HOME > Chowhound > All New England Archive >

Arrows or White Barn Inn

r
Rhino Apr 11, 2006 04:39 PM

We're from SF and we're going to be staying at the White Barn Inn on an upcoming visit along with some Hound friends from NYC. We want to do one special meal together and are deciding between eating at WBI or heading down to Arrows. Both of them get great national press. I realize that both are expensive, but we're willing to splurg and just wanted feedback from people who might have tried one or the other or both as to which you would pick if you had just one special meal.

Many thanks!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. e
    emilief RE: Rhino Apr 11, 2006 04:57 PM

    They are both very expensive and abit "fussy." We prefer Arrows because the place is so beautiful, depending upon the time of year as the gardens are blooming at Arrows. The White Barn Inn is very pretentous e.g. they bring all the entrees at once and lift off all the covers at once. I find it silly. I would say that the food in both places is equally good.
    If you want a really good meal that is not as expensive you can go to Arrows' more casual restaurant in Ogunquit- MC Perkins Cove- owned by Arrows but much less expensive and a fabulous view- on the ocean, unlik wbi or arrrows.

    2 Replies
    1. re: emilief
      h
      HDinCentralME RE: emilief Apr 11, 2006 06:22 PM

      Both are beyond expensive (for Maine). Of the two, I would choose Arrows because of the atmosphere and the freshness of the ingredients (literally grown on premises). But I agree that both are very "overdone" dining experiences.

      1. re: HDinCentralME
        i
        Irwin RE: HDinCentralME Apr 11, 2006 06:43 PM

        Both restaurants are fabulous, but I prefer White Barn Inn. The last time at Arrows and spending $100 each I left hungry, which is not the case at White Barn Inn.
        Also, for your information, just around the corner from WBI on Rt 9 is a restaurant that we feel is as good as WBI and Arrows, called "On the Marsh".
        Similar style eating in a old barn, but just awesome ambiance, and orgasmic dishes, and the last 5 times we were there was a incredible experience. Hope this helps you to decide.

    2. l
      Lynnie RE: Rhino Apr 12, 2006 02:53 PM

      I have to agree with Irwin, I would opt for On the Marsh. Definitely my favorite restaurant. Excellent food and atmosphere. Have eaten a number of times (and have stopped) at the White Barn Inn and once at Arrows and both are very good but sounds like you are looking to also have a nice time with friends and I see that being a little difficult at both. I have felt in the past that I needed to keep it to a whisper. Not saying of course that you would be loud by any means but just think On the Marsh would be a more memorable experience. If you're still opting for the WBI or Arrows though, I'd choose Arrows.

      1 Reply
      1. re: Lynnie
        e
        emilief RE: Lynnie Apr 12, 2006 03:05 PM

        Sorry to pipe in again- I have eaten at On the Marsh and we did not have a good meal. Must have been an off day. However, I will say that the atmostphere there is not even close to Arrows or WBI (with Arrows having, by far, the best most beautiful room and setting). We have eaten at Arrows maybe ten times over the years and never felt like we had to whisper!
        As you said, both WBI and Arrows have national acclaim. While On the Marsh might be a good place, definitely not in the same league.
        Whatever you choose, some advice- be sure to ask the price of things - once at WBI we were inticed into all 8 in our party having a glass of champagne only to find out-too late- that they were charging $16 per glass. I didn't ask the price because I was familiar with the champagne which sells in the 50-60 range for a bottle. Same advice with specials- they recite the specials but don't tell you the price- no one should be embarrased to ask "how much is the special."
        Whatever you choose, have a lovely time and remember it is only a meal!!!!

      2. m
        mcel RE: Rhino Apr 14, 2006 04:01 PM

        If you are staying at the White Barn Inn, than I would suggest you eat there.

        Both places are lovely, but this way you don't have to think about driving 1/2hr to Arrows.

        JMO

        1. s
          sixela! RE: Rhino Jun 4, 2006 11:04 PM

          My dude and I went to Arrows last weekend for the second time and I have to say, I were both disappointed. They seemed to have taken "fussy" to another level though, for all the fussiness, the service seemed to suffer. For example, we were offered "three types of complimentary butter" (yeah, ok...) though were never re-breaded.

          We each had the tasting menu and, at 97$ a head (and in Maine, no less) I think it's a rip off. Nothing was STELLAR, just ok and really small (particularily our salad served 4 ways (4 pieces of lettuce for each way)). Dessert was unsatisfactory and just kinda summed up the experience.

          As I said, we had been there before and had been overwhelmed with joy over our meal. This trip, we've decided, was our last trip to Arrows.

          1. e
            Etnier RE: Rhino Jul 9, 2006 04:10 PM

            Arrows was such a wonderful place when it first started. This was some time ago. Once Mark & Clark owned it, the place got more expensive and precious with every passing season, and we found the food actually getting worse in some ways.

            You have to be super-rich to afford Arrows now, and it seems to be all about that and presentation.

            1. i
              irwin RE: Rhino Jul 9, 2006 06:39 PM

              I can understand Arrows going down hill because I believe one of the partners is now at MC Perkins Cove. I do not go to Arrows because after spending $100 each I leave hungry. I much prefer White Barn Inn. We were there last Sunday Night and the cost is $89 each plus drinks. The food was fabulous,
              and yes, each person is served at the same time by their own waiter, and no, no covers were removed from the plates. The $89 includes (4) servings, and how can you beat that for eating dinner in a barn setting, gorgeous flowers, piano music being played, professional waiters, and the whole ambiance cannot be beat for any amount of money. In NYC or Vegas this meal would be $200 each, but no-one complains about that price because of the big city. Let me tell you, for $89 each, White Barn Inn is a bargain, and the finest restaurant in Maine.

              1. e
                E29 RE: Rhino Sep 24, 2006 02:41 PM

                The prices for both of these places just don't make any sense. Their prices are equal to some of the most noted restaurants in Manhattan and though both have nice ambiance neither warrants the prices they charge, which soured the overall experience for me.

                1. m
                  muffy0110 RE: Rhino Oct 1, 2006 07:26 AM

                  I have to post this- not The White Barn Inn. I had looked
                  forward the that meal for months. The food was ok- the service
                  was lacking- and I fell or the wet floor due the the snow
                  they did not shovel. I did not get hurt-except for my pride.
                  I wrote them a letter telling them I wanted nothing, but wanted
                  still to tell them have disappointed I was. Oh, how they
                  wanted really wanted to make things right- two weeks later
                  they decided flowers-would be the way-my husband told them
                  forget it-meal price 400.00

                  1. n
                    namewithheld RE: Rhino Nov 15, 2009 07:19 PM

                    We ate at both White Barn Inn and Arrows last week of September 2009. Hands down recommend White Barn Inn. The service was fantastic, food superb and worth the price. Arrows was a disappointment, the appetizer was neat and inventive, main was okay but not to the standards of the price and then dessert was bland to the point of being almost tasteless. I'm sure the service was fine, but don't remember it out of the ordinary as I found WBI.

                    Both establishments have a very cool decor.

                    1. t
                      terrystu RE: Rhino Nov 16, 2009 11:49 AM

                      This is too easy.
                      WBI is classy, elegant, and the service is always spot-on. Even though they are both expensive, at WBI the food is beautifully prepared and the portions are surprisingly adequate.
                      Arrows, on the other hand, is pretentious, stuffy, and overpriced. We have eaten there twice, and both times left hungry. On our last visit, the waiter actualy argued with me when I asked for tap water, eschewing the half-dozen or so pricey bottled selections.
                      My wife and I often eat at fine restaurants in Boston, NYC, and SF, and have never had this sort of negative vibe from any of them.
                      White Barn Inn is miles above.

                      1 Reply
                      1. re: terrystu
                        aadesmd RE: terrystu Dec 10, 2009 02:12 PM

                        Have to agree. I believe Arrows has the worst food for their price point in the country. WBI is substantially better.

                      2. l
                        lexpatti RE: Rhino Dec 11, 2009 07:39 AM

                        I've only been to White Barn and loved it, everything was exceptional: food, service and ambiance (and wasn't shocked by the prices).

                        1 Reply
                        1. re: lexpatti
                          i
                          irwin RE: lexpatti Dec 12, 2009 10:11 AM

                          White Barn Inn gets my vote.......
                          Wonderful establishment, excellent food, amibiance to die for, and service that is the best.
                          Muffy--sorry you had a problem, but things happen sometimes when not expected, but its good that you contacted them and they seemed to care.
                          Irwin

                        Show Hidden Posts