HOME > Chowhound > Greater Boston Area >

Prime Rib

Armand Dec 11, 2001 03:39 PM

Looking for the best prime rib in the Boston area - West is best. Mother-in-law insists on Prime Rib for dinner Christmas day - as you can see it is a democratic household.

Thank you

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. t
    Thomas RE: Armand Dec 12, 2001 01:44 PM

    A nice place for a mother-in-law looking for prime rib west of Boston is the Hartwell House in Lexington. Well-prepared large cut of prime rib, OK popovers, standard American sides, a piano tinkling over in the background, at a price consistent with food and service. Not novel, not sophisticated, but standard American food well-prepared in an ambience well-suited to the mother-in-law generation.

    3 Replies
    1. re: Thomas
      Fort Point RE: Thomas Dec 9, 2006 05:45 PM

      Are you sure the Hartwell House is still the name. I thought they had reopened as Steins. Doesn't mean they don't have prime rib, but I'm not sure about the name.

      1. re: Fort Point
        Rubee RE: Fort Point Dec 9, 2006 07:16 PM

        You're right. It is Max Stein's now. I have to point out that the OP's question and above response are from 2001, so I find it amusing that the CHs are answering this thread 5 years later. ;)

        1. re: Rubee
          Alcachofa RE: Rubee Dec 11, 2006 05:01 PM

          Maybe Armand is still looking! :-D

    2. j
      jundomania RE: Armand Dec 9, 2006 04:40 PM

      if yoiu are cooking, try Dewar's in Newton or Wellesley

      1. MC Slim JB RE: Armand Dec 9, 2006 04:45 PM

        I got a beautiful standing prime rib roast at The Butcher Shop to cook for Christmas dinner a couple years ago, which they trimmed for me (cut through the chine) for easier preparation. Punishing prices, but very high quality.

        1. e
          emilief RE: Armand Dec 9, 2006 05:15 PM

          I have been getting mine from Dewars for 20+ years. It is excellent and they will cut it however you want.

          1. frankie Imbergamo RE: Armand Dec 9, 2006 06:48 PM

            The Hartwell house in lexington is not in business anymore. The restaurant is now called Max Steins--this restaurant is great. I had the tenderloin it was excellent-im sure they also have a great prime rib. The atmosphere is also fantastic and they have a nice bar as well--give this place a try im sure you will enjoy it.

            Frankie Imbergamo

            1. g
              Gabatta RE: Armand Dec 10, 2006 08:37 PM

              If you are willing to drive a bit NW, the Gibbet Hill Grill has great prime rib, and an atmoshpere with fireplace and room which I think would be great for a holiday. A friend's family had Thanksgiving there and raved about it.

              1. t
                tamerlanenj RE: Armand Dec 10, 2006 11:57 PM

                Well. I was sitting next to someone at the bar at Abe and Louie's yesterday who ordered prime rib and it looked absolutely amazing...and was so, according to his verbal testimony, although I myself have never tried it.

                1. t
                  twentyoystahs RE: Armand Dec 11, 2006 04:29 PM

                  A friend of mine swears by the prime rib at....(brace yourself now..) Joe's American Bar & Grill. I am not a prime rib aficiando but it's a big hunk o' meat that always comes to the table perfectly cooked.

                  On a side note, how does someone reply to a post from 2001? wouldn't they have to do a search for "prime rib" and have this come up as one of the links? it's not like this is a thread that would come up anywhere close on the home page? Wacky.

                  Show Hidden Posts