HOME > Chowhound > New Orleans >

Got a New Orleans Top Ten?

g
groovyman Mar 5, 2005 03:54 PM

The last poster talked about some consensus but a lot of variation. I was wondering if the locals and experienced visitors would humor us with a top ten of their faves, in order. What better way to simplify, be direct, have fun, and start a debate! Lists ALWAYS start debates. And if a place make most lists, then it would seem to indicate that it's the quality of food more than individual taste or experience. (Like I assume Brigtsen's would make about every list, and Uglisich's a great deal of them)

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. f
    Fat Harry RE: groovyman Mar 5, 2005 05:55 PM

    Not really in a particular order, here are my current top 10. Yes I did leave Brigsten's off, and while I would probably eat there before Mandina's, I love Mandina's too much to leave it off a list. Unlike most posters on this board, I don't recommend Brigsten's or Ugelisch's (or Bayona or Marisol), but to each his own. I think my list will tell you the type of person I am.

    Clancy's
    Galatoire's
    Ralph's on the Park
    Tommy's
    Commander's Palace
    Dick & Jenny's
    Mandina's
    Emeril's
    Dickie Brennan's
    Adolfo's

    4 Replies
    1. re: Fat Harry
      t
      Tha Groovin' Gourmet RE: Fat Harry Mar 6, 2005 09:53 AM

      You're right...you like restaurants with apostrophes in the name!

      1. re: Tha Groovin' Gourmet
        g
        groovyman RE: Tha Groovin' Gourmet Mar 6, 2005 03:16 PM

        Too funny! Good eye, though.

      2. re: Fat Harry
        h
        Henry RE: Fat Harry Mar 6, 2005 10:49 AM

        Marisol
        Lilette
        The Grill Room
        August(sometimes)
        Pho Tau Bay
        Bayona
        Clancy's
        Rio Mar
        Drago's

        1. re: Fat Harry
          c
          college chowhound RE: Fat Harry Mar 13, 2005 01:19 AM

          from a new york college student who has made her rounds during time here
          Going to Brigsten's and Pelican Club in a month so they can't be on here yet. order is not very important
          1. Cuvee
          2. Jacques Imos
          3. August
          4. Stella
          5. Grill Room
          6. GW Fins
          7. Herbsaint
          8. Mr. B's Bistro
          9. Nola
          10. Palace Cafe

        2. i
          Ike! RE: groovyman Mar 5, 2005 08:52 PM

          Emeril's
          Bayona
          Peristyle
          Brightsen's
          Galatoire's
          Gabrielle
          Delmonico's
          Gautreau's
          Commander's Palace
          Uglesich's

          3 Replies
          1. re: Ike!
            j
            Jon RE: Ike! Mar 6, 2005 02:36 AM

            Great List!

            1. re: Ike!
              g
              groovyman RE: Ike! Mar 6, 2005 03:15 PM

              These are more the names I expected! People are throwing me more curve balls than I expected! Everytime I think I've whittled down the most beloved spots . . . .

              1. re: Ike!
                a
                Abner RE: Ike! Mar 6, 2005 04:21 PM

                Bayona
                Commander's Palace
                Gautreau's
                Galatoire's
                Herbsaint
                Brigtsen's
                Mr. B's
                Gabrielle
                G. W. Fins
                Pelican Club

              2. t
                Tha Groovin' Gourmet RE: groovyman Mar 6, 2005 09:47 AM

                I'm game...even if you did already mention my top 2 in order!

                1. Brigtsen's - waited for years to eat there, totally lived up
                to expectations then, continues to do so now. Currently
                debating whether we'll go twice on our upcoming trip.

                2. Uglesich's - making our final (and only 2nd) pilgrimage
                April 20 for a Holy Trinity of lunches. If Jazzfest weren't going
                on we'd be there Friday too. Their closing is the reason we are
                coming to town.

                3. Drago's - the only place we've eaten on each and every visit.
                Says it all except for 2 more words - charbroiled oysters

                4. Mother's - a Ferdie for lunch, an omelet and grits w/debris for
                breakfast, bloody mary's any time. YUM! And of course the ham trim
                deal.

                5. Joey K's - solid, non-touristy fave of ours for lunch. Possibly my favorite crab/corn soup version...even if the food weren't as good I'd still go for the biggest, frostiest goblets of Abita in town.

                6. Cobalt - best bet for Sunday, bar menu and beverages whenever
                the piano guy, David Torkanowsky, is there. Need to pop in this next
                trip to see if the new chef is up to snuff.

                7. Begue's - the best place if you're seeking a fine meal and demand
                an intimate setting. The place borders on empty more times than not,
                but the food and service have always impressed. Perhaps the most underrated spot in town...a fabulous brunch you rarely hear about.

                8. Palace Cafe - favorite of all the brunches. Commander's caliber
                at a better price. Their Santa Barbara, CA location rocks, and NO rocks mightier.

                9. Morning Call - more often than not we stay in Metairie. We love being able to drive a mile or so for the best beignets and cafe au lait,
                with no tourist trappings whatsoever.

                10. Old N'awlins Cookery - KPaul's for the pretension-weary and/or those on a budget? Not the trendy stuff, but the basics are there. I've never planned on going there, but every time I've wound up there over the years I've been pleased.

                1. j
                  Jess RE: groovyman Mar 9, 2005 10:17 PM

                  I'm making this list with the caveat that I haven't been to a bunch of places that I'm sure would be contenders. But, here goes, not in order, more by genre:

                  Commander's
                  Clancy's
                  Galatoire's
                  Arnaud's
                  Marisol
                  Brigtsen's
                  Upperline
                  Herbsaint
                  Irene's

                  That's 9. For the 10th, it's between Bayona,Gautreau's and Lilette, but I've only been to each of these once, and awhile ago. So it's a bit arbitrary, but I pick Gautreau's.

                  Places I haven't been: Peristyle, Delmonico, Emeril's, GW Fins, RioMar, Pelican Club, Dominique's, Cuvee, Bon Ton Cafe,La Petite Grocerie, Ralph's...

                  Honorable mention: Dick and Jenny's, Crepe Nanou, Jamila's, Vincent's, Mat 'n' Naddie's, Cafe Degas, Martinique, One.

                  See? It's too hard. Good luck with running the stats.

                  1. j
                    joedontexan RE: groovyman Jul 29, 2013 05:19 PM

                    1) Galatoires
                    2)Mr. Bs
                    3)Commanders Palace
                    4)Crescent City Steakhouse
                    5)Parkway
                    6)Mandinas
                    7)Bozos
                    8)Franky and Johnnys
                    9)Café Giovanni
                    10)Casamentos

                    5 Replies
                    1. re: joedontexan
                      g
                      Gizmo56 RE: joedontexan Jul 29, 2013 11:28 PM

                      Might have helped to launch a new thread, gentlemen.

                      Mixing your 2013 lists against pre-Katrina lists is odd (and "top ten" lists are problematic to start with).

                      Just sayin' ...

                      1. re: Gizmo56
                        r
                        roro1831 RE: Gizmo56 Jul 31, 2013 03:26 AM

                        This and the fact that Joedon has Bozos on the list and it closed as well as Franky and Johnny's

                        1. re: roro1831
                          h
                          hazelhurst RE: roro1831 Jul 31, 2013 01:27 PM

                          It won't matter much until Da Track opens but I thought Bozo's was only temporarily closed. I recall there were some nastiness, and landlord issues etc. Has the plug been pulled f'sure?

                          1. re: hazelhurst
                            r
                            roro1831 RE: hazelhurst Jul 31, 2013 02:44 PM

                            It is re opening. The people that own Mr Eds bought it.

                          2. re: roro1831
                            j
                            joedontexan RE: roro1831 Jul 31, 2013 03:58 PM

                            Bozos and Franky and Johnnys have both closed? Say it aint so!!

                      2. Bill Hunt RE: groovyman Jul 29, 2013 07:12 PM

                        From a person, who grew up near-by, and married a 3rd generation NOLA native, and then lived in the City for 10 years, here are MY "Top 10:"

                        Galatoire's
                        Restaurant August
                        Grill Room
                        Ralph's on the Park
                        Stella!
                        G W Fins
                        Emeril's & Emeril's NOLA (tie here)
                        Parkway Bakery
                        Commander's Palace

                        Runners Up:

                        K-Paul's
                        Felix's
                        Dominica's

                        Near misses:

                        Restaurant R'evolution

                        Hunt

                        4 Replies
                        1. re: Bill Hunt
                          j
                          joedontexan RE: Bill Hunt Jul 30, 2013 04:47 PM

                          Bill the Grill room is pretty great, and I don't think of it enough. I will have to make a special visit there next trip.

                          1. re: joedontexan
                            Bill Hunt RE: joedontexan Jul 30, 2013 05:50 PM

                            It has now been about 13 mos., since we last dined there, but were once again wowed by the food, the service, the wine list and the ambiance.

                            It was not always that way, as our first visit was anything BUT acceptable, and it took many years, before we would return, though we had a fully comp'ed meal, to make up for our experience. We never redeemed that, but did revisit, after several years - things had changed, and in a very positive ways. Since that return, I think that we have dined there a half-dozen times (through a few name changes), and have been impressed. Now, I do not hesitate to refer others to that restaurant - until things change.

                            Hunt

                            1. re: Bill Hunt
                              c
                              collardman RE: Bill Hunt Jul 31, 2013 11:35 AM

                              There has been a lot of turnover in the Executive Chef position there.

                              But we chose the Grill Room for our Spirited Dinner at Tales of the Cocktail as we haven't eaten there in almost 15 years and we liked the spirit pairings that were with the meal.

                              We were very impressed with the meal. Six courses of small plates with nothing too complicated. But pulling off 6 courses for over 100 people was quite a feat for the kitchen and the wait staff.

                              We do want to go back for a "real" meal based on what we saw and tasted,

                              Before the dinner I had an excellant Negroni at the 2nd floor bar and the Windsor Court Bar was named by TOTC as one of the 10 best choices for 2013 in N.O.for a Sazerac.

                              1. re: collardman
                                Bill Hunt RE: collardman Jul 31, 2013 06:07 PM

                                Good to know, and thank you.

                                It's now been about 13 mos., since we dined there, but enjoyed that experience greatly.

                                Last trip, we were at the Hilton, where we were at the Windsor Court the year before. Back then, we did the bar a few times, plus had a lunch there - great. We also like breakfast at the Windsor Court, even when we have a nice one in the Hilton's VIP Lounge up top. We will spend the $, just to do Windsor Court.

                                Appreciated,

                                Hunt

                        2. N.O.Food RE: groovyman Jul 31, 2013 11:52 AM

                          Blast from the past! RIP Gabrielle, Cobalt, Marisol, Uglesich's, Cuvee, Peristyle, and Begue's.

                          Lots of the same names today, though. I think I'd go with (in no particular order):

                          August, Maurepas Foods, Revolution, Lilette, Commander's, Galatoire's, Grill Room, Herbsaint, Clancy's, and Domenica.

                          Honorable mentions: Stella, Sylvain, Gautreau's, Bayona, Coquette, Fins, Annunciation, Patois, Emeril's, and lots of casual/ethnic places.

                          2 Replies
                          1. re: N.O.Food
                            j
                            joedontexan RE: N.O.Food Jul 31, 2013 04:22 PM

                            N.O.Food I have always enjoyed the sweet breads at bayona outstanding. pretty nice list really. But god I still miss uglesichs I feel lucky to have experienced theyre great food.

                            1. re: N.O.Food
                              N.O.Food RE: N.O.Food Aug 4, 2013 10:07 AM

                              Oops. Forgot Root. Definitely in the top ten.

                            2. s
                              shanefink RE: groovyman Aug 5, 2013 09:59 AM

                              Herbsaint
                              Domenica
                              Cochon Butcher
                              R'Evolution
                              Sylvain
                              Three Muses
                              Coquette
                              Brigsten's
                              Commander's Palace
                              August

                              in that order.

                              1. h
                                Hockey19 RE: groovyman Aug 7, 2013 04:02 PM

                                An amazing list of amazing places. I would like for some to throw out a few hidden places that fall under the radar. we love EAT. Couple of guys running around serving great food in as casual an atmosphere as you could imagine. And oh by the way, BYOB.

                                1 Reply
                                1. re: Hockey19
                                  Bill Hunt RE: Hockey19 Aug 7, 2013 05:52 PM

                                  I keep picking up recs. from trusted sources for Eat, but have not been able to work them into our mix. Maybe next time?

                                  While not really much of a BYOB guy, I can make that work too.

                                  Thanks,

                                  Hunt

                                Show Hidden Posts