- Eric Jaenichen Nov 11, 2000 11:37 AM
Hi, I'm wondering if anyone can point out where you can get the best hamburger in NYC. Thanks!!
I'm crazy about burgers at Corner Bistro, Jane St & W.4th St, $5. + great fries, & for beer I order a "dark", & sit on a stool at picture window. Love this neighborhood place. (someone on this board recently used the word "squalor" to describe this wonderful place, it got a big laugh from me.)
Cozy Soup and Burger, west side of Broadway at the intersection of Broadway and Astor Place in Manhattan.
As some wise soul already pointed out, there is no contest for the best burger in NYC...
Corner Bistro. Period.
Note: The Bistro has received some increased popularity and tourism over the years, which has made it more crowded and makes for a longer wait for a table. The eponymous "Bistro Burger" is a bacon cheeseburger, and with a couple of McSorleys Dark, gets you fully satisfied for about 8 bucks.
When corner bistro's good, it's very good indeed. I also love the old NY pubby ambiance and the jukebox. but there are two chefs, both mexican immigrants, and one is an angel, the other the devil (in personality as well as cooking style). I can tell in one bite who's working.
For burgers perhaps as good as the corner bistro's best, but more consistent (also they have a fireplace), I go to Molly's on 2nd and 22nd. Though Donovan's in Woodside, Queens (also a branch in Bayside) is better than all.
re: Jim Leff
Molly's is a definite favorite here. Also on the list is Island Burger that charlie mentioned on this thread and Zocalo's hamburgesa mexicana. The one thing to remember if going to Molly's for a sunday lunch is to take your sunglasses with you - going out to the sun after consuming your burger and a couple of beers in the dark can be a blinding experience :-)
I'm gonna be on the fence on this one and give you a few suggestions:
Cheyenne Diner on 33rd and 9th: Definitely the penultimate griddle fried diner chesseburger, and they use buffalo meat. Cant go wrong, especially since "Re-Run" from "Whats Happening" is a frequent customer.
Jackson Hole: Sort of touristy but its definitely a quality burger.
McSorleys (East Village): Its cheap, its basic, its good eatin, and it goes well with a few pints of light and dark.
re: Jason Perlow
With all due respect...I HATE the hamburgers at Jackson Hole. The are so big that in order to cook them they cover each burger on the grill, so you lose that great grill flavor and end up with a burger that is steamed...Yuck!
Last week I had a burger at Lucky Stike on Grand street and I was suprised by how good it was. It is certainly worth another try.
I nominate Brew's on E 34 St. (between Lex and 3rd)...perhaps not THE best burger in the city, but pretty damned good. And a good old bar up front, too. Brew's has been there since the late '30s, and it's named after the original owner's last name (Brew), not a weak joke on brewing beer.
I brought an out-of-town friend there...he took a look around and commented, wisely, "Ah, this is the place all the other burger bars are imitating."
Worth a detour.
re: Peter Krass
Thanks to your suggestion, I just returned from lunch at Brew's where I had a positively lovely time. Had the burger--rare--and it was cooked perfectly and the french fries that accompanied it were terrific--shoestring-style with skin. My lunch companion had the turkey burger and she commented that it was moist and juicy. We both left nothing on our plates.
The atmosphere was warm and cozy and given the rotten weather today, neither of us wanted to leave. So we opted for dessert and stayed a little longer.
Thanks for making a dull day a bit brighter.
Just saw this thread and have to throw my $.02 in! A different neighborhood altogether...the burgers at JG Melons on 74th St. and 3rd Ave. are VERY GOOD indeed. As are the "cottage fries." And they even make a variety of Bloody Mary at the bar with beef boullion...I think it's an old classic that you just don't see much anymore.
Obviously Corner Bistro (how could it have taken so long to say this?). The delays on a peak time weekend burger are horrendous though - right out the door!
Lunchtime or early evening burger eaters could do a lot worse than the ones at the Beer Bar on the corner of 45th and Vanderbilt in the bottom of the Met LIfe (old PanAm building). They are big, tasty, properly accessorized (great onion strings and fat fries) and decent value at $10 (in Midtown). Not the raucous bar scene of many others mentioned but great burgers.
As of late, I've had an irrational craving for cheeseburgers. Normally, I'm theoretically opposed to cheeseburgers--especially when eaten with an ice cream drink. But I was at Duke's on 19th between Park and Third last Monday around 5:30 with the express purpose of satisfying that craving. The menu said they were Angus meat--another minus IMO--since I find the whole black angus thing--yet another advertising ploy to grab the fat-phobic market, but I ordered anyway. Medium, cheddar. It came w/o onion or pickle, only tomato and shredded lettuce. Another minus. But it was at least 6 oz, and served on a bun that was kaiser like. No juice was oozing out over the plate. Yet! Yet! When I bit in, it was superb. The meat was light, moist and had the flavor of--BEEF. The fries were wonderful also. I'm gonna give this place another try, because I suspect this burger was an exception and not the rule. The fries and anything fried at Dukes--so far are the rule.
As for Jackson Hole burgers, imagine the 50's sci-fi movie, "The Amazing Colosal Man" being played by a White Castle Burger before being caught before the Nuclear Blast. After the White Castle Burger survives the blast--it would shed its pickle and mutate, growing to ungodly heights--becoming THE JACKSON HOLE BURGER.