How is this? Is it worth going to from Wilton?
Consiglio's is good, but IMHO, not the best in town. It's cute, but kind of small, and a bit on the pricey side if that's a concern to you. Driving from Wilton, I'd guess there are other,closer options for you to consider.
IMHO consiglio's is mediocre Italian-American food. If you want to come to NEw Haven for food,
are worth the trip
Realize this thread is 4 years old, but in the interest of saving someone else, and having just eaten there myself, the answer to Suzanne's question is an emphatic "no".