HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >
What's your latest food quest? Tell us about it
TELL US

Where to eat - only in NYC 3 days - HELP!

t
Tori Aug 9, 1998 02:53 PM

I'm going to NYC for a brief trip, never been there!
I definately qualify as a Chowhound and want every
bite I have in the Big Apple to be the best. With all
the great restaurants how do you pick? I love Italian
and steaks or veal dishes. Can you help?

  1. r
    Ragnar Kolstad Aug 11, 1998 04:28 PM

    Hello Tori

    Last year I asked about the same question here. When I
    asked about The Great American Steak, most ChowHounds
    mentioned Peter Lugers and Gallaghers. Since my wife
    and I are smokers, Peter Lugers was a non-runner, so
    Gallaghers was our place. I've seen many critics saying
    that it's going downhill, but my wife's Filet Mignon
    and my own Prime Rib couldn't be bettered. Her mashed
    potatoes - she said to my disappointment - was as good
    as my own. Maybe we were lucky? We've never been there
    before or since, so we don't know.

    Ragnar

    1 Reply
    1. re: Ragnar Kolstad
      j
      John N. Knoesel Aug 14, 1998 07:15 AM

      I agree about Gallaghers. - Great steaks and big
      drinks! Not cheap but this place is a NY institution.
      If you like seafood a must is Oceana on E.54th.
      Another midtown favorite is Solera. Excellent tapas and
      a beautiful garden in the back.
      Regards, JK

    2. a
      Alex Aug 10, 1998 08:27 AM

      Go to Peter Lugers - It is the best steak in the country,and a real NY experience.

      For Italian, I highly recommend Babbo. It just recently opened to a lot of hype, but IT IS as good as they say. Some of the most consistenly phenomenal pasta dishes that I have ever had the pleasure of eating in a restaurant: from the gnocchi with prosciutto and portobello, the tagliatelli(sp?) with lobster, sweet corn and crushed plum tomatoes and the bucotini with baby octopus in a spicy tomatoe sauce. Plus, don't miss the grilled polenta and portobellos, with shaved parm. regianno appetizer. Call now for reservations.

      3 Replies
      1. re: Alex
        p
        pat hammond Aug 10, 1998 03:05 PM

        Is this the new restaurant jointly run (or owned?) by
        Mario Batalli and the chef owner of Frico? Thanks. pat

        1. re: pat hammond
          a
          Alex Aug 10, 1998 05:31 PM

          Yes. Mario Batali runs the kitchen while Mr. Bastianach (whose family owns Felida, Frico, etc) runs the business end.

          I am usually rather disappointed with pasta dishes in restaurants. They are usually pretty good, but rarely great. I always think, what's the big deal, I could do this at home. Well on four seperate occasions trying 4 different pastas, I have been blown away. In addition, the room is very nice, but not at all dainty. I should stop talking now if I ever want to get a reservation there again.

          1. re: pat hammond
            p
            Pal Barger Sep 14, 1998 12:41 PM

            Yes Frico owner in old Coach House Reservations are hard.

        Show Hidden Posts