
            Beth P. Aug 30, 2001 06:06 PM

            From what I understand, Patsy's is a licensed name (ie: there's no connection except for the name), and the only one that's good is the one in East Harlem.

            1. re: Eva L.
              e
              elayne aschkenes Sep 1, 2001 10:20 PM

              Patsy's on 69th street is very good, so is John's on 64th st between 1st and York

          2. re: Matt
            s
            s sale Aug 30, 2001 05:53 PM

            Danny's Pizza on 2nd avenue between 87 and 88th is a tiny place that serves the best traditional pizza by the slice on the upper east side(59-96 st//York-5th ave)

            Eli's cafe at 91st and York just put in a pizza oven-also good but a bit pricey at 2.15 for a small slice.

            Aghatha and Valencia(79 +1st ave)) sells various cheese and tomato foccacias from 10AM until they run out.

            Patsy's uptown on 117th and 1st tops the above three.

            1. re: s sale
              m
              mkgold Sep 1, 2001 01:19 PM

              Thanks for the tip about Danny's pizza. I tried it yesterday, and thought that it was pretty good--but it definitely did not blow me away.

              I usually like a little more sauce than they used (almost none), and also, I found something very strange about their slices--they dripped water. Usually, when one folds a slice of pizza, one sees red-tinged oil drip from the back of the crust. But this was not oil--it was water. Could it be that they're using very fresh mozzarella, and that the water is coming from that? I found it strange, whatever it was.

              Anyway, while I do appreciate the tip, I have to say that my search for a good slice of pizza on the Upper East Side continues...

              best,

              Matt

              Link: http://www.guidetocinema.com

            2. re: Matt
              d
              Dan-o Sep 4, 2001 04:24 PM

              Matt --

              Viand, Trattoria Rustica, Saigon Grill, they all rock...

              Pizza is a different story on the UES. Almost all are disappointing (I will give Danny's a try though). My advice is to go to John & Tony's (1st Avenue at 60th St.). To date (3+ years and running) it beats everything else I've tried up here.

              Enjoy,
              Dan-o

              1. re: Dan-o
                m
                Matt Sep 4, 2001 05:28 PM

                Thanks for the suggestion, Dan-O--I'll give John & Tony's a try and get back to you.

                best,

                Matt

                1. re: Dan-o
                  m
                  Matt Sep 4, 2001 09:22 PM

                  I tried John & Tony's tonight, Dan-O (couldn't wait!), and thought it was very good--exactly what I was looking for. Thanks so much for the suggestion.

                  Matt

                2. re: Matt
                  j
                  Jutta Sep 10, 2001 04:35 PM

                  Matt, I understand that you are the real Pizza specialist here, but why don't you try some unusual Pizza (whole grain flour, unusual toppings) at Pintaile's on 2nd Ave between 64th and 65th. It's sold by the slice. Although they run in a different category, I think they beat John's (with its dry mushroom toppings... on 64th anytime for flavor.

                  Jutta

                  1. re: Jutta
                    k
                    kan Sep 24, 2001 06:18 PM

                    pintaile's has a location on 77th and york, too.

                  2. re: Matt
                    m
                    Matt Sep 23, 2001 03:19 PM

                    I think that I have finally found good pizza by the slice on the Upper East Side:

                    Gino's Pizzeria, on 83rd between 1st and 2nd, right next to Triangolo.

                    Great cheese (and a lot of it), fresh ingredients, garlic-infused tomato sauce, delicious crust.

                    Finally!

                    Matt

                    1. re: Matt
                      c
                      ChristineNYC Nov 16, 2007 09:16 AM

                      Try Zesty's on 95th & Third Avenue. Amazing Marinara sauce.
                      for fresh pizza, there's also Nick's restaurant on 94th & 2nd. both are great.

                      1. re: ChristineNYC
                        j
                        jackieparis Nov 17, 2007 07:18 AM

                        I think Slice pizza on 2nd and 74th is great! It's healthy and has great toppings.

                      2. re: Matt
                        u
                        UES Mayor Nov 17, 2007 02:30 AM

                        Saigon Grill on 88th and 2nd has been "closed" going on two yrs now! btw what's the update on this place?

                        1. re: Matt
                          b
                          blanchita121 Jan 4, 2008 10:12 AM

                          Anna Maria's on 1st and 83rd has awesome slices! I used to live on 85th and would get their slices all the time! Their slices are good and crunchy. I always ask for well-done (not black) and it's great!

                        2. re: eva l.
                          c
                          claire Nov 2, 2004 02:18 PM

                          Ota-ya is really good fresh sushi for a staple night and they deliver faster than you can imagine
                          Barking dog has the best cobb salad in the whole universe
                          Annies is also a good one for brunch.

                        3. h
                          howard Aug 29, 2001 05:55 PM

                          My favorites are Etat Unis at 242 E.81st(between 2nd and 3rd Ave.) and their wine bar across the street.Get the chocolate souffle.Small places,friendly service,interesting wine list( drink Chinon), menu small and determined by what's fresh per markets.

                          1. e
                            Ellysa Aug 29, 2001 10:12 PM

                            Don't miss Dan Maxwell's on Second btw 89th and 90th. Terrific steaks and the best sauteed mushrooms I've ever had.

                            1. k
                              kate Aug 30, 2001 02:05 PM

                              Other suggestions:
                              Sirabella's on york in 80s has good italian (and good for takeout, too).
                              For French, Etats-Unis.
                              For Mexican, Zocalo in 80s off 3rd has interesting selections (not your typical burrito-type Mexican).
                              A takeout place i like is Chicky's on 86th bet 1-2 - kind of a dump but they make great cheap grilled chicken salads (salad not always as fresh as could be desired, but great if you have your own salad makings)
                              Agata on 79th and 1st has good produce and some prepared foods - check this out vs. Eli's Market on 3rd and 80th, which has very nice quality produce but absurd prices
                              The Sultan on 2nd in 70s has good Turkish/Middle Eastern.
                              DTUT on 2nd bet. 84-85 is a good Starbucks alternative.

                              1. j
                                jojo Aug 30, 2001 02:38 PM

                                la tour, your basic neighborhood bistro, on 3rd and 75 (or 74?) has a great $15 all you can eat mussel and frites special (everyday!) Make sure to choose the "la tour" version-- with mustard and rosemary in the broth. The mesclun and goat cheese is a good starter for this meal.
                                Welcome to the neighborhood!

                                1. b
                                  Brian Wickham Aug 31, 2001 12:13 AM

                                  On the premise that you can't spend a lot of money every night I would suggest the Mansion Diner at York and 86 St. Really good: chicken burger, tuna melt, egg salad sandwich, beef stew, chicken ala king, chicken pot pie, meat loaf, the coffee is always good, and the apple crumb pie ala mode is great. The marble pound cake is moist - a rarity these days. The staff is very nice and the prices are dirt cheap. Two of us eat there for $17 to $23 total, usually. I almost forgot: the chicken noodle soup is unbelievable!

                                  The Comfort Diner at 86th and Lex is a sad impostor in a world of good food. And they charge you a bundle for the privilege of eating there.

                                  For pizza give Candidos a try. They're at 1st Ave btwn 83 & 84 Street. Coal brick oven pizza that is very much like an Arthur Ave pie in the Bronx. A subtle taste that sneaks up on you. The first slice will taste bland but the second will have you hooked. It's like John's, only with really good tasting crust. Whole pies only. Another plus is they are family owned and operated, and also nice people.

                                  I'm convinced you can't get eggs cooked properly on the eastside unless you go to Viand on Madison Ave but that can be expensive for breakfast and I don't like their home fries. On weekends we still go to Big Nick's on Broadway and 77 Street.

                                  1 Reply
                                  1. re: Brian Wickham
                                    w
                                    wanttoeatout Nov 15, 2002 11:30 AM

                                    any other restaurants recommended upper eastside NYC.
                                    70th-90th, 1st, 2nd aves

                                  2. m
                                    MARK Aug 31, 2001 01:24 AM

                                    HIYA..CHECK OUT CANYON ROAD ON FIRST AND 75-76? FOR SOME REAL NICE SOUTHWESTERN FARE!

                                    1. l
                                      LED Aug 31, 2001 12:29 PM

                                      This is all so wonderful! Thank you everyone for your suggestions. I can't wait to try these places!

                                      -LED

                                      2 Replies
                                      1. re: LED
                                        a
                                        Andy Stauffer Aug 31, 2001 02:25 PM

                                        I second the Barking Dog -- 2 locations now, 94th/Third and York Avenue somewhere;

                                        Pesce Pasta on Third at 88th Street has a great antipasto spread, and I like the lasagna bolognese;

                                        Pollo at 91st and First for Peruvian chicken -- although I'm not sure if they're still open -- they were closed for renovations for awhile;

                                        Pretty good burgers at Island on Madison/92nd;

                                        I agree with the Wu Liang Ye recommendation for Chinese; avoid Pic Up Stix at all cost;

                                        Welcome to the 'hood!

                                        1. re: Andy Stauffer
                                          p
                                          Pete Sep 28, 2001 05:06 PM

                                          Pollo is now Pio Pio; still good.

                                          Candido Pizza on 1st Ave @ 82/83rd St is most excellent NYC-style pie ... best in the city. Wow, 2 posts in one day and both mention Candido... maybe I do need to go there tonight...

                                      2. g
                                        Graciela Sep 5, 2001 06:41 PM

                                        Here are my picks for the UES:
                                        Japanese - Ikeno Hana (73rd & Lex)
                                        Italian take out - Vivolo (74th bet. lex & Park)
                                        Diner - Three Guys (76th & Madison)or EJ's on third and 73rd.
                                        Chicken & Ribs - BBQ on 3rd ave & 73rd
                                        French - Orsay on 75th & Lex (great fries)
                                        prepared food - Citerella on 3rd & 75th st. or Grace's on 71st street. What's reall good but really expensive is William Poll on Lex & 75th st. They've been around for 100 years, they have the best sandwiches (Woody Allen ordered them while shooting film) plus the best chips and dip.
                                        Good luck!

                                        1. s
                                          Siegel Oct 12, 2003 01:18 PM

                                          I like Vinci's Pizza on 1st Ave in the lo 60's. Let me know what you think.

                                          2 Replies
                                          1. re: Siegel
                                            c
                                            CEB280 Nov 16, 2007 09:45 AM

                                            Totonos Pizza is super good.
                                            Bistro Le Steak is great for brunch and has a great "Le Steak Burger" and french onion soup!
                                            Etats Unis is really good
                                            Vinyl is good for cheap breakfast

                                            1. re: CEB280
                                              a
                                              ann_mit_01 Nov 17, 2007 08:13 AM

                                              Bistro 61 (61st + 1st) for gnocci / risotto / burger-topped-with-foie-gras
                                              Nick's (95th +2nd) for penne with vodka sauce / calzone / thin crust pizza

                                          2. c
                                            chow3 Nov 17, 2007 10:44 AM

                                            PIZZA: I recommend Italian Village on First Avenue in the 80s for delivery. It is wonderful, old-school pizza. They have great white pizza and cannolis. John's, as recommended above, would be the alternative for a thinner crust pizza. In my experience, the Patsy's locations are mediocre.

                                            My other recommendation would be the Bar at Etas Unis -- it's a little wine bar across from the Etats Unis restaurant (recommended above and wonderful) which is more low-key and affordable and one of my absolute favorite places on the UES.

                                            I also think that the best prepared food is at Grace's on 71st and Third. They have good catering and the trattoria next door is a great place for a casual lunch or dinner -- good pannini's.

                                            My favorite bakery is Two Little Red Hens and my favorite bagel is Pick-A-Bagel. I like their black and white cookies better than William Poll.

                                            1. g
                                              girlcritic Nov 17, 2007 10:57 AM

                                              I'm with the last poster. Italian Village is BEST for pizza. Bar at Etas-Unis great for dinner. Donguri for homestyle Japanese. Inase and Gayjumura for Sushi. Wui Lang for Schezuan. Red Hen for pastries. Pio Pio for Chicken. What else? Land Thai is pretty decent. Elio's for Italian.

                                              1 Reply
                                              1. re: girlcritic
                                                j
                                                jeanki Jan 5, 2008 05:53 AM

                                                For eat in pizza I think Nick's is wonderful. Love all the fresh basil.

                                              2. b
                                                bastet212 Jan 4, 2008 06:09 AM

                                                How about good, CHEAP food up here....

                                                1 Reply
                                                1. re: bastet212
                                                  j
                                                  jeanki Jan 5, 2008 05:54 AM

                                                  Try El paso taqueria on 97th between park and mad, authentic Mexican, very flavorful and cheap.

                                                  There's a new authentic ramen joint, Naruto Ramen around 91st and 3rd. Cheap cheap.

                                                  Also like Buddha BBeeq around 92nd and 2nd, fresh pan Asian (Korean owned) trendy storefront, tasty for the prices.

                                                  If you want reasonably priced Italian-American comfort food Ottomanelli Grill on 94th and Lex is good and the steaks are a relative bargain.

                                                2. e
                                                  EatDrinkAndBeMary Jan 4, 2008 09:15 AM

                                                  Uva on 2nd between 77th and 78th--great rustic italian food and wine bar--kinda pricy.
                                                  Beyoglu on 81st and 3rd for Mediterranean tapas on the cheap
                                                  The new Hi-Life on 78th and 2nd has a great atmosphere and 1/2 price sushi on mon and tues...not to mention giant martinis.
                                                  Vespa on 2nd between 83 and 85 (can't remember which block!) is also great italian and has a really cool back garden when it's not freezing.
                                                  Bardolino on 78th and 2nd is also pretty delish, if you can get past the fact that it looks like a cheap hotel lobby.
                                                  Iron Sushi on 78th between 1st and 2nd is great for eat in or take out.
                                                  La Tour, as Jojo said, is also great basic french fare with killer mussels.

                                                  By the way DTUT coffee shop has been closed for a good 6 months and a wine bar is opening there soon.

                                                  Show Hidden Posts