HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >


Stephen M. Blakley May 1, 2000 08:18 PM

What happened to Goldbergs Pizza on 53rd Street and 2nd Ave? Wife and I have been going there for over 30 years! Did it open somewhere else?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. b
    bryan RE: Stephen M. Blakley May 2, 2000 06:50 AM

    Alas, I'm not in New York but I'm curious to know if this is the same Goldbergs Calvin Trillin waxes on about.

    14 Replies
    1. re: bryan
      Barb. H. RE: bryan May 2, 2000 10:54 AM

      Yes, the very same.

      1. re: Barb. H.
        david RE: Barb. H. Feb 11, 2001 03:33 AM

        i am from missoula, montana, found this board by doing a search. many years ago i came across a recipe book in the public library "goldbergs' pizza" and i used the recipe from it to make my first home cooked pizza, it was tremendous. after i graduated from high school i went into the army, and did no cooking for a while. when i got out, i could no longer find the recipe. while i have a fair recollection of what was in the sauce, i can't remember what the crust recipe was. does anyone have this? please e-mail it to me if you do.

        1. re: david
          magnolia RE: david Feb 11, 2001 10:25 AM

          I'm sure someone on site will reply but the GOldberg's pizza I recall was on York Avenue in the upper 70's and it might even still be there. They might all be related, and if they're there, they might be willing to part with the recipe (if it's the same one you found in the public library).

          1. re: magnolia
            Jennifer RE: magnolia Feb 11, 2001 10:43 PM

            If this is Fats Goldberg's (childhood friend of Calvin Trillin), last I heard he moved back home to Kansas City.

            1. re: Jennifer
              David Jacobson RE: Jennifer Feb 13, 2001 09:39 AM

              There was one last Goldberg's on 2nd and 52nd, closed about a year ago

            2. re: michaela
              Dave Feldman RE: michaela Dec 3, 2003 11:48 PM

              Unfortunately, "Goldberg's Pizza Book" is out of print and very expensive when available (the one offered on Amazon is selling for $52.00). I believe that the recipe for some of his diet pizzas (including hte crustless pizza) are in his diet books.

            3. re: david
              Dave Feldman RE: david Feb 12, 2001 01:56 AM

              Good News: I own Goldberg's Pizza Book.
              Bad News: I can't find it.

              But I just did a search on my favorite used-book site, and at this moment, seven different copies are available at bookfinder.com, the cheapest at $7.50.

              Seems to me that it wouldn't be a bad investment. Even the "diet" S.M.O.G. pizza in the book, a popular offering at the original Goldberg's is quite edible.

              Larry ("Fats") is indeed back in Kansas City. I miss him, but am glad he is back in his spiritual homeland.

              1. re: Dave Feldman
                jenniferfishwilson RE: Dave Feldman Oct 6, 2001 10:48 PM

                When he moved back to KC he opened a Goldberg's Pizza in Prairie Village but it's closed now.

          2. re: bryan
            Dave Feldman RE: bryan May 2, 2000 05:11 PM

            Same Goldberg. Long before he left, he sold the place to a holding company, and continued to manage the place for quite a few years thereafter. He is back in Kansas City, where he belongs.

            1. re: Dave Feldman
              Stephen M. Blakley RE: Dave Feldman May 2, 2000 07:44 PM

              Can you give me the address of this place? I need to contact this guy to see if he opened any others in or around NY!

              1. re: Stephen M. Blakley
                Dave Feldman RE: Stephen M. Blakley May 2, 2000 10:59 PM

                The original location is at 992 2nd Ave. in NYC (in the low 50s). At one time, I think there were three in Manhattan, but now there is only one, assuming that is still open (haven't passed by in a year).

                I doubt very much if Larry Goldberg has any involvement with the place anymore.

                1. re: Dave Feldman
                  Stephen M. Blakley RE: Dave Feldman May 3, 2000 08:00 PM

                  I know about the ones in Manhattan. One was on 72 and York (the original) then there was one on 22 Street and 3rd Ave, and the one on 53 and 2nd. I was asking about the one in Kansas City.

                  1. re: Dave Feldman
                    Bill Wolf RE: Dave Feldman Dec 16, 2000 07:30 PM

                    I've been going to Goldbergs for over 20 years. The one on 2'nd and 52'nd. I tried to go again just the other day and found that the building has been leveled to make some new awful east side appartment building. There was no forwarding information.

                    The two guys that owned it worked for the original Goldberg who sold it to them when he retired.

                    I'm really saddened by this :-(

                    Please contact me if anyone's aware of a new location.


              2. re: bryan
                Stephen M. Blakley RE: bryan May 2, 2000 07:40 PM

                Not sure, but I see the following replys say it is!

                Can you give me the address of this place? I need to contact this guy to see if he opened any others in or around NY!

              3. salvati RE: Stephen M. Blakley Oct 20, 2009 04:23 PM

                Damn, this is a blast from my past.

                1. b
                  billmfoto RE: Stephen M. Blakley Apr 24, 2014 01:22 PM

                  There was one in the 20s also which closed. I don't know why!! I loved those little deep dish pizzas they used to serve ! What A Loss !!

                  Update :

                  Show Hidden Posts