Chelsea Lobster Company
Eh. I've been several times, and usually get the spicy crawfish roll; that's tastier than their lobster. You want lobster? Not that I should be telling you this, but head (further) downtown to Pearl Oyster Bar (Cornelia st. near w. 4th) or Mary's Fish Camp (W. 4th & Charles) for amazing lobster rolls and steamed lobsters. There's no describing them. Umm. But get there early, because there's always a wait.