Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >
May 26, 2001 04:39 PM

Hotdog fillings

  • s

What type of fillings do Americans put in there dog apart from Ketchup, Mustard and Saurkraut and is there such a thing as a gourmet hot dog?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Here is the midwesst don't always see sauerkraut, ketchup/mustard/relish are staples as are chopped onions for those wanting more kick. Chili is always very popular--Detroit has really first-class coney island--sauce is spicy in a chili sauce with very finely ground beef. Chili dogs are ubiquitous anywhere dogs are sold. "Gourmet" dogs probably refer to the quality of the hotdog --all- beef/kosher. Well regarded brands are Koegel's and of course the popular Ball Park.

    1. Stephen, I'm moving my reply to the General board before this topic takes off. Meet you there? pat

      4 Replies
      1. re: Pat Hammond

        Where is it??? (Sorry I'm just a poor stupid Scots bloke!!)

        1. re: Stephen Tait

          Here's the link to the main board. Scroll down to the little map, and you'll find the link. And lots of other stuff, too.

          By the way, if you come here to do research on hot dogs, ask for "toppings", not "fillings". You're British?


          1. re: ironmom

            Got to the little map but pressed New York and ended back at where I started. ALthough I now have opened up a debate in Chicago!! Not only am I Scottish, I'm obviously stupid too!!

          2. re: Stephen Tait

            Stephen: I apologize for assuming you knew your way around! You found the Manhattan board, one of the regional boards specific to food in Manhattan. The General board is for more general food discussions. I'll include a link for you at the bottom of this post to the General board. You can get back to the Homepage from there too.
            You probably came in through the Homepage, where you'll find a feature that will make life easy for you around here. It's called Hot Posts. This will show you all of the different boards and up-to-the-minute postings for the current date. Take a moment to get your bearings while on the Homepage, which is, by the way, a treasure trove of goodies.
            If troubles persist, let me know. And welcome! Pat


        2. d
          david sprague

          while this discussion will probably move to general topics before too long...

          suggesting ketchup on a dog is like suggesting, oh, i don't know....pineapple on pizza. it's a no-no for any serious dog aficionado.

          i'm usually a mustard only guy. sometimes onions, sometimes chili (if i trust the place's version thereof). for some reason, i've never cared for sauerkraut on a hotdog, though i do love it with kielbasa.

          here in queens, there are a lot of south/central american luncheonettes/snack stands that serve interesting takes on the dog, identified, variously as "Colombian" or "Ecuadorian." key ingredients include raw onion, a sweetish dressing somewhere between russian and thousand island and to top it off, crushed potato chips. takes some getting used to, but can be very, very addictive.

          1. j
            Jonathan White, cheesemaker

            Yers ago, I had a friend with an apartment on West West 54th (more or less). Her sixth-floor walkup faced the back court, which was the home port for a huge fleet of grubby hot dog vendor wagons.

            Each morning, long before the sun was up, the most horrific stench would waft and seethe its way up the fire escape-a fetid odor that could kill you in your sleep, just by power of suggestion.

            The source of this hazmat: 50 lb sacks of stinking, squishy-rotten onions were being chopped and mixed with god-knows-what to make that famous onion relish, to give a NYC hot dog that "je ne sais quoi".

            Oh yes, there is a truly urban Urban Legend in NY: if you eat a hot dog and don't drink down a coke with it, you'll explode. I've never dared to test this one.



            1. Theres a variant sometimes called a Coney Island hot dog topped with mustard , chopped onions and a ground meat sauce ( looks like coffee grounds ). I have no idea what was in the sauce but the combination was great.