HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >
What's your latest food project? Share your adventure
TELL US

Superbowl food for Pittsburgh

d
davey Jan 25, 2006 11:49 AM

Philly has Cheesesteaks. New England has Clam chowder. What does Pittsburgh have?

I need to know what to cook for the Superbowl. All opinions welcome.

Thanks.

  1. c
    Celia Jan 25, 2006 12:03 PM

    It may sound odd but Pittsburgh has a tendency to put french fries on everything- salads, sandwiches (especially pastrami), basically anything! Not the healthiest option but it is tasty.
    If you want to get a bit more "gourmet", you could make a Turkey Devonshire which is a classic Pittsburgh baked sandwich. Here is a recipe I found on the net...
    Frank Blandi's Original Devonshire Sandwich
    Cream Sauce:
    3/4 stick butter, melted
    1 cup flour
    1/4 pound Cheddar cheese, grated
    1 pint chicken broth
    1 pint hot milk
    1 teaspoon salt

    Melt butter in deep pan and add flour, stirring constantly. Add chicken broth and then hot milk, stirring all the while. Add cheese and salt. Bring to boil, then cook slowly for 20 minutes, still stirring. Cool to lukewarm. Beat with wire whip until smooth before using. This makes enough sauce for 6 Devonshire sandwiches.

    For each sandwich:
    1 slice toast, crusts trimmed off
    3 slices crisp bacon
    5 thin slices cooked turkey breast
    Cream Sauce, recipe above
    Melted butter
    Parmesan cheese and paprika

    Preheat oven to 450 degrees.

    In each flat, individual oven-proof casserole dish, place 1 slice of toast and top with 3 slices bacon. Add 5 thin slices of cooked turkey breast. Cover completely with cream sauce. Sprinkle with a little melted butter, then with the combined Parmesan cheese and paprika. Bake 10 to 15 minutes or until golden brown.

    9 Replies
    1. re: Celia
      a
      Amy G. Jan 25, 2006 03:56 PM

      I would serve hot sausage sandwich's made with peppers and onions and olive oil on good rolls, or ham barbeque (have the deli "chip" the ham) made with Heinz Chili sauce and gingerale, or sauerkraut and kilbassa. Pure Pittsburgh.

      1. re: Amy G.
        o
        orion Jan 26, 2006 10:14 AM

        Ham barbecue is a great idea. They're really simple to make and much tastier than they sound. They originated at a deli called Isaly's, which was a Pittsburgh institution for a long time. I have a recipe around at home. Ginger ale and Heinz chili sauce is key, and the only other ingredient I can think of is mustard powder and maybe brown sugar? I think to get chipped ham outside of Pittsburgh you have to ask for shaved ham. Am I correct? I may break out this recipe for Super Bowl Sunday myself.

        1. re: orion
          a
          Amy G. Jan 26, 2006 11:20 AM

          Isaly's actually has a product called "chipped ham" but I don't use it when I make barbeques, I get a good deli ham and have it "chipped or shaved" very thin. Generally one adds pickle relish to ham barbeques, but I have never heard of brown sugar in the mix.

          1. re: orion
            o
            orion Jan 30, 2006 12:22 PM

            I found the recipe I use:

            1.5 cups ginger ale
            12 oz heinz chili sauce
            1 tsp dried mustard
            1 tsp brown sugar
            1 lb chipped ham

            combine the first four ingredients in a saute pan and heat through for 5 or 10 minutes over medium heat. Add the chipped ham and cook another five minutes, separating the slices of ham into the sauce. Serve on hamburger buns.

            This recipe from the PG is a bit different but probably pretty good as well:

            Ham Barbecues
            Thursday, July 08, 2004

            Pittsburgh Post-Gazette

            1 pound chipped ham
            1 tablespoon Worcestershire sauce
            1 teaspoon prepared mustard
            2 tablespoons vinegar
            1/4 cup brown sugar (light)
            1/2 cup ketchup
            1/2 cup water
            1 onion, finely chopped
            Dash of Tabasco sauce

            Add all ingredients, except chipped ham, to saucepan and cook 5 to 10 minutes, until onion is soft. Add meat and heat through. Serve on warmed sandwich buns.

            1. re: orion
              j
              joypirate Jan 30, 2006 01:59 PM

              On a semi-related note, I checked for a co-worker and, in Philly, the Springfield Beer Distributor carries Iron City beer.

              1. re: orion
                a
                Amy G. Jan 30, 2006 05:13 PM

                Orion,
                Would you consider reposting this on the Home Cooking Board? Maybe some others would like to have these recipes for their Super Bowl parties.
                Thanks,
                Amy

                1. re: orion
                  g
                  Georgia Arturo Jun 3, 2006 12:55 PM

                  I was just looking high and low for a recipe I had used perhaps 10 years ago for chipped ham made with chili sauce -- but to no avail.

                  I was so happy to get it from you, because I know it made a bit hit when I made it years ago.

                  Thank you. (I live in Butler, PA & picked the recipe up in a community cook book that was published.)

                  Georgia

            2. re: Celia
              g
              Ginni Jan 19, 2009 03:07 PM

              This doesn't seem to be a Pittsburgh food. Try the Chipped Ham barbaque, Hot saugsage , stuffed cabbage, pierogies and even chocolate covered strawberries--Pittsburgh style.

              1. re: Ginni
                yayadave Jan 19, 2009 07:46 PM

                Actually, the Turkey Devonshire has a strong history in Pittsburgh. I just don't know where you could find a good one right now. Here's some info on Pittsburgh and the Devonshire.

                http://www.post-gazette.com/food/20020704devonp9.asp
                http://www.post-gazette.com/dining/20010921dine0921fnp1.asp
                http://www.post-gazette.com/food/20010215mailbox.asp
                http://www.post-gazette.com/pg/05272/...

            3. f
              Frank Jan 25, 2006 12:55 PM

              Iron City beer

              1 Reply
              1. re: Frank
                r
                rememberme Jan 20, 2009 10:12 AM

                Yeah, and anything made by Heinz

              2. s
                Stacy Jan 25, 2006 01:30 PM

                You have a few choices:

                1.Purchase a box of your favorite Perogi’s. Serve them Pittsburgh style. (Smothered in butter and sautéed onions.)
                2.Make a Primanti Brothers style sandwich. French fries and coleslaw piled high is a MUST. (Link with menu included.)
                3.A six-pack of Iron City Beer

                If you’re truly from the "Burgh",have all three.
                GO STEELERS!!!

                Link: http://www.primantibros.com/menu.asp

                3 Replies
                1. re: Stacy
                  d
                  Debbie Jan 27, 2006 08:09 PM

                  I second the Pierogies. If you can't get good ones, it is more important to really do them well. I think you can get them online that are pretty good:

                  This place is very popular:

                  http://www.claraspghpierogies.com/

                  By doing them well, I mean sauteeing a huge amount of sliced onions in real butter until they are soft and goldern brown. Take them out of the pan, then add a little more butter and saute the actual pierogies until they are lightly golden. Serve with sour cream.

                  Another really popular thing are these little hot green peppers, stuffed with a piece of provolone that is wrapped in prosciutto. These, however, may be popular everywhere.

                  But the pierogie, and the sandwich with tomato, vinegar slaw and french fries on Italian bread in Very Pittsburghy.

                  Serve some sort of Pgh. beer. Do they still make IC?

                  Link: http://www.claraspghpierogies.com/

                  1. re: Debbie
                    c
                    chevrelove Jan 20, 2009 08:38 AM

                    Since someone else already revived this thread, I thought I'd comment on the post about Clara's Pittsburgh Pierogies. Sadly, they are no longer in business - though if that changes, I'll be one of the first to know as Clara is my grandmother and my aunt ran the business :-)

                    Not sure where else you can get good pierogies from Pittsburgh, especially shipped - but if anyone else knows, I'd appreciate a tip! Some delicious, homemade pierogies would be an excellent addition to my SB lineup. Go Steelers!

                    1. re: chevrelove
                      yayadave Jan 20, 2009 09:04 AM

                      Most people I know just go to the local Orthodox church or Pierogis Plus.
                      http://www.pierogiesplus.com/

                2. v
                  vel Jan 25, 2006 02:36 PM

                  a steak, pittsburgh-style. Scorched on the outside and bloody in the center.

                  and a steak salad, with required french fries, is a good thing too.

                  Vel

                  6 Replies
                  1. re: vel
                    f
                    Frank Jan 26, 2006 10:09 AM

                    "A steak...corched on the outside and bloody in the center"

                    What makes this 'pittsburgh-style' as opposed to KC-style or Austin-style or any other style? This is a very common steak preference.

                    1. re: Frank
                      o
                      orion Jan 26, 2006 10:19 AM

                      A Pittsburgh steak is abosolutely burned on the outside and raw on the inside. The legend behind it is that steelworkers would bring steaks to work and cook them by laying them down on the blistering-hot pipes in the mills, which would burn the outsides but never cook the steaks through. I don't think anyone really knows if this is truly the case or not, yet it seems unlikely to me.

                      1. re: orion
                        f
                        Frank Jan 26, 2006 03:51 PM

                        Thanks for the info. It certainly rings true.

                        This method is kind of geographically generic - I used to cook on the tubes of a wire annealing furnace in Jersey; truckers cook on the exhaust manifold etc. I mean to say, we all have done it at sometime somewhere.

                        1. re: orion
                          a
                          alice (steelworker's daughter) Jan 28, 2006 03:39 PM

                          "Legend" indeed...since it certainly wasn't until well into the '60's that most steelworkers could AFFORD steak for lunch!!!! Or dinner, very often, for that matter. If anyone was cookin' at the mill, it was more likely to have been kielbasa, ground meat, chipped ham...

                          1. re: orion
                            r
                            Rick Jan 19, 2009 07:33 PM

                            Pittsburgh Rare is what we call it here. For my superbowl party we're having home made pierogies and meatball sandwiches along with all of the pre requisite junk food like buffalo chicken dip, wings, taco dip etc. Like others have said, hot sausage sandwiches, pierogies, kielbasa and sauerkraut, and stuffed cabbage are foods you'll often see at family parties. Our hot sausage sandwiches tend to be served with a red sauce on top in addition to the onions and peppers. Not sure if this is a Pittsburgh thing or not, but other than here at home I've had hot sausage sandwiches with just sauteed onions and peppers, no red sauce.

                            1. re: Rick
                              k
                              Kelli2006 Jan 20, 2009 01:30 PM

                              I grew up in the Akron area and we called those steaks "black and blue because they were so rare inside that it had a tinge of blue. I leaned to cook them in 20 seconds with the interior of the steak not reaching 100°.

                              We do the same sausage w/ grilled onions and peppers in this area. Ive never used a red sauce but we occasionally put roughly chopped tomatoes on the flattop.

                      2. p
                        Penzgirl Jan 25, 2006 09:16 PM

                        Just remember...the ketchup must be Heinz!

                        1. y
                          yayadave Jan 27, 2006 09:53 PM

                          For hot sausage sandwiches:
                          Cut the sausage to bun lengths. Fry slowly with lots of onion and green pepper. Serve on sausage buns.
                          For kielbasa sandwiches:
                          Cut the kielbasa to bun lengths. Drain some sauerkraut and add some onion. Put in a crock pot with some beer. You can also cook this in the oven in a covered baking dish. Don’t use aluminum foil. Serve on sausage buns.
                          For ham Bar-B-Q sandwiches:
                          At the deli counter, tell them what you’re going to make. They should know how to “chip” the boiled ham, baked ham, or chopped ham. You can look around at the deli case or ask them for Isaly’s Bar-B-Q sauce. Or make your own, or buy the Isaly’s and doctor it up. Put the ham in a pot to heat. As it heats, it will release some oil and you can separate it with tongs or forks and add the sauce to heat. Separate it some more – you’ll be surprised. Serve on sandwich buns.
                          For perogies:
                          You can get good ones at "Perogies Plus" on Island Avenue. Since Super Bowl week-end is liable to be a big one in the ‘Burgh, you may have to order in advance. Also check around for churches that make and sell perogies, especially orthodox. Just fry them in butter with chopped onions.

                          This all works. I’m sure other posters will have other ideas, but this is a starting place for their embellishments. Don’t forget some Mylanta.

                          1. mkmccp Jan 19, 2009 04:28 PM

                            I agree with the other posters re: ham bbq's, hot sausage sandwich, pierogies. Adding my 0.02- stuffed banana peppers, try googling it and you will find many recipes, fried provolone (NOT mozzarella) sticks, enormous fried fish sandwiches, smiley cookies from Eat-n-park (you might be able to order them online, otherwise the nearest Eat-n-Park is in Lancaster), Pecan Balls (scoops of French vanilla ice cream, rolled in Pecans, then covered with Hot Fudge sauce and whipped cream), haluski (to go with the fish sandwiches), kielbasy and sauerkraut... Ok thats it for now, and I am getting hungry, if I think of more I will post or if you need details on anything I will be checking back to see what others have posted- this is interesting.

                            1. goldy12 Jan 19, 2009 05:06 PM

                              Pepperoni rolls: basically take a bread dough and roll it thin Sprinkle with cheese (provolone or mozzarella), top with pepperoni and yellow peppers, roll it up and bake at 400 until the crust is golden brown. I like to serve with a side of sauce for dipping.

                              I'll second the fries on everything. Make a salad, top it with steak and fries and have it Pittsburgh style!

                              1. EJC Jan 20, 2009 12:55 PM

                                Just returned from an AFC Championship weekend in PGH where everything I ate was beige and fried...
                                The one food that I haven't seen mentioned - parmesan hot wings. Not sure if I loved 'em, but they were on a lot of menus and all of my local friends were big fans.

                                Show Hidden Posts