HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >
What are you cooking today? Get great advice
TELL US

Mary's Fish Shack

t
Tinky Feb 14, 2001 04:06 PM

I enjoyed dinner at the new Mary's Fish Shack on W. 4th and Charles. The place is small and laid-back with friendly and gracious service. Even though there was a line waiting for tables, the waitress let me and my friend finish our heart-to-heart chat with out the usual rude your time is up gestures.

We shared a yummy salad and both ordered the red snapper special that was baked in a crust of thinly sliced potatoes with a horseradish sauce. It's a small menu and glancing around the room I noticed a lot of people snarfing down lobster rolls, lobster pot pies and finely julienned crispy fries. Luckily, we saved room for dessert -- a grown-up hot fudge sundae with a very generous amount of dark chocolate hot fudge.

  1. m
    Murphy Feb 21, 2001 01:36 PM

    I too have been to Mary's and I must say it is EXCELLENT! I had the lobster pot pie. Chockfull of lobster in a wonderful sauce with potatoes and vegetables and a wonderfully light pastry top. My friend had the shellfish bisque which was yummy, yummy. I would recomend this place to anyone at any time.

    Show Hidden Posts