Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >
Nov 12, 1999 09:16 AM

Pearl Oyster Bar: A Wonderful Lunch!!

  • m

Yesterday, I had off from my job, and wandered down to the Pearl Oyster Bar on Cornelia Street in the village. This simple marble bar with a table was just what the doctor ordered for a wonderful lunch. I started with 1/2 dozen perfect bluepoint oyster. These sparkling fresh oysters were served with a migionette sauce, some horseradish and lemons. They were redoulent of the ocean. I washed them down with a pint of Young's Oatmeal Stout, a slightly salty, thick, perfectly poured pint of brew. Next I received the Lobster Roll. Maine lobster, lightly tossed with mayo, celery and seasonings, stuffed into a buttered grilled hotdog roll, topped with a salad of mixed greens in a light vinaigrette. On the side of the plate was a veritable pile of shoestring: Belgian Style fries. I asked for malt vinegar and they had it!!!
Mostly everything is made in the 'scratch-house'. except the hot dog rolls, of course. The windows were fogged up with the steam of many bowls of steamed ipswich clams served with bowls of clambroth. YUM!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. I love Pearl and am tempted to allocate one of my two dinners in NY on an upcoming weekend (after a year away!) to a whole fish and a caesar salad there. But I'd rather schedule lunch on Saturday. Are they open for lunch Saturdays? I wasn't even aware that they were open for lunch on weekdays so hope hours may have expanded all around.

    2 Replies
    1. re: deborah

      I nearly forgot, they have the best fried oysters in the world.

      1. re: deborah

        Went to Pearl for an early dinner a week ago Friday with a workmate. We had:

        Dozen mixed raw oysters - fresh, nice size, 6 kumomoto, 6 bluepoint. Succulent with just a drop of lemon, don't forget to down the juice!

        Smoked salmon & cream fraiche appetizer on a johnnycake - still a great app, but I LOVED it when they used a lightly fried crispy thin potato pancake instaed of the griddlecake. They have not gone back to the original recipe, despite numerous occasions of begging on my part.

        Fried oyster appetizer - as Deborah said, among the best in NYC.

        Lobster roll and french fries - best roll this side of "Lunch" in Ammagansett, the fries just gild the lily - eat them with vinegar in stead of ketchup!

        Crab cake w/cole slaw - meaty, nice, homemade slaw, but not quite up to the "11 on a scale of 1-10" that the rest of the meal rated.

        Did I mention that Pearl has only 3 beers, but they are all great? Always a carefully chosen quality stout, amber and lager - we had many Paulaner pilsners when we were there.

        No room for dessert this time, but don't pass it up, it is always great. Tips: go early (they open at 6) and ask lots of questions - the ladies behind the bar love it when you take an interest in their carefully prepared food!