HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >
Do you create unique foods? Share your adventure

Near Carnegie Hall/City Center???

Charles Troob Nov 17, 1998 08:30 PM

I always used to go to the Broadway Diner for
perfectly acceptable food in glitzy but tacky
surroundings--the floor is restroom tile, everything
is a little rushed. This fall I got a Carnegie
subscription and decided to upgrade my preconcert
dining. I heard good things about the $19.95 prix
fixe at L'Ermitage--it's closed. Topaz Thai (raves in
the Zagat) was pleasant but the food was like
neighborhood Chinese. Brooklyn Diner was pleasant but
the food was heavy and dull and overpriced by five or
seven dollars. Mangia was not for real--at least not
in the evening. I went to Cafe Europa for dessert
after a concert and wouldn't go back--I didn't like my
stale creampuff or what I saw on other plates. At a
ritzier level, I've been to the Redeye Grill twice.
The atmosphere is wonderful but the food??? Not
poison, not good. Should I just go back to the
Broadway Diner? I live downtown, and I'm prepared to
pay $5-$10 more than I'd have to in Chelsea or the
East 20's for simple food, but to pay a premium and
eat badly isn't my idea of fun. (One night I ate
downtown--the price and food were right but getting up
to the concert turned out to be a nightmare.)

Here's what I want--between 5th and 8th Avenue,
between 55th and 58th Street. Either a tasty plate of
food and a drink in decent, simple surroundings for
under $16 (plus tax and tip), or a meal in a nicer
place (it doesn't have to have three courses) for $20
plus drink, tax and tip. Any ethnic cuisine is OK.
(There are a lot of places on W. 56th.) I know that if
I move up the price scale I can do better but I hate
the idea of spending $45 just to eat before a

I'm asking this as a public service--I don't go back
to Carnegie until March.

  1. s
    Steven Shaw Nov 18, 1998 01:58 PM

    Incidentally, Redeye Grill and Broadway Diner are
    under the same ownership, as is nearby Trattoria
    Dell'Arte (and two other restaurants in different
    neighborhoods: Fiorello's and Hosteria Fiorella). I
    think Trattoria Dell'Arte is the best of the Carnegie
    Hall-area restaurants, and it's possible to get out of
    there without breaking the bank if you engage in
    careful study of the menu. I think the thing with
    Redeye Grill is that you have to be selective. The
    smoked salmon and the clay-pot fish are very good, in
    my experience. The Cobb salad--something I never
    order--came highly recommended so I tried it and it
    was pretty damn good (mixed tableside, if you're into
    that sort of thing). Molyvos is good but damn
    expensive for Greek taverna food. Don't forget about
    the Carnegie Deli. You say Eighth Avenue is within
    your striking range, in which case Tapika (sort of in
    the Arizona 206/Mesa Grill mold) is an option. If you
    extend that to Ninth Avenue, well, you're in a whole
    universe of good, cheap eats (more bang for your buck,
    I would argue, than down where you live). I turn you
    over to the serious chowhounds for Ninth Ave.

    1. d
      Deb V. Nov 18, 1998 07:43 AM

      Have you ever tried Molyvos on Seventh Ave. (east side of the street) near 55th? It is a lovely place, warm and inviting with a charming, efficient waitstaff. The food is marvelous, even the more prosaic moussaka was very, very good. The grilled octopus salad appetizer is delightful, unctuous and not over-browned--and the chef knew how to handle sweetbreads. I give points for that.

      The price may be slightly higher than on your wish list, but I think you can pull it off with a little creative ordering. I do think you'd like it.

      1. d
        Dave Feldman Nov 17, 1998 10:52 PM


        How about Angelo's for pizza? It's in the alpha-
        Hound's latest edition of "What I Had for Dinner" and
        I reviewed it here, too. The salad is fine, too. And
        it's across the street from Carnegie Hall, closer to
        6th than 7th.

        3 Replies
        1. re: Dave Feldman
          Charles Troob Nov 18, 1998 07:20 PM

          Amici miei--grazie so far

          --I know I can do well on Ninth--it just seems far--is
          there anything good there on 56th or 57th?
          --I can't wait to try Molyvos, but it's too pricy for
          a quick early meal (or isn't it)?
          --I saw the Angelo's posting and intend to try it.

          1. re: Charles Troob
            Dave Feldman Nov 19, 1998 12:53 AM

            I wrote off Molyvos prematurely after one so-so meal.
            I had a terrrific meal there two weeks ago. The
            special fish dishes were superb.

            But I wouldn't want to rush the meal. The servers are
            very accommodating but it is crowded and popular. If
            you want a light meal, you could do worse than the
            antipasti at Trattoria delle Arte. You can even eat
            it at the bar. Along with their excellent bread, you
            can make a meal of it if you aren't too hungry (or two
            of you could split a pizza). But this is also a
            popular restaurant and not cheap and VERY noisy.

            I'd go to Angelo's and eat at Molyvos when there was
            more time.

            P.S. There is also a quiet and decent (not great)
            Spanish restaurant on 58th St. between 6th and 7th on
            the south side of the street. Very moderate prices.

            1. re: Charles Troob
              joanne Feb 1, 1999 03:52 PM

              On 56th and 9th Ave there is a lovely, intimate Italian
              restaurant that serves superb food. It's called Bello.
              If you just order a main course (veal saltimboca for
              about $15) you can get out for 20 bucks.

              Also, believe it or not I got a really decent broiled
              red snapper dinner at DJ Reynold's on 57th and 9th.
              Their dinner specials are always priced reasonably.
              Definitly in your price range.

              Tapika is pricer but delicious.

              Chinese in the area seems pretty mediocre.

              Arriba, Arriba on around 52nd and 8th is good Mexican.

              Good luck.

          Show Hidden Posts