I would also recommend the Hardcover. I recently went to a dinner for 20 to celebrate a birthday and everyone had a great meal. There are many surf and turf selections as well as a lighter appetites section and a children's menu. The deep fried lobster ravioli was an interesting appetizer, there are a few unusual choices on the menu but most are classics. Dinner with appetizers, drinks, desserts, and tip came to about $40 per person.
A warning: It's very easy to miss, when coming north on route 1 keep an eye peeled after the 128 intersection, it's on your right.