HOME > Chowhound > New Orleans >

Best Gumbo in NO?

Lisabnyc Aug 11, 2005 09:38 AM

Where can I find the best seafood gumbo in New Orleans? I always liked Sid-Mar's before it got touristy, but I need a new spot to try.

Any recommendations?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. l
    leek lady RE: Lisabnyc Aug 11, 2005 02:51 PM

    Martin's wine Cellar (either location) has the best I think. Eat there or take out. Friday only & they sell out by 1pm.

    1. m
      Mike D RE: Lisabnyc Aug 11, 2005 04:03 PM

      Seafood gumbo: Luizza's By The Track on Lopez

      Okra gumbo: Cassamento's (which closes for the summer simmer)

      2 Replies
      1. re: Mike D
        Fat Harry RE: Mike D Aug 11, 2005 05:19 PM

        I think Casamento's has some of the worst gumbo in the city. They need to stick to oysters.

        I will agree that Martin's has awesome gumbo. Sid-Mar's is hit-or-miss and it has come out cold before, although I wouldn't call it touristy.

        1. re: Fat Harry
          Hungry Celeste RE: Fat Harry Aug 12, 2005 12:14 PM

          Oh, I agree about Casamento's gumbo. Keep the tomatoes and oregano out of the gumbo pot, please! IMHO, none of the best gumbos will ever be found in a restaurant kitchen (sorry)...this is akin to searching for really, really great chicken soup in a restaurant. Some foods only achieve true greatness and perfection in the home kitchen. That aside, I've eaten gumbos I liked (in differing styles) at Gabrielle, Bon Ton, and the old Zachary's on Oak (Wayne Baquet is now at Lil' Dizzy's on Esplanade). Baquet's gumbo is good ol' creole homestyle...fresh sausage rather than smoked, crab bodies in the gumbo, good dark-but-not-burned roux, thin enough to truly be a soup...not made from "soup base" or "seafood stock", but actually composed in the pot from raw ingredients.

      2. t
        Tom RE: Lisabnyc Aug 12, 2005 10:26 AM

        My vote(s) go to Mr. B's and Herbsaint.

        1. g
          Gobbles RE: Lisabnyc Aug 14, 2005 09:24 PM

          Many, if not most resturants in NO buy their gumbo in wholesale bulk from the Gumbo Factory

          3 Replies
          1. re: Gobbles
            Hungry Celeste RE: Gobbles Aug 16, 2005 10:27 AM

            What on earth are you talking about?

            1. re: Gobbles
              Pat in Mid-City RE: Gobbles Aug 18, 2005 02:10 PM

              C'mon Lisa. You must be talking about NYC, where you are from.

              Gumbo in New Orleans is a time honored tradition, and no two are alike. Every chef makes their own version.

              For you to say that "most restaurants in New Orleans buy theirs in bulk from the gumbo Shop" just shows your ignorance.

              Stick to something you know, like NYC. Leave NOLA to the locals.

              1. re: Pat in Mid-City
                Rico Pan RE: Pat in Mid-City Aug 18, 2005 03:03 PM

                Um, Pat, before you start calling people names, maybe you should double-check whether you're replying to who you think you're replying to. (You're not.)

            2. d
              donkeyhodey RE: Lisabnyc Aug 14, 2005 11:18 PM

              Mr. B's gumbo ya ya is very good.
              But the best gumbo (IMO)is: Brigtsen's Restaurant Rabbit Gumbo.

              Link: http://foodfest.neworleans.com/rec_in...

              1. g
                guideauxamoeba RE: Lisabnyc Aug 15, 2005 07:40 AM

                Where the f**k is the Gumbo Factory? Is that a joke?
                I find the best and most consistent gumbo comes from the Gumbo Shop. Yes, they are touristy, but the price is right and they have been doing it for over 60 years, so I think they've got it right. I especially like their Smoked Duck and Oyster Gumbo when it is the special.

                1. w
                  williet RE: Lisabnyc Aug 15, 2005 03:54 PM

                  i like mothers

                  1. m
                    Mikey RE: Lisabnyc Aug 16, 2005 03:38 PM

                    I have to pick Herbsaint because after years of eating gumbo, I have come to love the sausage and game/poultry gumbos rather than the seafood/okra. Just a preference but Herbsaint makes a great one!

                    1. b
                      bwdirector RE: Lisabnyc Aug 17, 2005 04:39 PM

                      I vote for Mr. B's, it's marvelous and I don't particularly like gumbo, I always have the catfish beignet app.

                      1. b
                        Boatman RE: Lisabnyc Aug 27, 2005 12:03 AM

                        I really like the gumbo at Dookey Chase.

                        1 Reply
                        1. re: Boatman
                          Hungry Celeste RE: Boatman Jan 17, 2007 03:06 PM

                          This old topic just resurfaced, and the sentiment & timing of the above post brought a tear to my eye...

                        2. b
                          BandeetoBehr RE: Lisabnyc Jan 12, 2007 06:26 PM

                          None of you had the gumbo from the kitchen of my Aunt Isobel's on Coliseum Street. I have the recipe but have never been able to duplicate it exactly ... whatever the secret ... it went to the grave with her elderly cook.

                          1. t
                            Tchoupitoulas RE: Lisabnyc Jan 13, 2007 07:10 PM

                            Gumbos are like snowflakes, there are no two alike. Depends on whether you want Creole Gumbo (tomatoes and okra) or a Cajun Gumbo (neither tomatoes nor okra but often with a dollop of potato salad in the middle). Funny but I don't think I can ever remember ordering gumbo when I have gone out to eat, it's always been a "make it at home" thing, so I guess I'm not much help.

                            1. a
                              apb1235 RE: Lisabnyc Jan 16, 2007 05:33 PM

                              A good restaurant for a nice dark roux gumbo is Atchafalaya Cafe.

                              1. n
                                nowonmai11 RE: Lisabnyc Jan 16, 2007 06:00 PM

                                I hate to burst people's bubble,, but what Gobbles said about many restaurants buying pre-made gumbo, is true, sort of.

                                I am pretty sure that the brand is called Gumbo Factory, but I can't be certain. Many local restaurants do order this product. (I have worked in a few of them, in fact.) Some doctor it up, others just heat and serve with rice. It is a surprisingly tasty product that comes frozen in a bag.

                                That being said, there are LOTS of restaurants that would never think of ordering pre-made gumbo in a bag. Mr. B's, Herbsaint, Casamento's, Dooky Chase, Commander's, etc. all make their gumbo in house. You can probably guess which one's would make their own, and which would order it. (though you might be surprised by some).

                                2 Replies
                                1. re: nowonmai11
                                  Hungry Celeste RE: nowonmai11 Jan 17, 2007 03:20 PM

                                  I think Gumbo Factory is in Mandeville...isn't this the place that used to be called Mr. Gumbo? Certainly some lower price point restaurants use pre-packed products--more than would freely admit it. Unfortunately, the heat-and-serve revolution has spread beyond fast food joints.

                                  1. re: nowonmai11
                                    MakingSense RE: nowonmai11 Jan 17, 2007 04:45 PM

                                    Sad, isn't it. But a lot of folks need to wake up and smell the Starbucks because even good old New Orleans coffee is getting hard to find locally.
                                    A lot of the character of New Orleans food is changing due to mass production and perhaps the expectations of the tourist trade. My grandparents would scarcely recognize much of it now. Not to say it should not evolve, but it's sad to see traditions lost. I walked by the acclaimed Stella's recently and there wasn't a single local fish on the menu. I hear tourists raving about the wonderful salmon they ate in New Orleans...

                                  Show Hidden Posts