HOME > Chowhound > Chicago Area >

Discussion

NY style pizza in Naperville area?

  • c
  • 7

I am going crazy looking for a place in Naperville area that serves NY style pizza. If I have to eat another pizza casserole, I will cry! Even "thin crust" is not really "thin crust" as I know it.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. A transplanted New York City pal of mine swears by...
    Botticeli's
    1669 Montgomery Road
    Aurora 60504
    630-898-3989

    4 Replies
    1. re: mirror

      Bless you. Thanks for the tip. :-)

      1. re: cheryl

        Let me know whether it meets your specs. I'll follow your thread here.

        As of the moment, I prefer very thin, very crisp pizza...

        Mrs. T's Chicago Style Pizza (excellent; not much salt)
        4246 Main St
        Downers Grove, IL
        630.963.0800
        (Spinach, mushroom, garlic on extra crisp thin crust)

        Uncle Steve's Pizza (excellent)
        421 E. Ogden Ave.
        Naperville, IL 60563-3232
        4 p.m. - 11 p.m. every day
        630.357.0050
        (Extra thin crust, whole-wheat blend available)

        1. re: mirror

          Vito & Nick's has an authorized branch in the Lemont Lanes bowling alley in Lemont. It's not NY-style, but it's very thin and pretty tasty. Cut into bite-sized squares. Flavorful sausage.

          Good luck, Cheryl.

          Thanks for the thin-crust tips, Mirror.

          1. re: Mugs

            I believe they have opened another Vito and Nick's on 30 in New Lenox(near Kohls in a strip mall). Haven't been there but friends that live near there like it a lot.

    2. If you can get up to Hoffman Estates, Garibaldis has the best pies! If not,Tony Saccos by Fox Valley Mall and Fiamme in downtown Naperville are both excellent. A little more like Naples style than NY, but I'll take it over Chicago pizza any day. I also hear that the pizza place next to Barnes and Nobles downtown is NY style. But they have limited hours.

      1. The original comment has been removed
        1. The original comment has been removed
          1. The original comment has been removed