HOME > Chowhound > Greater Boston Area >
Are you making a specialty food? Tell us about it

What makes New York's sushi better?

munchabunch Feb 25, 2002 10:58 AM

Recurrent themes in past sushi threads are that Japanese food is bad here and sushi is way better in New York. Just what exactly makes the difference? I like much of the Japanese cuisine I've tried here, but I have nothing to compare it to.

  1. s
    slade Feb 27, 2002 02:43 PM

    Unfortunatly, its true. I used to live in New Jersey and I do miss the steller sushi I used to get in NJ/NYC area that I can't find around here. :-( Alex explaination most likely sums up the reason. However, I've seen great things on this furom about a restaurant called Oishi somewhere in Chestnut.

    2 Replies
    1. re: slade
      slade Feb 27, 2002 02:52 PM

      ...Chestnut Hill, that is.

      1. re: slade
        galleygirl Feb 27, 2002 03:08 PM

        Actually, several New Yorkers I know also think Takeshima in Coolidge Corner is equal to NY quality...

      2. a
        Alex Feb 26, 2002 11:08 AM

        There is at least one very good Japanese restaurant in the Boston area: Sushi Island in Wakefield.

        What makes the NYC restaurants better? I could speculate... A critical mass of patrons helps them keep a wide selection of ingredients consistently fresh. Not to mention that a large population of Japanese natives includes more trained sushi chefs than a smallish city like Boston has to offer. Somehow, some combination of things is resulting in a lower chef-to-patron ratio, which means the fish is warmer, the rice colder, the sushi bar shorter, and the number of tables larger.

        The quality of Japanese restaurants in NYC pales, though, when compared to San Fancisco -- probably for the same reasons.

        2 Replies
        1. re: Alex
          munchabunch Feb 26, 2002 05:39 PM

          Thanks. The volume and chef pool effect make sense. I'll give Wakefield a try too.

          1. re: munchabunch
            Ginger Feb 27, 2002 05:08 PM

            Try Oishii too. I recently moved to Boston and have been majorly underimpressed with most sushi places here. Just went to Oishii today and was blown away. Great sushi (very large and fresh), incredible maki (interesting selections, rice is perfect texture and temp) and the chefs are hilarious. Be sure to try the Torch maki. The hand rolls looked incredible and the Alligator maki (shrimp tempura inside, unagi, tobiko, avocado outside) was beautiful. The address is 612 Hammond st (off of rt 9). They're closed monday. We found out the hard way...

        Show Hidden Posts