Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > San Francisco Bay Area >
Jan 11, 2002 09:42 PM

The Cheese Course

  • m

. . . is a fine cheese store in Healdsburg where I recently selected an after dinner cheese course.

My friend Julie joined me last weekend in the country. We were up until the wee hours of the morning catching up, talking about life, and our intentions for the new year while nibbling from the cheese board and tasting them with different wines.

Dinner was simplicity itself: a couple of live Dungeness crabs from Bodega steamed at home, plenty of melted butter, a mixed salad, and a round of sourdough pull-aparts from Costeaux bakery in Healdsburg. We toasted the new year with NV Billecart-Salmon “Cuvée Reservée” Brut Champagne and popped open a white burgundy (Chardonnay, 93 Colin-Deleger “Clos Devant” Chassagne-Montrachet (1/2 bottle) to enjoy with our crab.

Susan at The Cheese Course had been accommodating about cutting small portions for just the two of us, making it easier to serve a selection of four cheeses: La Montagnard, Cave Aged Gruyere, Taleggio, and Crozier. Plus I snagged her last loaf of Meyer lemon rosemary bread from Della Fattoria. For our cheese course, the more serious wines came out: 93 Dom. Tempier Bandol rouge (1/2 bottle), 90 Terrabianca “Campaccio” Barriques Super Tuscan, and 83 Doisy-Daene Barsac-Sauternes (1/2 bottle) to try with the cheeses.

Le Montagnard is a washed rind cheese from the Vosges Mountains over Alsace. Ooey, gooey, this was in a perfect state of runniness. At this maturity, the rind was a sunny yellow that reminded me of the color of polenta. Soft and buttery in flavor and texture with plenty of character yet not at all "strong". It showed the best of the group for us this time. It matched well with all our wines, especially the Campaccio.

The Cave Aged Gruyere, matured for more than a year, was in splendid condition from a deliciously nutty and richly flavored wheel. This had aged gracefully, growing in complexity, but not drying out or turning hard. The Swiss say you should only drink white wine with their cheeses and we found it to be true in this case. The Champagne and the white Burgundy were the most complementary.

Taleggio, from Lombardia, is one of my favorites. This piece was mature and reaching that semi-soft stage with a fatty texture. The aroma was quite strong and pungent, but the taste was floral, mushroomy and meaty. Surprisingly, it didn't find a marriage with the Tuscan wine, instead it had more in common with the leathery earthiness and floral note of the Mourvedre grape in the Tempier.

This was my first taste of Crozier, a strong sheep milk blue from Neal's Yard. This is an intense blue with plenty of lanolin sheepishness too - not for the faint-hearted. When I pulled the Sauternes from the cellar, I was thinking along Roquefort lines in making the match. Instead, a vintage Porto would have been a better pairing in the manner of a strong Stilton.

In the morning, I pulled out a soft and mild local table cheese, Crescenza, which has the texture of a runny brie and is sold in a plastic tub. This topped toast of the remaining meyer lemon bread to be savored with jamon serrano and some fresh fruits for our breakfast. Julie and I both took note that we were not hung-over at all. Maybe the magic of our cheeses counteracted the effects of 3 1/2 bottles of wine?


  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. l
    Leslie Brenner

    Darned if this post doesn't make me want to jump in the car and head up north for a dinner of Dungeness crab, stinky cheese and wine! Thanks for the vicarious thrill, Melanie!

    1 Reply
    1. re: Leslie Brenner

      Your time will be here soon, girlfriend!

      When I was typing the initial ramble, I was more focused on the cheeses, but I gotta say a couple more words about those vinos. The Campaccio was incredible - the wine of the night. This was the first of my three bottles that I've opened. I have a friend who has a case and he's been trying them and telling me to hold back. Well, it's just about perfection now. We couldn't imagine it getting any better. So harmonious, the Cab and the Sangio have completely integrated and you really can't identify either's contribution. Lots of depth and length and still full of fruit with some a whole bunch of other stuff going on.

      The Tempier, even in half bottle and just the regular cuvée, had aged beautifully. We were surprised at how floral the initial nose was, but then the Tempier stench started to come on with gamey aromas, saddle leather and tons of spice. Still plenty of red fruit and verve, but alas, my last bottle of this one. So much pleasure for a $7 original investment.

      Colin-Deleger must be my favorite Chassagne-Mont. producer, seems that's all I have. Julie commented that the 93 was a great deal fresher, even in the small format, than a 94 premier cru she'd opened recently. I'm finding the 93s to be sleeper vintage among the best producers. The extra acidity has preserved them well and they don't suffer from the alcoholic heat of 92 and 94.

      What more can I say about Billecart-Salmon? I drink more of this house than any other Champagne (not that I'm swilling the stuff ever day, mind you). This one had two years of bottle age post release and showed some nice biscuity notes, fullness on the palate and had lost that raw acidic zap that younger bottles have. So very pleasant to sip through the crab course, you want to have more than just a glass.

      I'm not much of a Sauternes fan, and I find that I like the freshness and verve of Barsac when I do have one. Doisy-Daene has held up remarkably well for an 83 in half with medium gold color, light botrytis influence, honeyed apricot fruit, cleansing acidity, and not overly alcoholic. This would have been better with a fruit tart though than the Crozier.